Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

The Web Is More Than Enough (https://ftrain.com)

217 points by edward 12 days ago | 170 comments | View on ycombinator

simonw 11 days ago |

I like this statement:

> The web browser is very, very, very powerful software for applications, and the cost of accessing that power is going down seemingly every day.

It's wild how much easier it is to build things that harness web technology these days. I'm building features on top of three.js and offline storage and SSE and WebAudio and WebAssembly multiple times per week these days. I used to tinker with some of those maybe once or twice a year.

azangru 10 days ago |

> So take a look at Simon Willison’s new web-based browser 3D game, Battle Drones. He’s hosting it on GitHub. He wrote it himself. He’s not a games builder.

I checked the repo, and it is written by Claude. Does this count as writing it himself?

the__alchemist 11 days ago |

For anyone having a hard time following the comments or mentality: Someone explained in a HN comment a few weeks ago in a comment which has helped clarify in my mind: Web (And especially SAAS) developers make up a large portion of HN users. They use and love frontend frameworks, Node, NPM, and using web tech for many tasks, as a first line of tools.

Devasta 11 days ago |

25 years ago well over 95% of users would have been on windows, and there is no chance in hell you'll ever convince me that modern web development is as easy as Visual Basic was for whipping up UIs back in the day.

That AI is making it easier is happenstance, it makes generating UIs in anything easier.

palata 11 days ago |

I know it tends to be an unpopular opinion, but to me the Web is too much, really.

Many people (me included) like to complain about how systemd is trying to overtake everything, but browsers are a lot worse than that. Even if I can realistically choose my OS today, I have to run most apps in a browser. And the browser landscape is not that nice in terms of freedom: Google controls it through Chromium, Apple manages to force their users to use Webkit, and Firefox... is marginal.

More than that: I can realistically assemble my own OS, that is actually feasible. The one tricky component that I will need to integrate, though, is the browser. And the browser landscape, again, is totally controlled by BigTech.

Pushing for webapps is pushing to lock us into Chromium, controlled by Google. I don't see what's great in shipping a copy of Chromium embedded in a webapp and calling that a "desktop app".

I want control and diversity. The Web is far from there, and for some reason people love that.

Kuyawa 11 days ago |

It is, and I'll tell you my anecdote...

I am developing a game and right now got iOS, macOS, Android, web responsive, Rust for Linux and Rust for Windows versions ready. Six different source folders for the same game. It is exhausting even with the help of modern tools

If we could use just one tech stack providing native parity without drawbacks for all of them that would be the final achievement in software development, but I still think we are decades away from that

zanellato19 10 days ago |

This is the kinda of techno-optimism that I thought was done for. I don't believe in this anymore. AI enabling teams of one to do what before were done by 100s! That just means that a lot more people will be unemployed and that Anthropic, OpenAI and other big tech companies will be middlemen for all software being written, collecting their tax on everything everyone writes and making the richer even richer.

I guess a new generation of techno-optimism will be born, but I don't believe in the power of technology by itself being strictly for the better. And with the handful of AI companies that we have today, I have no reason to think that anyone's lives will improve from it, other than, again, the richer getting even richer.

JoshTriplett 11 days ago |

I run roughly six applications regularly:

- One browser window (with tabs)

- One terminal window (with tabs)

- Signal (not a web app, for good reason, though frankly I'd be thrilled if it lived in a browser tab anyway as an app being served to localhost)

- The occasional PDF viewer for PDFs I'm working on (anything loaded from the web gets viewed in the in-browser PDF viewer, but when I'm creating presentations or papers or similar, I have a terminal and a PDF viewer both half-maximized)

- Video player for local videos (mpv)

- Music player for local music (quodlibet)

galaxyLogic 11 days ago |

Web-tech is basically user-interface tech. Its super-power is that you can commit your GUI to be on the web, while the servers can be implemented with anything. The web-gui must have the most users world-wide, largely because all you need to install isss a wweb-browser and you get access to unlimited applications.

Any application can have a web-GUI, so why not have it, and they do, because that allows more people to use the app, with the standard conventions. Once you learn the basic functionalities of the browser (like back-button etc.) you can benefit from that knowledge with any app.

This starts to look like the good old OSI-model thinking. GUI is one layer, and like other layers it can be standardised.

galaxyLogic 11 days ago |

WEb-tech is basically user-interface tech. Its super-power is that you can commit your GUI to be on the web, while the servers can be implemented with anything. The web-gui must have the most users world-wide, largely because all you need to install isss a wweb-browser and you get access to unlimited applications.

Any application can have a web-GUI, so why not have it, and they do, because that allows more people to use the app, with the standard conventions. Once you learn the basic functionalities of the browser (like back-button etc.) you can benefit from that knowledge with any app.

maelito 11 days ago |

We're rebuilding Google Maps on the Web, and the Web only with https://cartes.app.

The main problem we're struggling with is mobile OSes' will to hide the possibility of installing Web app on our devices, and deactiving things like the vibration API. Not the Web itself.

palata 11 days ago |

> the multiplayer-over-audio thing is a first for an RTS as far as I can tell

Because it's fun, but that's all it is. I had a class at university decades ago where the goal was to transmit data between two computers over audio (and the sound was unpleasant). It's not a novel idea, it's just not something that should be done other than for learning or fun.

utopiah 11 days ago |

FWIW with WebXR it's not "just" 2D or 3D with WebGL, no it is immersive content (i.e VR or AR) on ALL platforms, including the very latest Steam Frame.

plant-ian 11 days ago |

It does seem that more and more browser features have become stable but that has been sort of drowned out by the AI boom. Even with millions of us monkeys on these keyboards, (now monkey simulators?), I still think there are even more discoveries to be found in web dev. You can get so much functionality with even the most basic hardware.

505050 11 days ago |

But unlike the year of the Linux desktop (any year now!), the promise of the Web as the app platform of the future seems to recede ever further into the distance.

rsync 11 days ago |

The web, circa 1998 is more than enough.

Most of the problems we have with online security, privacy, tracking, etc., are the result of the rapid, irresponsible and sometimes infantile expansion of capabilities of the simple web browser.

Canvas? Resolutions? Sound drivers? web-usb ?!

We’re giving up something very valuable when we “improve” html or “enhance” the browser.

xyzsparetimexyz 11 days ago |

WebGPU sucks compared to the desktop APIs. JavaScript and wasm suck compared to native code. Not being able to have threads for loading things like assets in the background sucks.

Yeah there's a ton of llm slop web games out there but anything serious is going to be a desktop application

mmahemoff 11 days ago |

Okay, but how is the title not “Web is All You Need”.

elxr 11 days ago |

Crazy to say when desktop apps and TUIs are becoming more useful than ever. No the web is not enough, even for something as simple as version control.

We're probably further away now from "web is enough" than we were 5 years ago.

BatchJob 11 days ago |

The web is a pile of garbage fronted by horrible software in the form of terrible browsers that is under massive, unceasing attack from AI bots that will render the entirety of it unusable over time.

It will be shutoff. And i wont miss it.

theK 11 days ago |

> for software people, being perpetually devalued is pretty novel

Hadn't really realized this is happening. Is it? Actually my experience right now is the exact opposite.

bookofjoe 11 days ago |

wdiamond 7 days ago |

the next revolution is robotics. and it will also become cheaper. I dont believe in communism, cattle meat will still be expensive compared to chicken meat. Most will have free chicken meat, but not for more kids. human race will shrink to a previous number and wont have any motif to grow again at least not because more intelligence or work force is needed.

mrsssnake 10 days ago |

By the Web we mean apps for Chromium platform? Because good luck implementing the "standards" now and making any new browser.

smohare 10 days ago |

[dead]

undefined 10 days ago |

undefined

150g2 11 days ago |

[dead]