938 points by p4bl0 10 days ago | 212 comments | View on ycombinator
giancarlostoro 10 days ago |
nticompass 10 days ago |
I did notice that my domain kept working past the supposed shutdown date, but I let the domain registration expire.
I'm so mad now! I assume there is no way to get my domain/email forwarding back :(
I suppose I could try to ask the registrar, but I highly doubt they can do anything...
(Edit: I'm not actually mad, but it was annoying to have to move accounts from my [email protected] email to another one)
soupbowl 10 days ago |
Unfortunately I am stuck in commitments on a few of these domains and just had to eat the cost increases, the rest I moved to .com/.net.
.consulting was the worst offender.
troyrollo 9 days ago |
This meant a lot of domains expired. Worse, some entered the Redemption Period, where they can no longer be transferred to another registrar - the only option is to redeem through Tucows and they will not do it.
The practical solution seems to be: 1. If the domain is expired but still within the grace period, transfer it now; 2. It it entered the redemption period, wait until it becomes available again (up to 35 days) and re-register through a registrar like 007names to recover it.
Quite unsatisfactory on the part of Tucows (the biggest registrar of third level domains by far), to let all this happen and they really should offer subsidised redemption for affected domains in the redemption grace period.
derhuerst 10 days ago |
kwanbix 10 days ago |
mlefer 9 days ago |
For all the ones holding exclusive second level domains, just give them the second level domain. For all the ones holding shared second levels, offer a buyout and/or allow parties to negotiate with each other on a shared ownership structure of the second level.
Tepix 10 days ago |
Resistance is not futile.
toomuchtodo 10 days ago |
Success is possible. Well done to all.
sparkling 10 days ago |
slow_typist 9 days ago |
origini 10 days ago |
codexon 10 days ago |
padjo 9 days ago |
damoe 9 days ago |
zamadatix 10 days ago |
a1o 10 days ago |
greyface- 9 days ago |
listedb 9 days ago |
doublepg23 10 days ago |
Shame I didn't register on my lastname .name , I had thought it was a much newer gTLD.
zen_mike_eu 9 days ago |
bilalabdullahi 10 days ago |
exploderate 9 days ago |
ChrisRR 9 days ago |
walthamstow 10 days ago |
What the heck is ICANN doing in Bali of all places?
RagnarD 9 days ago |
xyst 10 days ago |
I was expecting for Verisign to take this to court, drag it out, and bleed the opposing party out. I suppose the judges that Verisign lawyers depend on did not get favorable re-election.
Ofc it’s probably something less nefarious, and boring. Verisign probably did some basic math and determined that taking this to court with their army of overpaid lawyers was simply not cost effective compared to just supporting 3rd level domains.
thbb123 9 days ago |
And one good aspect of this is that I hope I'll get less spam as a result.
asdfasdkljfhkah 10 days ago |
xydone 10 days ago |
calebio 9 days ago |
charlieyu1 10 days ago |
andunie 9 days ago |
A new decentralized name system is necessary.
undefined 10 days ago |
eks391 10 days ago |
kinabalu76 10 days ago |
bibimsz 9 days ago |
reliep365 9 days ago |
hoppp 9 days ago |
charcircuit 10 days ago |
k0morebi 10 days ago |
ferrule 9 days ago |
dasd2ey2i7y3ihz 10 days ago |
jon128 10 days ago |
not2b 10 days ago |
minimaxa 9 days ago |
Why do they care about third-level domain names anyway, not really much admin costs leaving them active.
Now you can join us in 2026 and work on your website design and remove that hideous lavender background color? :)
dist-epoch 10 days ago |
nekusar 9 days ago |
eloto333 9 days ago |
This was what I figured SHOULD happen when they did this. Allow existing customers to keep renewing, but nobody new allowed, if a tld frees up over time, reclaim it completely and sell it off.
What they were proposing should really be illegal...