Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Anthropic, please ship an official Claude Desktop for Linux (https://github.com)

362 points by predkambrij about 7 hours ago | 198 comments | View on ycombinator

aaddrick about 6 hours ago |

Hey!

I manage the unofficial build at https://github.com/aaddrick/claude-desktop-debian

Debian is in the name, but scope has grown to all backends, compositors, etc.

The main reason must companies don't publish Linux electron apps is fragmentation. If you're doing anything more than rendering a webpage as an app, it starts to get complicated. I've got a bank of VM's setup for testing, and I still need it up.

Retr0id about 7 hours ago |

If only Anthropic had some kind of automated tool that was good at porting software

splwjs about 2 hours ago |

What's the market for linux users who want an electron app so they can vibecode in a visual studio fork but wont just build it themselves nor do they want to clone and build someone else's repo

shanewei about 7 hours ago |

What do you miss from the Desktop app that the CLI doesn’t cover? I’m mostly on Linux too and have just been using the CLI, so I’m curious.

ok_major_9889 15 minutes ago |

I'm building a platform that does just that: https://yeet.cx/docs/

We give Claude full visibility into your Linux machine, with a JS runtime over the top for building tools.

nullpoint420 about 2 hours ago |

I'm still surprised at how many developers still turn their noses up at using Linux.

Like... You already use Docker and deploy to K8S... On Linux...

neilv about 3 hours ago |

OK, just please be careful how you frame what you're asking for.

For software development use of Claude, I'd be happy if the `claude` CLI executable does everything I need, within the Linux KVM VM sandboxes I create for the work, without a desktop client. The cleaner and more trustworthy, the better.

Also, for random interactive use of Claude for asking questions, I use it from my host desktop, sandboxed within the Web browser, and I want that to be well-supported. Someone marketing/product person at an AI company will naturally want to dark-pattern push people towards a proprietary desktop client, but that's one corner of abuse potential that we can still keep in check.

For agentic automation of my host desktop things and the things they have access to... no, thank you, the state of the art is not ready for that.

STELLANOVA 44 minutes ago |

This sounds like a really good test for agentic coding and something Anthropic should seriously consider doing as a proof of Claude Code quality. They could easily have agents built per Linux distribution that will run on every new release and do complete testing and publishing. IF they can successfully do that it would be a nice marketing as well. :)

taspeotis about 6 hours ago |

Personally I don’t understand why Claude Code doesn’t have a mode to make text green and characters come down from the top of the screen individually, like in The Matrix.

robrain about 6 hours ago |

Just one-shot vibe it for yourself.

Lame, I know, but you have to entertain yourself sometimes when the only thing anybody talks about here is ruddy spicy autocorrect and self-inflicted job destruction.

btown about 1 hour ago |

I find Claude Desktop on macOS infinitely better at managing RAM when you have 10+ or more parallel sessions.

(Some for different aspects of full stack features, some for managing specific client situations advised by the codebase and its tools!)

The CLI is not designed to be lightweight, and it’s easy to get into situations where every CLI session consumes multiple GB of memory alone - stack them up and it’s a lot!

And not all terminal GUIs handle multiple tabs well enough to see all sessions at a glance.

So on top of the plugin features, desktop is a really useful thing to have!

skeledrew about 7 hours ago |

YES! But also hmm, maybe not. I literally installed the unofficial build[0] a few hours ago, and when I started it and saw a bunch of Electron processes immediately trigger my spawn swarm detector, I just closed it. Don't think I'll ever touch it again.

[0] https://github.com/aaddrick/claude-desktop-debian

999900000999 about 1 hour ago |

Which Linux.

You build it for Ubuntu , people will demand fedora. Build fedora they’ll want Arch.

This is fine for FOSS projects where the community can fork and contribute, but as a company I can imagine tons of support tickets coming from Linux users who’s particularly DE/Distro permutation isn’t working right.

Still. An App Image would be nice

ljlolel about 2 hours ago |

I made a way to build Swift apps that build on Linux and run and look the same on MacOS https://github.com/Lore-Hex/QuillUI

I know Claude is electron now but if they made it native swift on macos then they could use this

himhckr about 4 hours ago |

Not exactly Claude Desktop but we have something more "generic" that works across multiple OSes (written in Tauri) - Msty Claw [1]. It also comes with a companion E2E encrypted mobile app.

[1]: https://msty.ai/claw/features

xacky about 1 hour ago |

Might as well say "Adobe, please ship an official creative suite for Linux", and will probably fall on the same deaf ears.

undefined about 2 hours ago |

undefined

ddosmax556 about 3 hours ago |

Anthropic, if you're reading this: I'm a developer trying to figure out LLMs, I use them 8h per day to do my work. Claude Desktop is a missing piece I don't have access to because I'm only on Linux! I'm happy with a simple AppImage.

zoba about 6 hours ago |

Also can you please make it easy to switch between my work and personal accounts on mobile!

bcherny about 1 hour ago |

Boris from the team here — we’re looking into it.

2OEH8eoCRo0 about 4 hours ago |

I love the dueling messages on AI

"It'll make software easy and replace all software jobs!"

"Sorry, a Linux client is too hard and too much work!"

majorbugger about 2 hours ago |

Yeah nah it's yet another security risk. There was an article recently about Claude Code desktop installing some browser files, it wasn't a hole per-se but doesn't make the whole thing trustworthy.

shmoil about 6 hours ago |

>> Anthropic, please ship an official malware for Linux

Here, fixed it for you.

pacificat0r about 4 hours ago |

How can they? They are busy designing agentic loops. They ship 8x more lines of code!!!

kentf about 5 hours ago |

Our app, Runner: Cowork++

Supports linux :)

https://runner.now/

predkambrij about 7 hours ago |

Cowork already boots Ubuntu 22.04 internally on macOS. The Linux execution path exists inside the product. What's missing is a published build.

bytepursuits about 5 hours ago |

I thought going into ipo they were selling the idea that claude is already build claude.

JSeiko about 6 hours ago |

Yes please! I think it's just kinda weird that this hasn't been done yet.

jeremyjh about 6 hours ago |

If you feel that strongly about it, why not write the issue description yourself?

rtk_asp about 4 hours ago |

"Sources for the load-bearing claims"

I no longer know if this is a real person who is simping for Anthropic and will be ultimately enslaved by Anthropic or if this is an Anthropic ad to have "proof" for the high demand of their services.

cyanydeez about 6 hours ago |

Why would they do that with their...checks notes...software changing AI?

trumpdong about 4 hours ago |

Doesn't Wayland make it impossible anyway?

dahkenangnon about 7 hours ago |

We are all waiting for it.

dstnn about 5 hours ago |

You're better off just using code cli

coretx about 6 hours ago |

Why dont you ask Claude to write you a TUI ?

JohnHaugeland about 6 hours ago |

just use WINE or docker

LoganDark about 2 hours ago |

"Linux" is not an operating system. One does not "just" release something "for Linux"

shevy-java about 4 hours ago |

Please don't.

There is already way too much slop.

d1553636d about 1 hour ago |

[flagged]

knightops_dev about 3 hours ago |

[flagged]

znpy about 6 hours ago |

That will come the year after the year of linux on. The desktop /s