299 points by Yorothegoat 10 days ago | 218 comments | View on ycombinator
gosen 10 days ago |
option_greek 10 days ago |
bertt 10 days ago |
I read this as: We'll build anything and everything into Claude eventually.
How does this work long-term? Is the new reality going to be picking an AI provider for all of your SaSS tooling, similar to Cloud providers for infra? Hopefully competition thrives.
FailMore 9 days ago |
I'm building https://smalldocs.org / https://github.com/espressoplease/smalldocs. My take is that the siloed approach of previous document formats is now redundant. The document formats were isolated because we needed heavy tools for humans to do the work. Now we need lightweight javascript predominately for rending as agents do the work, so document formats can be blended.
This means SmallDocs allows an agent to put together a document (the underlying format is markdown with rich custom rendering on top) with text, diagrams, a multi tab spreadsheet, charts, code, slides, etc.
Some example SmallDocs:
* AlphaFold 3: capabilities, evidence and operational limits (diagram, spreadsheets, charts, code, math): https://smalldocs.org/s/k9BtoviHg1eMsWzrSDBVZM#k=v0oIAbORXDj...
* Profitable growth can run out of cash (slides, spreadsheet, charts): https://smalldocs.org/s/nfCr0EEduLQwZAr0_v9ZR2#k=tv_BjigEYwt...
Kuyawa 9 days ago |
I really don't understand why people can't see the future, in ten years the speed at which AI will create apps will be astonishing. Any app, ask and get it done instantly. So if one provider (your AI provider) has them all why would you go around looking for the same thing if you already have them in one place?
I use DeepSeek because Claude never allowed me to play with it (living in Venezuela), but I know people that started with Claude just use it everyday and by inertia they won't switch, no reason at all. Just ask Claude for anything and it will deliver. Same for any AI. Retention is the key word, tools, apps, services, plugins, libraries, all in one place, everything.
AI is the new OS, the new browser, the new marketplace
ddaletski 9 days ago |
mmcconnell1618 10 days ago |
1broseidon 9 days ago |
AntonJidkov 9 days ago |
Next step, domains and email?
Also this differs from Claude design imo - which was too token heavy and not easy enough for a human to manipulate without prompting. Here, the human and agent user have a similar level of control.
tormeh 9 days ago |
qwerty_clicks 9 days ago |
sakesun 9 days ago |
paxy 10 days ago |
etoxin 9 days ago |
As a traditional company, if I had invested with a large team to build out these three tools. I wouldn't launch it with a short blog post. It shows how serious they are at maintaining them. People forget there are entire teams/companies supporting SaaS products. Not just the engineers that built them.
2001zhaozhao 9 days ago |
In other words they're able to create an entire ecosystem around this cost advantage and there's very little others (without their own models with higher cost-performance than public ones) can do about it.
darkmatriarch 9 days ago |
Build vs buy keeps getting pushed further to build, which is great for people in general but it feels like Anthropic is digging its own grave proving the only value it can provide is the model itself, and from what it looks like that's still scaling linearly and unprofitably.
htrp 10 days ago |
either fully commit to disrupting your customers and keep a walled garden or stop building in the space, this incremental approach will only ship confusion
kimseungyong 9 days ago |
We must consider that if tools with these basic features continue to be created, people will gradually start using them, eventually leading to a dependency on specific tools.
That ecosystem is expected to grow substantially.
yodon 10 days ago |
All Anthropic needs is to host an S3 clone and they become the default place to put all your company's data because they are the easiest place to analyze the data.
postatic 9 days ago |
_pdp_ 9 days ago |
ragdollk 8 days ago |
One of the lesser product releases as part of this announcement was Claude Meetings. If what you want from this launch is meetings turning into work for your agent without being tied to one vendor, we've just released bwat. It's a Zoom bot and app, writes each commitment as a card with the sentence it came from, and one button sends a todo into one of your sessions. It's free.
github.com/qoralai/bwat
minimaxa 9 days ago |
But the trade-off is a move from a bundled cloud service that is currently unlimited use into a new method of token-based content generation, which can be more expensive via API.
It appears to be a business model made directly from the 2000's with expensive mobile phone data charges and overages.
librasteve 9 days ago |
This project comes from a pure love of grids of numbers - and a deep sense that Excel has failed to keep pace with stuff like columnar data (Apache Arrow), fast queries (Rust Polars), proper number types, etc. so tbh don’t feel very threatened.
Feedback - good and bad very welcome.
the-chitmonger 10 days ago |
prtmnth 9 days ago |
ibenwandu 9 days ago |
onlyrealcuzzo 10 days ago |
These seem like natural extensions that I'm sure will be very useful.
brap 9 days ago |
Wouldn’t it make a lot more sense if they’d just let Claude connect to your Excel/Google Sheets/whatever?
Doesn’t even need an MCP or official integration at this point, if there’s computer access there’s access to everything.
nozzlegear 10 days ago |
tkdb 10 days ago |
sporritt 9 days ago |
cco 10 days ago |
nthState 9 days ago |
scottydelta 10 days ago |
cadamsdotcom 10 days ago |
Let's get Claude office, Claude auth, Claude notebooks.... maybe call it C Suite.
ajmurmann 8 days ago |
useruser125524 10 days ago |
ClaudeCloudServices
ClaudeERP
ClaudeCRM
ClaudeNeuralLink
ClaudeConsciousnessUpload
vcryan 10 days ago |
sheepseb 9 days ago |
mentalgear 10 days ago |
The better solution would be a uniform 'App Suite of the commons' (open-source) with a plugable/switchable data and inference providers.
adolph 9 days ago |
Seems like they are already touting agentic development with a core of Filemaker [0]. Moof!
rwmj 9 days ago |
walthamstow 10 days ago |
There's a reason my co still has Slack and it ain't because of its great features and bug-free app. It's because every written conversation we've ever had is in there.
haute_cuisine 9 days ago |
drdrek 9 days ago |
Ancalagon 9 days ago |
seanhunter 9 days ago |
franticgecko3 9 days ago |
mentalgear 10 days ago |
hbarka 10 days ago |
dogscatstrees 9 days ago |
WhatsName 10 days ago |
For one, maintaining a lot of apps and connectors costs time and focus for a marginal return. Also it burns relationships with everyone building on top of your API if they can be disrupted anytime.
AbuAssar 9 days ago |
ex1fm3ta 10 days ago |
tomaac_ 9 days ago |
chasd00 10 days ago |
latentsea 9 days ago |
syngrog66 9 days ago |
ActionHank 10 days ago |
Their competition is offering good enough models for vastly better prices and they are making products that their customers don't need.
I feel like there will be a site similar to google graveyard for all these AI+X products that OAI and ANT are throwing out.
arthurcolle 9 days ago |
IshKebab 10 days ago |
gregoriol 9 days ago |
undefined 7 days ago |
6x7 7 days ago |
undefined 8 days ago |
esafak 10 days ago |