427 points by shenli3514 6 days ago | 420 comments | View on ycombinator
porphyra 5 days ago |
nerdjon 5 days ago |
But I really do question how well Windows on Arm is really going to work out long term.
For Apple it worked because they were able to force the issue. If you wanted a new Mac it was going to be Arm and we all knew eventually (this year or is it next year?) Intel support would drop. Over time we have seen M series exclusive features.
Developers were forced to update or abandon Mac which gave users a great experience (with some early growing pains).
This is something that Windows will never be able too do. They will always be stuck maintaining an emulator and a likely large subset of apps only supporting one over the other. (also does this work the other way around with an Arm only app working on x86?)
This seems like a repeat of when it was not uncommon for games to only support Intel or AMD or NVIDIA or AMD. But worse since they are not both x86. Sure at least we have emulation but just like with Rosetta2 it shouldn't ever be the long term solution.
jmyeet 5 days ago |
- 5090/6000 Pro: 1792GB/s
- 5080:: 960GB/s
- 5070Ti: 892GB/s
- M3 Ultra: 819GB/s
- DGX Spark: 273GB/s (less than an M5 Pro at 307GB/s)
Memory bandwidth isn't everything but it will cap inference rate pretty heavily. Also, the M3 Ultra is for an almost 2 year old Mac Studio. It's widely expected that it'll be refreshed in Q3 with a likely M5 or M4 Ultra with >1000GB/s. I really hope Apple realizes what a market opportunity Apple has here.
The above shows just how good value the 5090 really is. It basically a RTX 6000 Pro with less RAM (and ~12% fewer CUDA units), which is a ~$10k card, for 20-30% of the price. This also demonstrates how NVidia uses VRAM for market segmentation. As an aside, the true data center cards (eg B100, H100) use HBM memory at ~3.2TB/s.
[1]: https://wccftech.com/nvidia-enters-pc-space-with-rtx-spark/
ThunderSizzle 5 days ago |
I can easily run Qwen3.6 35B-A3B with Q5_K_M with a 260k+ context window with some vram to spare. It easily runs probably 80tps. It took me quite a while to find the
Compared to GHCP Claude Sonnet 4.5 or 4.6, I have full parity. The wall clock time is faster for agentic workflows, and rule following is about on par.
With either, doing something kind of novel or obscure takes more hand holding compared to just generate a GUI or crud app. For example, trying to build an actual program that performs a complicated process correctly requires quite a bit of hand holding to get it to properly help.
Sure, it isn't Opus or something, but I think with the right harness, it probably can get close. I think most of the issues these days is the harnesses are lacking.
giancarlostoro 5 days ago |
hs86 5 days ago |
Looking at devices like the NVIDIA Shield gives me some hope that NVIDIA will be better than Qualcomm here. I just hope this is not a case where the OEM has to purchase X years of driver support from the chip vendor beforehand, and that NVIDIA will provide support directly itself.
eigenspace 5 days ago |
I've heard there's still a large backlog of both software problems, and hardware problems with the platform. The software problems could be fixed with time, but they'll still give a shitty first impression. I'd have thought Nvidia would just bury this and try again with a successor run of silicon with a new design.
This thing seems practically destined to just be a repeat of the Snapdragon laptop debacle.
BoggleOhYeah 5 days ago |
rnxrx 5 days ago |
ilia-a 5 days ago |
2001zhaozhao 5 days ago |
Tiberium 6 days ago |
Of course, DGX Spark is a miniPC, so laptops will likely be slower due to power limits/throttling.
comandillos 5 days ago |
https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/gb10.c4342 https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/products/rtx-spark/
PeterStuer 6 days ago |
minraws 6 days ago |
Around 2-3K USD something with a good GPU + CPU + 128GB of integrated RAM is just going to be an awesome experience.
Considering Mac options are north of 5K+ even on a regular day.
timpera 6 days ago |
aseipp 5 days ago |
airstrike 5 days ago |
I expect we'll get there in a few years, so perhaps this is Nvidia taking an early step in that direction.
In that case, this goes against Anthropic and OpenAI's business models. Which is a double whammy after Jensen Huang's recent comment about how agentic coding will only increase demand for software engineers, not reduce it.
So it also feels like a part of a budding shift in the competitive tension between the various parts of the AI supply chain.
thot_experiment 5 days ago |
boredatoms 6 days ago |
analogpixel 5 days ago |
rldjbpin 1 day ago |
knowing nvidia and their approach to consumer hardware (especially those on notebooks), i'd take a heavy grain of salt on getting a good deal.
also, they've been bad to their ecosystem partners, but now they've been able to boss them around into supporting them so far. i suppose getting anticheat vendors to finally support arm might be enough of a nudge for linux support? one can only dream
rsolva 6 days ago |
PunchyHamster 5 days ago |
It's just worse Strix Halo, as you are landing square in middle of Windows ARM problems
LatencyKills 5 days ago |
> "Our goal is to deliver unmetered intelligence to every home and every desk with Windows," said Satya Nadella, chairman and head of Microsoft.
Then:
> However, Ian Fogg, Research Director at industry analyst firm FDM CCS Insight said the change was "likely to come with a significant price tag" and Nvidia would be targeting "those looking for workstation-class performance".
So... not every desk with Windows.
ChrisArchitect 5 days ago |
A powerful new chapter for Windows PCs, accelerated by Nvidia RTX Spark
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48352693
Surface Laptop Ultra: Made for World Makers
nokeya 6 days ago |
jqbd 6 days ago |
cyanydeez 6 days ago |
bechmarks with DGX arnt spectacular for NVIDIAs software and CUDA lead.
wouldnt count on this being a price/compute challenger. especially with overpriced VRAM.
ocdtrekkie 5 days ago |
Eventually a lot of inference will get right-sized into something you affordably run yourself.
dvhh 5 days ago |
SilverElfin 6 days ago |
NVIDIA and Microsoft Reinvent Windows PCs for the Age of Personal AI
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48352705
NVIDIA DGX Station for Windows Puts a Trillion-Parameter AI Supercomputer on Every Enterprise Desk
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48352691
Introducing Surface Laptop Ultra: Made for world makers
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48352627
Introducing a powerful new chapter for Windows PCs, accelerated by NVIDIA RTX Spark
AI2070 about 19 hours ago |
Schlagbohrer 5 days ago |
In university a friend of mine had a large hardcover book she kept in her dorm freezer. I asked here WTF she had a big book in there. She said it was for minecraft - she'd place her laptop on top of it while playing. The book was cold but also quite dry. I wonder how well it worked.
hgoel 6 days ago |
dom96 5 days ago |
KetoManx64 5 days ago |
SilverElfin 6 days ago |
donkeylazy456 6 days ago |
easygenes 5 days ago |
mastermage 6 days ago |
atilimcetin 5 days ago |
Saying that I think this is product is kinda dead on arrival.
orthoxerox 5 days ago |
Maybe the Nth time's the charm and Microsoft+Nvidia will manage to make Windows on ARM a viable platform.
modeless 5 days ago |
big-chungus4 5 days ago |
lowbloodsugar 5 days ago |
What does AMD or Intel have here?
amelius 5 days ago |
zer0zzz 5 days ago |
Geekbench cpu bench leaks indicate they aren’t as good as m3 at single core even.
Will they support booting into a Linux installer?
ma2kx 6 days ago |
I'm not sure if I like this. Sure for a laptop this might be not a big problem but if this ARM ecosystem is a success it will spread to desktop computers and I fear we could lose the existing modularity.
throwa356262 6 days ago |
I think more announcements will follow soon from other companies.
perarneng 5 days ago |
tommica 5 days ago |
synergy20 5 days ago |
smcleod 4 days ago |
zmk5 6 days ago |
Floppyrom 2 days ago |
chris_money202 5 days ago |
tonoto 5 days ago |
"Introducing the NVIDIA RTX Spark™ Superchip. The fusion of NVIDIA AI and RTX graphics in a single chip redefines Windows PCs and delivers amazing creating, AI development, and gaming—on the slimmest, most beautiful RTX laptops ever and small, ultra-efficient desktops."
xeyownt 5 days ago |
Guess I need to postpone my gamer PC renewal to end 2030.
awesomeusername 5 days ago |
NVIDIA nailed it
agnosticmantis 5 days ago |
cultofmetatron 5 days ago |
lanycrost 5 days ago |
koolkao 5 days ago |
atlgator 5 days ago |
t_mahmood 6 days ago |
I don't think so.
This most likely be a winmodem situation, again
undefined 5 days ago |
bch 5 days ago |
More seriously, obviously a ton of work in an incredibly competitive space, and an incredible machine (without getting into competitive comparisons/minutiae). Was watching a techtechpotato[0] quick post pre-launch about "why is this even being tried?", which was also interesting. What an age we live in.
numron-dev 5 days ago |
locusm 5 days ago |
yobid20 5 days ago |
exabrial 5 days ago |
However, I'd jump from Mac in a Heartbeat if this supported Linux.
toksum 5 days ago |
lucamark 5 days ago |
sylware 5 days ago |
throw0101c 5 days ago |
pseudosavant 6 days ago |
renoir 6 days ago |
babhishek21 5 days ago |
seanalltogether 5 days ago |
officerk 6 days ago |
asimovDev 5 days ago |
https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2026-4-10...
> Over 100 Windows software providers such as Adobe, Blackmagic Design, Blender, CapCut, ComfyUI and OTOY, and game developers such as KRAFTON, NetEase, Remedy Entertainment, Riot Games and XBOX are embracing the new RTX Spark platform. [...] NVIDIA is partnering with Adobe to rearchitect Adobe Premiere and Photoshop for RTX Spark. [0]
> Gaming on Arm is finally coming of age thanks to the NVIDIA partnership. Native anti-cheat solutions from Epic and BattlEye are fully supported on the RTX Spark platform. Major developers are jumping on board, with Riot Games bringing League of Legends and Valorant natively to the architecture, alongside KRAFTON bringing PUBG Battlegrounds. [1]
Also, Nintento Switch is an Nvidia/Arm gaming device so many game publishers already have some experience with the combo.
[0] https://nvidianews.nvidia.com/news/nvidia-microsoft-windows-...
[1] https://www.windowslatest.com/2026/06/01/microsoft-builds-it...