Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Show HN: Jeff – A read-only CLI for semantic code review using Jev (https://github.com)

26 points by imalessandro 1 day ago | 5 comments | View on ycombinator

22c about 1 hour ago |

Interesting, but didn't the folks from System One specifically say that Jev isn't really tuned for these kind of "Has the rest of the owl been drawn?"-style prompts?

For example:

> Non-obvious code lacks explanation of its rationale

This is so open-ended, I don't really think you're going to get reliable feedback from Jev here, at least according to my interpretation of what System One representatives were saying.

tancop about 21 hours ago |

Looks like you only get a yes/no result and a confidence score for each file. No explanation or function level diagnostics. This is useless.

aidiveyt about 22 hours ago |

Worth saying how read-only is enforced rather than promised. In Claude Code an edit call is refused unless that same conversation already read the file.

RomanKornev 1 day ago |

This is great!

We can now replace Kolmogorov complexity-based metrics with pure Jev-slop code quality metrics.