Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

The Sicilian Citrus Family Tree (https://www.notesfromtheroad.com)

126 points by wmchen 9 days ago | 42 comments | View on ycombinator

chicken-stew 5 days ago |

During lockdown, I started citrus plants from seed (they’re polyembryonic and have a copy from the parent plant). I really wanted Clementines, you never see those in nursery catalogs, the sweet ones with the thin skin that falls off. So I dived into the literature to find out more about its history and … no consensus whatsoever. There’s one pile of publications claiming it’s a hybrid from this and that parent, and a diff pile of papers stating it’s most definitely not a hybrid but a mutation. So whenever I come across a poster like this I feel the urge to ask the author: why are you in the hybrid origin camp?

translucenthund 5 days ago |

There's one type missing, the so called Vanilla orange (arancia vaniglia)

It exists only here from what I know, it's a non sour orange that I believe it has been created in Sicily, or at least I haven't seen or read about it anywhere else. Very interesting

skyberrys 5 days ago |

This is interesting. I wonder where Australian citrus fits in with this? Do you know about finger limes aka caviar limes fit in this image?

madads 5 days ago |

Incredible work. This is fantastic. I've always wondered about the origins of lemons, and how there seems to be many varieties in my local supermarket but they're all just labelled lemons, despite being very different at different times of the year.

I was on the hunt for actual bergamot, as I love Earl Grey tea, and they've mostly sythesized the aroma/taste as oil spray's, and I wanted to make my own Earl Grey with real bergamot. Maybe this is the beginning of my adventure...

gus_massa 8 days ago |

Related "A ternary plot of citrus genealogy" https://www.jlauf.com/writing/citrus/ (HN discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47238272 (170 points | March 2026 | 37 comments))

easyThrowaway 4 days ago |

God, I miss the mandarini and cedri from my grandpa's garden.

Also all the different drinks you'd get from each permutations of citruses, or by mixing them. I can't find a chinotto, cedrata or mapo mapo worth its name anywhere nowadays.

chasil 5 days ago |

I wonder if any Sumo or Tangelo is grown there. These are in season and available in the U.S. in the early spring.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dekopon

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tangelo

somat 5 days ago |

Only tangential, but it reminds me of how the cure for scurvy was found, then lost. https://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm Basicly, the danger of using something you don't understand. It mostly works, Until it doesn't and you can't fix it.

pg_bot 5 days ago |

Aren't all of the citrus fruits native to South East Asia?

motionlessveloc 5 days ago |

Citrus ancestry is stupidly complex, and the generally commercially available varieties sadly few.

You may have heard of yuzu, which was a foodie fad a couple of years ago (and deservedly so, it smells & tastes great). In Japan, it's only one of numerous citruses, including dekopon (navel mandarins, occasional sold in Australia as "sumo"), tachibana, kabosu, sudachi, etc.

Hop a few islands down to Okinawa, and the fruits change yet again! Here you have shikwasa (hirami lemon), tachibana, tanibuta, etc.

An incomplete list on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_citrus

exmadscientist 5 days ago |

I love posters like this one!

Unfortunately when I try to shop for them nowadays they're all AI slop. Is it too much to ask to get a nice Encyclopedia of Pastries poster? Apparently it is.

margalabargala 5 days ago |

This doesn't actually answer the question. It lists the parentage of some other varieties, and then lists a bunch of blood oranges without saying where they came from.

Claude can make some very interesing, informative, accurate sites to present information. This isn't an example.