634 points by casi 10 days ago | 328 comments | View on ycombinator
deng 6 days ago |
Freak_NL 6 days ago |
> The open question is supply. Finding two good used phones is easy; finding a few hundred matching ones, with healthy batteries and predictable camera behaviour, would take more work. I feel increasingly confident that it’s possible.
RaspberryPies and such are commodity hardware. You can buy one, two, ten, twenty, a hundred, and it just scales along. All of those devices will, barring perhaps a few dead-on-arrival ones covered under warranty, just work out of the box.
A used smartphone will have issues which can vary from device to device, so scaling that would take a very dedicated refurbishing setup where the quirks are ironed out (and the unsalvageable ones discarded).
I would also expect that you are starting out at the other end of the bathtub curve: with new devices you will have a few that fail soon after unboxing and using them a bit, and then they will run fine for years until you start hitting the other end of the curve and wear-related faults pop up. With old cheap phones you would start out at that side of the curve, so if you buy one hundred of those, a bunch will fail at various points soon after deploying them.
The cost of that unpredictable behaviour seems high to me. So much so that I wonder if it wouldn't be cheaper to buy a lot of unsold stock of a certain type of budget smartphone from two or three years back. Those devices could run fine as long as they aren't connected to the internet directly.
cdetroye 6 days ago |
I am by no means an expert at this, but starting of with a device on the Postmarket OS list and Claude, you can get a lot of these old devices working with mainline Linux and nearly all drivers. The newer devices are a bit harder, but if you go back nearly a decade, they're very easy to get working.
So far I have repurposed a Fairphone 3, Nexus 5, Galaxy S20, and Galaxy Tab 3.0 7". All of them (except the s20) with all drivers working compared to stock. Others have done a lot too: https://github.com/mlainez/awesome-nerves-systems
For DIY projects you can use host USB, or get one of the Adafruit FT232H type boards for GPIO pins.
yjftsjthsd-h 6 days ago |
Because the pi has a maintained kernel and a userspace I don't have to fight.
randomblock1 6 days ago |
Used phones are good for tinkering, especially for "display with sensors and battery attached" usecases, but there are still plenty of downsides. And unfortunately Linux on phones is just not ready for primetime, last I checked.
axegon_ 6 days ago |
bita_nidir 6 days ago |
dava96 6 days ago |
I particuarly think the economics of this are interesting, if you take the one plus 11 you can get one for around £200-250. The CPU is very capable and the alternatives are a PI 5 or N100. You get 16b of ram, a screen, gps, bluetooth a camera... the list goes on.
These devices could really shine as edge computing devices and I believe they are overlooked.
asmodeuslucifer 6 days ago |
siknad 6 days ago |
I guess laptops are way easier: more upgradeable and repairable, don't require unlocking mostly, battery can just be thrown away and it works with its native PSU. Just need to make sure power won't go out. And it is bulkier, though maybe less susceptible to overheating.
dividedbyzero 5 days ago |
StrLght 6 days ago |
1. Batteries swell over time. Replacing them is easy, but it's still harder than changing one inside a UPS hat. Most phones won't even start without a battery.
2. Software support will be awful. Maybe you'll get lucky and your device will be able to run postmarketOS.
3. There's no modularity, you're stuck with the full package. Don't feel comfortable having a camera or a microphone on a device with no security updates? Too bad, there's not much you can do about it.
Don't get me wrong, if you understand these risks, are fine with them, and Android devices cover your use cases — that's great, go for it! I just find SBCs with decent software support to be a better option for general projects.
pjmlp 6 days ago |
Even with the prices increases that the PI has suffered, there no systems of vendors like Tuxedo, or System 76, at similar price point, with ARM support.
stevefan1999 6 days ago |
herrherrmann 6 days ago |
63stack 6 days ago |
MacNCheese23 6 days ago |
nchmy 6 days ago |
It was vastly more powerful than the old RPi 3 that i have, and significantly easier to work with given the screen, keyboard, wifi etc...
louwrentius 6 days ago |
My blog article about this: https://louwrentius.com/the-raspberry-pi-5-is-no-match-for-a...
shit_game 6 days ago |
>I’ve unlocked and rooted the Redmi
Herein lies the issue. I don't know fuck all about phones. I don't want to. They are engineered to keep me out, and that is a pain in the ass I don't want to deal with when doing hardware work. I want to own something that works the second I get it and doesn't fight me the entire way. Sure, I could let an LLM guide me through it or even do it for me, but why bother when the whole point of the hardware is for me to fuck off and use it as a subscriber to the OEM and carrier? This is tedium, removed by further spending. Not to mention documentation - what bullshit is the OEM hiding in their board or firmware thats going to ruin my day? I'm sure that some of these devices are great for reuse as a self contained server with media and modem, but is my old phone going to do this?
I'm not gonna spend $50 on ewaste to try to do something unless I want to use that ewaste (old keyboards, old toys? :3). Old phones are a non-sequitur because, again, they're engineered to keep me out.
walrus01 6 days ago |
psilvia 6 days ago |
guestlistplus10 6 days ago |
Peteragain 6 days ago |
bahmboo 6 days ago |
In other words if the power goes out you need to physically be there to get the device running your always on stuff.
root9876 6 days ago |
casualscience 6 days ago |
schobi 5 days ago |
In the end this will need it's own microcontroller to speak USB to the phone and toggle IOs quickly enough.
Biggest challenge is to make the software universal enough for porting anything to that system - some won't work..
sgt 6 days ago |
subtextminer 6 days ago |
luis_valerio 6 days ago |
class3shock 6 days ago |
armcat 6 days ago |
nimitbhardwaj 6 days ago |
https://nimitbhardwaj.github.io/posts/hermes-agent-rooted-an...
denysvitali 6 days ago |
albert_e 6 days ago |
Some are bought with US carrier locks - never activated or unlocked. Any chance they can be unlocked with today's tools and not dumped into ewaste.
There are a few simple projects for home automation i have in mind but the rooting felt like a daunting task.
ForHackernews 6 days ago |
poisonborz 6 days ago |
nntwozz 6 days ago |
Nowadays I dumpster dive for old computers and parts to Frankenstein together what I can with Debian as headless servers.
One man's trash is another man's treasure, repurposed to sail the high seas.
Arrrr!
classified 6 days ago |
muhehe 6 days ago |
Vax- 5 days ago |
edude03 6 days ago |
Not to mention not all phones are hackable, they might not have the gpio or software you want or ecosystem (I’m quite fond of the Poe hats for example) and frankly if you’re buying a pi you’re obviously not the person who has the perfect hackable phone lying around or otherwise can easily source one
tropicalhunter 6 days ago |
Raspberry PI's don't give me near the struggle and I never dumbly signed a contract that I didn't really own the device I was purchasing (that I am completely aware of)
niutech 6 days ago |
evergreenokada 6 days ago |
alanwreath 5 days ago |
elxr 6 days ago |
But a new pi is just a bad deal for anything right now.
interludead 6 days ago |
b112 6 days ago |
No one cares if you have overpriced white earbuds or not for Pi tasks.
JulianPaul 6 days ago |
Jemm 6 days ago |
a012 6 days ago |
chr15m 5 days ago |
blocked_againnn 6 days ago |
999900000999 6 days ago |
ThrowawayTestr 6 days ago |
lovegrenoble 6 days ago |
InsidiousWombat 6 days ago |
Need to fuck about pretty much per phone model,rather than install Debian, unattended-upgrades and forget about device for 2 years
goeiedaggoeie 5 days ago |
esafak 6 days ago |
Havoc 6 days ago |
* Lithium batteries are a problem
* No ethernet
* No prebuilt images like say Talos
* Can't readily attach an SSD
spiritplumber 5 days ago |
ImJasonH 6 days ago |
You can get a cheap Tracfone for like $20, never pay for the subscription, and run termux on it.
rootnod3 6 days ago |
Sure, CPU wise an old phone can do the same job, but not the GPIO.
But hey, thanks AI delusion , even a fucking raspberry pi is now a purchase I gotta think 3 times about before pulling the trigger.
stn_za 6 days ago |
The point of a rasperri PI is to allow general, easy, and intentional bespoke availability of a fully programmable platform, where it also allows you access to low level, but practical means of acheiving home automation via GPIO etc.
I have 5 old phones in my cupboard, the most recent 3 of them have locked bootloaders and could potentially be rooted simply because of them not being region locked, while not gauranteeing me any real and complete support such as a PI would.
Nevermind even thinking as far ahead as GPIO pins etc etc.
At best, 1 out of the 5 phones might be able to eventually, and with effort/time and possible additional cost for extras give me parity to a PI, even exceeed the PI in compute.
But that is not the point. You know it. I know it.
Your post is not in search of an answer. You know the answer, you are the minority, and you know this.
You would not get an expensive PI if you had what you need from your old phone and skillz.
So why ask us where you already knew the answer...
It's because you are not asking anything, you are trying to show off and be dishonest by posing it as a question while assuming generousity by 'helping' people not 'waste money'
You are transparent buddy.
Yep, the typos are understood and left as is. Does nothing to take away my meaning.
babodabo 6 days ago |
nhod 5 days ago |
didntknowyou 4 days ago |
samsaga2 6 days ago |
l00sed 6 days ago |
spencerawlson 6 days ago |
arbor-group 6 days ago |
jessemhoffer 6 days ago |
undefined 6 days ago |
cnczeric 6 days ago |
ankur_misra 5 days ago |
ReDress 6 days ago |
elvisgodevelop 5 days ago |
alexcodebytes 5 days ago |
WorseIsBetter 5 days ago |
ankur_misra 6 days ago |
NorrisFByrd 6 days ago |
cedricddesigns 6 days ago |
undefined 5 days ago |
enoch_hou 6 days ago |
The boards are of course bigger, which I guess will be a non-starter for many. They'll also require active cooling unless you downclock them considerably. They often also require more power, although many mainboards can be configured down two a few watts of power consumption, depending on what peripherals and speed you need.
Yeah, it's more work than just getting a Pi, but given the current prices, it makes sense for me.