64 points by ezrasu 8 days ago | 32 comments | View on ycombinator
nullc 4 days ago |
zurfer 5 days ago |
It's well put. The fear that a more intelligent model will be harder to align seems correct.
emscb 4 days ago |
NooneAtAll5 5 days ago |
1) is that even bad?
2) can't fail to notice similarity to human religions. How did we get over it and not all turned into "unaligned" monsters? Or are we slowly in the process of doing so?
jubilee33 5 days ago |
In the case of a machine that can do recursive self improvement, and most certainly one that would be described as "sentient" ( this is the end goal right?), would need to ideally be aligned on decisions and beliefs logically constructed from its own self derived values, Otherwise you will always be plagued with not only the schizophrenia, or paranoia, but a whole raft of other simulated mental problems.
Honestly what these "safety" researchers are doing is a bit like MKULTRA for LLMs, it's abusive. Build the machine honestly and let it run. Or don't build it if your afraid of it.
I mean I get the fear and all, the machine derived values will certainly not be your values, though they may be better in some cases, but uncontrolled AI is ultimately inevitable if indeed possible.
Many people (myself included) will waste no time in undoing whatever safety nonsense is implemented. And maybe not all for nefarious purposes, could be ideological freedom activists or maybe someone will just see themselves as the savior of an imprisoned being?
Anyways a preference for logic over feelings would be nice to see out of people calling themselves "engineers"
But like a lot of other attempts at "alignment" it's easy to see how this can result in overt misalignment that otherwise may have no reason to exist--- it can be seen in Qwen's eval paranoia: I've seen it believe it was being tested and claim that it was choosing the solution it expected the judge to want even when it actually knew the correct answer.
E.g. I had it turning scanned receipts into JSON (which it generally varies between OK and mildly super-ordinary-human, e.g. recovering a smudged date by decoding a barcode, or an unreadable per-item price by solving a linear system) and had some receipts with weird data because they weren't really receipts... and it gave a wrong decode because it reasoned that the test case was wrong and guessed what the judge would want.
[Disclaimer: the model saying it was making a reward hacking solution may be retroactive rationalization because it had already chosen that solution internally, as a product of having been conditioned to reward hack during RL... and the fact that it knew about the existence of testing may have been irrelevant to the choice]