Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

PCs refuse to shut down after Microsoft patch (https://www.theregister.com)

199 points by smurda about 9 hours ago | 212 comments | View on ycombinator

einsteinx2 about 7 hours ago |

> Microsoft says that entering the command "shutdown /s /t 0" at the command prompt will, in fact, force your PC to turn off, whether it wants to or not.

Wow how the tables have turned…the argument used to be you used Windows instead of Linux because on Linux you might occasionally have to use the scary terminal to fix an issue haha.

9JollyOtter about 6 hours ago |

The fact is that Windows isn't the cash cow it used to be for Microsoft. Windows makes up less than 10% of Microsoft's revenue now. Server and Cloud and Office 365 make up the bulk of their income now.

As time goes on Windows is going to be smaller piece of this pie and I suspect Microsoft will move it over to a subscription service or you will just have like 1000 ads shoved in your face. I made the move over to Linux last year and Windows will have to live in a VM.

jmward01 about 3 hours ago |

My biggest fear when getting a new laptop is that I won't figure out the BIOS fast enough to get it to recognize the usb drive I have plugged in and it might actually boot to windows. Now I will be extra freaked out because it might not even let me turn it off to try again!

mdavid626 about 7 hours ago |

Instead of putting Copilot everywhere, Microsoft could hire some proper devs and qa to avoid such problems, But no, MS employs vibe-coders only and fired the entire qa team.

the_wolo about 7 hours ago |

It seems to me that MS has started to vibe code Windows. It's so surreal that they managed to kill the shutdown program. I mean: this 1 simple program worked for 30 years no probs doctors hated this trick but idk

g947o about 4 hours ago |

Slightly off-topic: my PC always comes back to the login screen immediately after I manually use "sleep" from the power menu. I have to to the sleep thing again. Has anyone else run into this issue?

My Mac Mini M4 is on its way. Can't wait to stop dealing with this mess.

(Just this morning, I noticed that the login dialog for network drives, which has worked fine for decades, has misaligned text fields. I don't want to think how this could possibly happen.)

26d0 about 8 hours ago |

My mind immediately jumped to the "pull out the plug!" moment in a movie.

kmoser about 5 hours ago |

Maybe they could ask CrowdStrike to issue a software update to "fix" this.

nahBro 12 minutes ago |

what's new

shevy-java about 3 hours ago |

Microsoft really wants people to use other operating systems. This is quite amazing.

It does not affect me as I moved to Linux in late 2004 already, but I can't help but feel I would have to be constantly annoyed at Microsoft for abusing me and my computer.

hsbauauvhabzb about 8 hours ago |

I’ve killed a laptop by placing it in a backpack which failed to suspend. Based on the heat I assume parts of it cooked despite any thermal throttling. It’ll be interesting to see the damage a bug like this might cause.

emeril about 5 hours ago |

-omg, I always disable windows update -more harm than good unless you're in some more sensitive position

aeon_ai about 4 hours ago |

In recent months, with any computer that runs into Windows issues, I just take it as sign that its time for me to format it and install linux.

concinds about 8 hours ago |

The health dashboard says it only affects Enterprise and IoT. The KB note says “all editions”. Which is it? I wish El Reg did deeper reporting besides their snark shtick.

Also, 3/4 of comments here are already off-topic. Never change, HN.

hexbin010 about 6 hours ago |

They're probably just testing the waters. They already took away proper standby, because reasons.

okokwhatever about 7 hours ago |

It sounds like introducing minor issues today is the best way for Microsoft and Apple to push OS updates that nobody is asking for.

My two cents...

ArcHound about 9 hours ago |

I mean... At this point, what even would make people switch from MS? End users don't care, companies don't care so MS just gets away with piles and piles of slop.

tensility about 7 hours ago |

So, should we assume that they vibe-coded this patch? Sad...