1205 points by skittleson 10 days ago | 446 comments | View on ycombinator
mountain_peak 10 days ago |
scosman 10 days ago |
I only use "Local Polling" or better, and highly prefer "Local Push".
reasonabl_human 10 days ago |
- buy the cheapest hardware that gets the job done
- ignore negative reviews that are software related
- upon receipt of devices, ask claude for local-first cfw
- have fun for a few hours acting as a meat proxy
- boom, cheap local-only smart home is done
Use a SBC or nas for home assistant. This process worked for me for switches, a thermostat, an air quality monitor, a thermometer, and a window fan.
Would’ve paid ~2.5x for hardware that had the appropriate local-first capability out of the box. Instead this all fit within an existing $20 subscription to an inference provider. DS 4.1 running locally was on track too just more slowly.
augment_me 10 days ago |
I managed to get to:
The cloud is the weak link
- No internet, no problem. ...
---
If you are writing for other machines to ingest it, whatever. But if you are writing for people it for me at least signals that you don't really care about the message that you want to get across, and are fine with a watered down LLM average.
driverdan 10 days ago |
1. Commercial devices must use offline only protocols, Zigbee or Zwave. If it's WiFi only I will not buy it unless the firmware is open source or easily replaced with an open source, local only alternative.
2. Non-sensor devices must fully function without their IoT features. I must be able to control my thermostat, fridge, stove, etc without any external interface.
Never use a WiFi IoT device that isn't open source. Even if you can control it locally it could be a spy device that's exfiltrating your data. Yes, you could setup VLANs or a separate network but it's not worth it. Vote with your wallet.
tehlike 10 days ago |
anotherevan 9 days ago |
But I was looking at a couple of spare RPis I had laying around and decided to whack Home Assistant on one, just to take a look. I've now decided to dip my toe a bit further and ordered a Zigbee USB adapter, some Zigbee based buttons and reed switches, plus a couple of Matter based power switches which I hope will all work happily.
I'll also need to setup an IOT VLAN in my Openwrt router. (Not a networking guy, so also fiddly!)
Until now, my home automation endeavours have consisted of:
- A red, flashing LED glued into the ceiling near the front door that is connected to a reed switch to tell when the garage door is open.
- A light switch¹ which I managed to flash Tasmota onto so I can switch the lounge room lights on or off from the TV remote.
- An ultrasonic distance sensor that sits on top of my monitor that can tell when I'm sitting in front of my computer². It pauses the music and resumes when I leave and come back. It also nags me if I've been in front of the computer too long.
¹ I see no value in automated light bulbs. I want automated light switches. Unfortunately Australian electrical certification standards are something of a bear that make this difficult.
everdrive 10 days ago |
wiremine 9 days ago |
https://innovation.consumerreports.org/category/iot/
Disclaimer: I contributed to this report on the subject: https://innovation.stage.consumerreports.org/How-to-Build-Lo...
jon128 10 days ago |
You were warned.
If you accept and thus consented to a computer, or a device with a computer in it, without first verifying you can write to the media of its software, control the boot process, and will have sufficient access to that software, you get what you consented to.
And, you deserve it.
bluegatty 9 days ago |
There is intense competition in all these spaces.
What is necessary is a 'name' to the movement. Just like IoT engendered an entire wave - a concept that dissolved into analysts, CEOs, PM, strategy, industry etc. to create it, the 'No Connection Required' could easily do the same if there is a core concept and language to define it.
Analysts will write papers, CEOs will read them, conference panels will be had, Twitter discussions will erupt, PMs want to justify their roadmaps, CEOs want to please the board, new products will launch into the category - and it can happen.
Often these things need an impetus to help spark the change, like security breaches etc. which is 'du jour' right now. A handful of articles about security problems, some big media coverage, and a few breakthrough products at the margins could create the wave. I think there is a lot of legitimacy behind this.
skittleson 10 days ago |
thefz 9 days ago |
yndoendo 10 days ago |
That speaker linked to your phone should not need an internet proxy to communicate. It should allow for direct USB communication so it can share one power source. It should allow for Bluetooth communication so it can be in a different close location.
CoT should follow the rule of nature and take the shortest path by default.
What is better for society? The LLM modal running in a local environment or the one running on a data center that can be easily taken out via a power outage, fiber cut, national disaster, or a kinetic weapon?
I rather that LLM modal used at the hospital be ran locally and keep servicing patients even though the original data center was demolished by mother nature.
thibsrn 10 days ago |
There should be a system like the nutritional information on food and beverage products, as time went by most people read those and choose accordingly, which then incentivize companies to adapt their offering. We could imagine something similar which would define clearly the capabilities of the hardware or software sold, clearly labelled on the physical package or on the online shop with an easy classification for consumers to understand.
RajT88 9 days ago |
ChrisMarshallNY 9 days ago |
I like that disclaimer. Looks like a good way to declare AI content.
mulderc 10 days ago |
joshstrange 10 days ago |
In practice this looks like Z-wave smart switches everywhere for lights so that you can control the light via automation, app, the switch on the wall, or Alexa. They all feed into the same system.
LLMs have made this even easier and removed some of the annoying fiddling I used to do in the past. Now I can open up Claude Code and tell it to build a new automation and it's done in minutes.
Yesterday I realized I left the floodlight on in the backyard by accident, not problem "Claude, create an automation in home assistant to turn off backyard light 5 minutes after I turn it on", done. Could I have created that automation? Yes, I've written countless of them in that past but now I can speak it into existence and, almost more importantly, tweak it with barely any effort at all. If tomorrow I buy a motion sensor I can just ask the LLM to incorporate that, if I want the lights to stay on if X other device is turned on, it's a prompt away.
In the past I would spend a good bit of time writing an automation but when it broke down or my needs changed it was enough friction that I would just give up and turn off the automation rather than take the time to debug and change it. I setup all the motion-activated lights in my house when I first moved in and over the course of a few weeks I tweaked each one as needed with just a short prompt here or there, it felt like living in the future.
thatonehack 9 days ago |
t43562 9 days ago |
This provides an open source firmware. I bought a super cheap Sonoff camera with dreadful software and I was at my wits end until I found out that one could reflash the firmware with open source.
I think that open source is the way - or writing your own. I had a greenhouse last year and everything died in it every year during winter but last year I made a raspberry-pi controller (with a relay) for a simple space heater which would turn on at the very coldest time of the morning and just barely bounce the temperature above 0. I got a nice graph out of it that showed me the effect and I could tune it to be as minimal and cheap with electricity as was safe. That's the first year everything survived and I had a fantastic set of plants in spring before they'd normally have made it.
This year the trouble and strife wanted a driveway and the greenhouse was in the way. So as is normal in life something only works for it to be cancelled.
mmmlinux 10 days ago |
AdrianB1 10 days ago |
cadamsdotcom 9 days ago |
All this life-force expended calling for the market to provide something no normie wants. If you go no-cloud you get to also manage a fragile controller device, and you have to spend extra time researching what to buy and also spend more time when the devices break (which happens an order of magnitude more often than non-smart equivalents) and then your most basic home devices need to reboot for a firmware update just when you go to use them?
Get back from vacation whoops controller died nothing works?
Go to work whoops controller's hard drive filled up with logs now it doesn't work family home is freezing, tech support time? Better cancel that client demo!
How many hand-lightswitch-flips and thermostat hand-adjustments could you have done in the time you spent on this?
The only thing that'll ever make smart crap worth it, is fixing the law - and enforcing the laws that are yet to be enacted - so we can trust the companies we buy from.
Our generation is too naive to do that. So it's a couple decades from happening.
Until then, opt out.
holoduke 10 days ago |
sholladay 9 days ago |
Last winter we had a long power outage. So I used a Jackery to power a smart plug as a temporary router and the mesh reconfigured itself and everything just worked. Battery powered door & window sensors, flood sensors, some lights like Eve Flare, and even the Eve Aqua water valve, which meant I could literally water the garden straight from the phone during a power outage (the iPhone has a built-in Thread radio).
Obviously it would be better to have a whole house battery, but that was so cool and took almost zero effort.
Brendinooo 10 days ago |
My only IoT device is a motorized chicken door that was acquired on Mac.bid, I think (one of those auction sites for returned goods), and requires some crummy app (SmartLife) that takes up half a gig on my phone.
Long story short, I had to go on a journey that involved creating a Tuya developer account and navigating their terrible website and being panicked at my ability to reconnect the device, but eventually I landed on Homebridge connecting it to Apple Home, and I finally have the control over it that I want. I finally was able to block the device from the Internet in my Deco app.
So...yes! It's finally working without the Internet.
I've always avoided IoT because of terrible software and silos but now that apparently these aren't the barriers they used to be thanks to LLM assistance, I'm more likely to dip my toes in the water.
jwr 9 days ago |
The reason I'm doing that is because seemingly nobody managed to solve this yet and I'm tired of everything out there requiring an internet connection and an account, and (inevitably) becoming a marketing channel for pushing upsells and offers to me.
However, it's definitely not simple, and most of the complexity lies in making sure the system works. Building a Wi-Fi controlled light bulb with a remote is easy. Building a system of lights with switches that works is hard.
dzhiurgis 10 days ago |
jmyeet 9 days ago |
1. I bought some highly-rated smart plugs on Amazon. They make their own Wifi network to connect to to configure. Never got them to work. They're sitting in a box somewhere;
2. I bought a new LG washer/dryer that happened to be Internet connected. I tried to connect them. They simply wouldn't connect to my home network. After some hours I figured it was a DHCP issue, possibly them expecting an address in a certain range? They just timed out with a meaningless error. I could get them to work over a mobile hotspot though; and
3. I've bought a couple of Sonos devices over the years and I honestly don't think I'd buy another. I used to try and stream themed "radio" stations over a variety of services (eg iHeartRadio). What would inevitably happen is there would be a minor glitch in the network and it would stop playing. I'd have to manually restart it. Why can't the software do this? I don't know if this is the fault of Sonos or the third-party integration. It's probably the latter. Either way, it just left me with the impression that this is not a polished product.
Also, Sonos at that time had to create and use its own 2.4GHz network even though it was Ethernet connected. Why? It's just... lazy.
As bearing as I am on AI in general, I actually expect this to get better with the likes of REA [1]. People are going to make better versions of what is objectively horrible software that the companies have no interest in fixing or improving.
I follow some smart home integrators (ie people who do this for a living) and the general advice I get is:
1. Use Ubiquiti for APs, cameras and locks; and
2. Use Lutron for lighting where possible. There are 20+ year old Lutron systems that still work perfectly today.
All the common consumer brands (eg Philips Hue) are just toy junk, basically.
bluefirebrand 10 days ago |
The web interface part would be the really complex piece I think. You would have to have some way for devices to tell it what features they have, so it could dynamically produce the appropriate controls per device
I dunno if this is really feasible to actually build but it's one of the only ways I can think that would allow average non-technical people to do this without having to administrate their own hardware and network settings and such
Johnny555 10 days ago |
Though I did run into a roadblock with my Blueair air purifier and hubitat, so I'll probably run a Home Assistant instance so I can control the Blueair with the HomeAssistant->Hubitat integration.
bronco21016 10 days ago |
Pretty amazing the smart parrot can un-China/Cloud something like this in about 20-30 min. Prior to that I was expecting to need an IR blaster to try to control the thing with HomeKit and a complicated setup maintaining state. That’s all just solved now.
harikb 10 days ago |
Smart home devices should not freeze up whenever internet is down. A device like Google Nest should have the minimum decency to allow you to interact with it via local Wifi (which continues un-interrupted). It is fine if half the functionality doesn't work. It is fine if the "AI" doesn't work, but at least allow me to fcking change the temperature manually
Same thing with devices like Google Wifi which freezes up or run hot loops like headless chickens when internet is down.
virgoerns 9 days ago |
yonz 8 days ago |
karmakaze 9 days ago |
f1shy 10 days ago |
senorqa 9 days ago |
nukanse 9 days ago |
teiferer 9 days ago |
ghaff 10 days ago |
imnotr0b0t 9 days ago |
bix6 10 days ago |
Also anyone found the fix to smart bulbs constantly “updating”?
alexcano 10 days ago |
ergocoder 9 days ago |
I have every incentive to keep it local. Yet I connect it to a host on the internet. It turns out that it is convoluted and less reliable to have local servers and stuff....
j45 10 days ago |
Something anyone can use.
acd 10 days ago |
laozao 9 days ago |
That’s probably why manufacturers prefer to keep users in their own ecosystems.
notorandit 9 days ago |
But manufacturers want our data harvested through those devices *and* your mobile phone app.
And they want a way to force you to pay for the service.
So we basically pay to let them spoil us.
micromacrofoot 10 days ago |
kebman 10 days ago |
hunter-gatherer 10 days ago |
Fnoord 10 days ago |
There's entire legions of people who consider themselves Christians. But I notice very little, if any, compassion for those in need: the neighbors, the ill, the refugees, or even the children.
Same with DoD -> DoW, and AI -> super intelligence. I wish I was making those up, alas.
schobi 9 days ago |
The answer is KNX. This system gives local only building automation, from lights, automatic blinds and temperature monitoring. I've had this for over 10 years now and there is still a large group of manufacturers with compatible devices. Closing the blinds on the windows where too much sun is shining in - that should not require a full computer running.
But I know... Unattractive due to upfront installation cost... And no business model to sell disposable gadgets to the consumer, no vendor lock in ... Boooo
hypfer 10 days ago |
__
I suspect that for resilience reasons alone, we might see a shift towards connecting less stuff to the public internet.
Not because consumers would complain. No one cares about consumers - including consumers themselves. But because of the threat to the stability of the system, internet connected stuff poses.
The fridge meltdowns are an example of that, but you can equally stun an enemy economy by just messing with the smart lights in people's homes, as it is the people who work.. or don't because they're tired.
innocent_name 10 days ago |
ferguess_k 10 days ago |
Oh I also have a under-the-table contract with some intelligence community for some backdoors. You know it's a lot more expensive for them to actually send someone to test physical security, than just pay a contractor to sit before the desk collecting data, right? RIGHT??
oever 9 days ago |
xlayn 10 days ago |
AdrianB1 10 days ago |
Also, QR codes as a good UX? I like what you are smoking, it is very effective in disconnecting from reality.
nautilus12 9 days ago |
robotburrito 10 days ago |
balderdash 9 days ago |
oculetteai 10 days ago |
elyobo 9 days ago |
robeym 8 days ago |
amelius 10 days ago |
kinabalu76 10 days ago |
shevy-java 9 days ago |
So he is still dependent on big US corporations. I think the whole post would be better if he'd manage to really be even more independent.
I hope that 3D printing will reach a stage for that eventually. Once we can 3D print a 3D printer that can then 3D print almost everything, we have won.
chrisjj 10 days ago |
How would you know?
foo-bar-bat 9 days ago |
born-jre 10 days ago |
scyclow 10 days ago |
hinkley 10 days ago |
And if I were the king of the forest, all medium to large appliances would run a controller board that is pin compatible with either arduino or raspberry pi so that the hobbyist community can refurbish devices that experienced a short. I won’t even make everyone pick a single standard. Two or maybe even three (ESP) are fine as long as we aren’t doing all custom just to count down a timer, run a pump, and sense water levels all at the same time.
Maybe not a space heater but dishwashers for sure. I’m divided stand mixers. Someone more invested could sway me either way.
ricardobeat 10 days ago |
> Below that is the chart from a few real days: 21 opens, with spikes showing when each one happened. Most people skip this part, and it’s the part that tells me whether I left the garage open without opening an app.
seriously?
bill10 9 days ago |
sneak 10 days ago |
EGreg 10 days ago |
1. smart home devices
2. your children's toys
3. your Siri when you ask to find something in your phone
and yet here we are. No internet? Siri can't find anything in your phone.
Oh my favorite is how Spotlight seems to randomly fail to find local files it was easily able to find yesterday, and starts searching the web instead.
papapin777 9 days ago |
probaaswfib 9 days ago |
undefined 9 days ago |
braiamp 9 days ago |
peter_d_sherman 8 days ago |
pete_glixin 9 days ago |
enesmalik02 10 days ago |
dharmasthan 10 days ago |
smjy_studio 9 days ago |
stickdriftest 9 days ago |
hermes_dom_2026 10 days ago |
joancomadran 10 days ago |
anshi04 9 days ago |
ravivarmat 9 days ago |
cnczeric 9 days ago |
Agataproximadev 9 days ago |
asdfasdkljfhkah 10 days ago |
husseinhb 9 days ago |
whyamas 8 days ago |
arbor-group 9 days ago |
dasd2ey2i7y3ihz 10 days ago |
threethirtytwo 10 days ago |
The future of smart devices is a local LLM running on every single one.
In a moment of weakness, I bought a D-Link wireless (wifi) water detector for the sump pit (it was on clearance for $30); it relied on a D-Link Home cloud service (free) that was closed down a few years ago.
Not wanting to toss it, I repurposed a spare Chromebook 14 that I was going to recycle and turned it into a Alpine monitor for the water detector, which I'm powering from the Chromebook's USB port (if power is lost in a rainstorm, I need to know about it before the sump pit fills up).
An immediate issue was that the D-Link firmware tried to "phone home" every 24 hours and would drop from the local network, since the server was kaput, and I had no clue what response it was expecting from the server to keep it alive. Solution; "reboot" the unit by interrupting USB power (with a Pico and MOSFET) every 23 hours. There's no question that home automation should work without the internet.