Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Seagate's new hybrid drive raises some old questions (https://arstechnica.com)

105 points by PaulHoule 9 days ago | 64 comments | View on ycombinator

linsomniac 6 days ago |

I've often wondered why there aren't any (that I'm aware of anyway) Linux hierarchical storage managers (HSM). I realize they are typically used in big iron with things like tape as the base level of storage, but especially when it looked like Optane was going to be a thing it seemed like spinning<->SSD<->Optane<->RAM could be a huge performance opportunity. Though, I guess that's a "layering violation"... Honestly, at this point we've gone almost entirely SSD except for our ZFS backup servers, and that layering violation already has an SSD and RAM cache in it...

dabinat 6 days ago |

> …comes in 8TB ($699) or 20TB ($899) HDD configurations—neither of which includes the required SSD.

The 8TB version seems like very poor value for money. For comparison, Amazon is selling 24 TB Seagate Exos drives for $799.

robotnikman 6 days ago |

I used to have one of their 2.5in hybrid drive in a laptop. Seemed to work well for games. But once SSD's became cheap the tech was not longer worth it. Also, 2.5in drives topped out at 2TB of storage, while NVME and 2.5 Sata SSD's continued to grow in size.

Dylan16807 5 days ago |

> According to data collected by Tom’s Hardware, some solid-state drives now cost two to three times their historic lows, and it’s not just SSDs.

The 1-2TB TLC drives that were the best deal before are more like 4x their lowest price.

Grombobulous 5 days ago |

If you have to provide your own SSD, I would think that the target audience already knows how to set up a cache disk in their NAS solution of choice, and they'd save a bunch of money that way.

thisislife2 4 days ago |

I miss the WD Black2 Dual Drive - it was a hybrid 2.5 drive that had both SSD (120gb) + HDD (1tb) in it you could use it either as a fusion drive (where the SSD drive would be used for caching) or two separate drives. It was great for laptops or mini PCs that have limited disk bays. I do like that Seagate has made the SSD part replaceable with these new hybrid drives, but wonder if they provide the driver to use it as two separate drives?

Eric_WVGG 5 days ago |

Apple’s “Fusion Drives” were great!

I had a 2009-ish 17" Macbook Pro (the Cafeteria Tray), removed the optical drive and replaced it with an SSD, then reformatted the whole thing using a bit of voodoo to turn it into an unsupported Fusion Drive. Gave it to my father when I upgraded a few years later and forgot about it. One day he took it in to the Genius Bar for some kind of service, drew a whole crowd of Apple Store employees who had never seen a Macbook modified under-the-hood before…

mikae1 6 days ago |

> According to PCServerParts, a Seagate Exos 24TB drive that sold for $298.99 in the summer of 2025 was priced at $699.99 by August 2026.

Spoiled Americans. That drive is $1393 (14160 SEK) here in Sweden now[1]. A year ago it was 4160 SEK...

Three times as expensive in 12 months seems true for most drives.

I'm just praying no drives in my NAS are going to crap out anytime soon...

[1] https://www.prisjakt.nu/produkt.php?p=12519318

kotaKat 6 days ago |

"According to Seagate’s press release, the Alkemi intelligent storage platform takes a different approach. Where Apple’s Fusion Drives used tiering managed by macOS, Alkemi manages the storage pool directly from the enclosure."

Soooooo... it's gonna be like the old days of Drobo, where a little VXworks box did all the heavy lifting of BeyondRAID and transparently exposed it as a big ol' block device to your OS? Good times.

GaryBluto 5 days ago |

It's neat, but isn't it more of mixed-medium RAID-like setup than a "hybrid" drive? Especially since the SSD isn't included.

larodi 5 days ago |

They are taking the opportunity to still some more of older tech while demand lasts and it can well last into the next decade.

liquid_thyme 6 days ago |

Isn't this (architecture) basically like a NAS w/ SSD caching ? (w/ the caveat of not being on the network obviously)

debrisontrack 6 days ago |

The only relevant question seems to be "will these prices ever go down?"

kogasa240p 5 days ago |

Hybrid drives are back? Thought they faded into obscurity a decade ago but it makes sense that they're returning.

>Users will have to bring their own SSD

uhhhhhhhh