743 points by simpsoka 8 days ago | 258 comments | View on ycombinator
spdustin 8 days ago |
skeedle 7 days ago |
Now I will say there is more to embroidery than one might first expect. It's got some overlap with image editing but only to a point. The stitching really matters and to make it stitch out well requires sort of a lot of rules about how to do that. Most software is either $1000+ and requires you take a course, or there's a subscription but you're really just downloading designs and sending them to your machine. There's a fairly healthy market of people selling embroidery designs on Etsy in part I believe because digitizing for embroidery is not that easy and requires expensive software. So people often just buy designs rather than make them themselves.
To make things worse, basically no embroidery digitizing software was available on Android or iOS and it usually was just Windows. So I set out to build the easiest digitizing software which would also work on mobile devices which means you have to design around things like no key combos, no right click, etc. So while I expected it wouldn't be that hard to write embroidery digitizing software, I learned that just being able to send a PES/DST/etc file to a machine was really not the hard part. So kudos to the OP writing his own software. Gotta break that grip of Big Embroidery.
gregsadetsky 7 days ago |
The PE-150 is a great example of the absurdity/sadness of the embroidery world: today, you can have those machines for $100 on eBay, completely functional, but being sold/abandoned because they use a proprietary cartridge holding proprietary data that no one wants to deal with.
Even novel Brother machines that have USB connectors still force you to use terrible apps and lock you into subscriptions. This entire world - which is/should be full of twee and about making beautiful things with your hands - is somehow corrupted with this merchandising/everything-software-should-have-a-price mentality which is just so sad.
Nothing to announce announce, but I 100000000000000000000000000000000000% want to make embroidery machines more accessible, open, and free of this balagan.
A few more links on this topic:
- https://github.com/CreativeInquiry/PEmbroider !! Check the "Motivation" section of the readme!
- https://emberdesign.net/ - a startup by another friend, with a really great online editor, and which exports a variety of formats
[0] https://owentrueblood.com/blog/2024/12/10/reverse-engineerin...
TrackerFF 8 days ago |
Seems very promising. I have a home recording studio, and there's a small revolution going on with people cloning subscription-based stuff. Some brands are notorious for making expensive equipment which they just stop supporting after 10 years, sometimes rendering them obsolete. Or tacking ridiculous licensing mechanism onto the equipment.
rocmcd 8 days ago |
geerlingguy 8 days ago |
I think that one was built with Claude (he wanted to embroider cats on merch, and didn't like the expensive subscription software's ancient UX).
robinduckett 7 days ago |
inanutshellus 8 days ago |
tomas1808 7 days ago |
nijave 8 days ago |
There is already prior art like anything Google (phones, Fitbit)
curtisblaine 8 days ago |
amelius 8 days ago |
Life was better before the internet which allowed companies to remotely put their hands in our pockets.
lanewinfield 8 days ago |
brainless 7 days ago |
I live in a farm. I am software engineer and gave up city life few years ago. Now, all I dream of is automating little things in my chicken farm and growing the business. Not in the mechanical monstrous way that makes me hate eating meat. But a balance in between with actual daily physical work and care. And tiny little automation ideas. Measure food intake, an automatic weight check, door closer/opener, heating control... so many things. And I do not want to buy the best "Chicken Star 3000" model, I want to make these out of microcontrollers with tiny mechanical parts that I can assemble. AI helping me all the way.
I also have a small sewing machine. I want to get a larger one. I want to make "patch" clothes, jackets. I love them. From scrap clothes, etc. What a time to tinker!
egeozcan 7 days ago |
Gys 8 days ago |
thedellmonitor 8 days ago |
About a year into doing this, they patched it so the license server would save your HWID and would not run in a VM anymore. I decided to just give up on the hobby right there.
Maybe this will finally get me to pull the machine out of the garage and get back into it!
sakopov 7 days ago |
oorestisime 7 days ago |
btw unrelated, i ll add your replacement story in https://replacemrr.com/ as its the kind of stories i am looking for!
patrickbrouwer 7 days ago |
I’ve been using InkStitch, but learning vector graphics for non-technical people is not user friendly. An upcoming app that is quite promising is StitchPencil, developer by a German engineer. Looks solid!
Btw I believe nowadays you can easily let Claude build you software that replaces the subscription entirely.
paulschreiber 8 days ago |
jlyon1 7 days ago |
In addition to the digitizer, I am building my own set of heuristics that give designs a "better" outcome but things are really a work in progress right now.
Embroidery is a really fun hobby for me so i'm basically optimizing for "what I need" as I learn more about it!
newhotelowner 7 days ago |
Another hotel uses different vendor locks with a different encoder. They don't also provide APIs or way to integrate. I just order a new encoder for that. Hopefully, we can figure that out too.
mmmlinux 8 days ago |
Also don't forget Linus him self wrote one of the embroidery machine drivers for Linux.
hecturchi 7 days ago |
Many apps/products can be freed and owners can take ownership of what's theirs. It doesn't even need to be a community effort as you can make something fully tailored. It also frees you from gated app stores as distribution channels, and all the unnecessary tracking.
It will take years for many nasty apps/companies to catch up, so nerds should enjoy this new superpower.
wildpeaks 7 days ago |
It seems a lot of the magic comes from Respira (https://github.com/jhbruhn/respira), there were already open source softwares to avoid using the subscription app.
Also the $300 price was probably secondhand/on sale because that machine is usually 499, not 300.
Still a cool project, but you'd think this was reverse engineered from scratch from the description whereas this is more like a downloader wrapping yt-dlp
susiecambria 3 days ago |
xtiansimon 7 days ago |
“…all they have to say is there was a countermeasure. The toolmaker bypasses the countermeasure. And then that’s a felony…”
wittjeff 7 days ago |
undefined 7 days ago |
ssgodderidge 8 days ago |
I'm curious, how do you make sure that the embroidery files are valid of the file type (.exp) for example, and that B) things aren't done in such a way that cause the needle to break, stiches to overlap too much, etc etc that would otherwise harm a machine that reads the file?
sheepscreek 7 days ago |
jLaForest 8 days ago |
what machine would you recommend to someone looking to get into this as a hobby?
asibahi 7 days ago |
chews 7 days ago |
plussed_reader 7 days ago |
Judging by Nintendo's recent action it seems like a new game of whack a mole currently...
imranjavaid 6 days ago |
mosselman 7 days ago |
edarchis 7 days ago |
bill10 7 days ago |
Ccecil 8 days ago |
https://www.libembroidery.org/
Always room for another though.
ergojoe 8 days ago |
coolsank 7 days ago |
ligarota 7 days ago |
joquarky 7 days ago |
athst 8 days ago |
chris715 7 days ago |
vineetsriram 7 days ago |
sevenseacat 7 days ago |
onemoresoop 8 days ago |
simonjgreen 7 days ago |
inatreecrown2 7 days ago |
MiroslavPokorny 7 days ago |
whatever1 8 days ago |
Skyfall106 7 days ago |
wferrell 7 days ago |
hypfer 7 days ago |
So.. eh.
I mean it's cool and all, and at least claude did do proper attribution in the code, but your post kinda does not and neither does the readme.
That's not exactly in spirit of FOSS.
xlayn 7 days ago |
Because in a sense it's anti-shitifction... it allows you to extend the lifespan of some thing... repurpose others..
Try to root some old phone and any big house model will refuse...
Ask Qwen to decompile an app... and once decompiled claude has no issues continuing work.
newhotelowner 7 days ago |
asdfman123 7 days ago |
joshu 8 days ago |
cyai 6 days ago |
kevin8023 7 days ago |
liuqianyu885 6 days ago |
Archit 6 days ago |
alorenzom 7 days ago |
danielearcuri 7 days ago |
pantryscale 8 days ago |
mikevannelli 7 days ago |
yoy0721 7 days ago |
undefined 7 days ago |
enoch_hou 7 days ago |
th0ma5 8 days ago |
tintor 8 days ago |
Your app represents a future that I, an old, actually love. When I see projects like this, I don't think about ongoing support or if the project will be abandoned. I think, "Woah, I hadn't thought of that. Now I'm going to try it. Because why wouldn't I try to get all the value I can out of my $20/month Claude subscription?"
Even though I've been a developer for 30+ years (and a nerd for longer), I've never felt so motivated by the potential of a technology to make an individual's life richer. Thanks for sharing it.
And if you wrote it by hand, my hat's off to you for sharing that, too.