495 points by helloplanets 7 days ago | 752 comments | View on ycombinator
barbariangrunge 7 days ago |
Overdrivr 6 days ago |
fuussssip 7 days ago |
He regularly denies the use of new technology that is genuinely useful, and is a fairly conservative dude (I mean in the non-political sense. I do not know his politics. He may be a conservative politically as well, but that would be independent of the point I'm making.)
I've worked with many engineers at many different scopes. Big companies, indie darlings, web services, games. Games is always the last to adapt, always the last to think that anything they didn't invent is worth their time. Blow has experience in that domain, and is colored by working in it, but I don't think he knows what's happening on the bleeding edge very well.
_aavaa_ 7 days ago |
And I agree, it’s because organizations and people haven’t changed (yet, if you’re being positive) what it is they’re optimizing for and how they do work. AI gives you more of what you want and gives it faster, that doesn’t on its own change the culture or goals of a company.
Animats 6 days ago |
What will next year bring?
dustbunny 6 days ago |
Jon Blow doesn't have sufficient experience in using LLMs to talk about it.
This is evidenced by his focus on individual anecdotes on AIs failure to deliver something.
I would love to talk to him about this as I have fairly concrete evidence of the insane productivity gains one can get with smart AI usage.
Also would love to hear Ryan J Fleury talk about Tim Sweeneys statements on LLMs.
How long until RADDBG is primarily used by Claude? How long until Ryan is told he must support this? How long until he claims he was never against it?
jazzypants 6 days ago |
tracerbulletx 7 days ago |
dandersch 7 days ago |
pansa2 6 days ago |
The latter is why managers love AI - and the former is why the general public hates it.
Dave_Rosenthal 6 days ago |
Not only is developing complex software intrinsically harder, there is way less (and way less public) training data for the code behind these types of systems. Probably the biggest wins right now for big dominant software systems are things like porting, paying down technical debt, raising efficiency, etc.; these are all tasks where the behavioral spec is pretty solidly defined by the existing code.
The software that is getting accelerated the most is the "not too big and complex software": web sites for niche things, mini games, ad-hoc data analysis, solving little specific problems with scripts, etc. But most of these kind of things are used by not too many people.
So, averaged over software a random person uses on a random minute, AI has not solved coding. But averaged over all the long tail of distinct (and often fairly simple) software people are building, it pretty much has.
klevo 6 days ago |
rafaelRiv 7 days ago |
ozgrakkurt 6 days ago |
Running clang-scan-deps on some files takes as much time as compiling the file.
I am writing a build system that uses clang and this is just so insane if you compare it to how much other things take.
Doing the same version command on gcc takes 700 micro seconds. Even this is super slow imo but gives a perspective maybe.
leecommamichael 6 days ago |
- AI can reason (with caveats)
- AI is impressive technology
- AI can code "leaf functionality" pretty well
- Modern models don't really make dumb flubs as much
He's saying modern programmer culture has turned all programming problems into "leaf functionality," the stuff which interfaces with OSes, libraries, and web services. He's saying that is the architectural decision which continues to plague us.
He's saying the way we approach "decoupling" is damaging the quality of the greater connected system in terms of correctness and performance. For example, I think most people here can all relate to the idea that lots of things are network requests which just didn't need to be, and so can fail when they don't fundamentally have to.
He's skeptical that AI can make & maintain a complex system which is correct and performs well. He gives the example of having AI generate a script to operate on an Excel sheet. That's using the API boundaries and systems we have today. He states that AI is pretty good at that, but you have to understand that; that's not what the word "programming" means to him.
In my opinion, if you can do system design, you can probably use AI to speed up that the process of implementing said system. That, I think is the more interesting discussion they could've had, because it scratches at what parts of that kind of programming are essential to be done by a person, which I assume isn't 0%. It's for this reason that I still code by hand as much as I do. How do people learn system-design? How do people learn the parts of programming which are necessary to use LLMs well?
galkk 6 days ago |
I sometimes wonder if I'm a victim of gel-mann amnesia when I listen to his opinions on gamedev too :(
brainzap 7 days ago |
CrimsonCape 7 days ago |
So what argument is there to be bearish on it when it is in infancy? If you just want to go with "the quality sucks" well, sure, but it sucked a lot more two years ago, which means it sucks a lot less today, and in 2 more years, it will suck even less. I'd use different adjectives personally, cause I find it's pretty decent now (opus 5.5) and i'm pretty optimistic about what comes next.
hdhjsjja 6 days ago |
sd9 6 days ago |
But if you take him just _slightly_ outside of his area of expertise - video game design and perhaps philosophy - his takes are extremely strongly held, banal, and don’t really stand up to scrutiny.
Best to admire his work but it’s pretty safe to ignore anything else he says, at least in my experience, or treat it more like an opinion from an average colleague rather than an industry expert.
Very good at what he does, poor takes in general.
Don’t even get me started on Muratori who is not even good at what he does, yet has the same strongly held takes seemingly mostly to curry favour with Blow.
Sorry if that seems a bit personal but I’ve been following him ever since Braid and I have found this to be repeatedly true, despite the self evident quality of his work.
forgotpwd16 6 days ago |
ekidd 6 days ago |
1. Coding isn't completely solved yet. The further you get from CRUD apps, the more a little experienced human judgement helps.
2. The most dramatic improvements happened in the last couple of months. How fast do you expect software to ship?
3. I am now running multiple really amazing TUI tools that were largely written by someone's LLMs over the last several months. My software, at least, has already started changing.
It breaks my heart, because I love writing software and I think I'm pretty good at it. But another year of progress like the last 12 months, and I fear that our profession will be cooked.
jFriedensreich 6 days ago |
- interaction regression test and ensuring taste, feeling of app use are consistent. agents still suck at that, especially general review agents, i hope this gets better as i introduce dedicated vision test agents for userflows but at the moment it takes about a week of usage to find the things that are wrong in subtle ways before an agent task can be accepted, if i push too fast and dont wait a week the app degrades quickly
- data layer: ui coding is largely solved apart the above but the limiting factor is the logic/state layer beteen the database and the ui, this has to be pluggable from persistence (both local and remote) and local first and reactive and be able to encapsulate the logic that would make ui components eat up complexity and slowly degrade. There are 100 local first libraries all broken in different ways or losing data in edgecases, the most promising one seems to be tanstackDB but i still dont have a setup that just fits perfect, but i am also nowhere near the level of understanding of it i would need
mythz 6 days ago |
Obviously if you have time/energy invested learning a piece of software it's going to take you a minute to evaluate and learn a new alternative. But I can see vibe coded Apps fill the void when there aren't many great options.
JuniperMesos 6 days ago |
hdhjsjja 6 days ago |
Another gripe is he is willing to end privacy on internet because game piracy affects his sales.
One more thing he doesn't understand the struggles of people with kids and look down upon people with lesser talented than him. But this is okay given how much he toils to build skills and inspire others devs.
If u r reading this thanks Jonathan Blow for u r streams. You have been great inspiration.
maxdo 7 days ago |
asifnazeer24 6 days ago |
empath75 7 days ago |
I have a personal project where I am merging 100+ PRs a week and at work I would be lucky to merge 8. I spend 20x as much time trying to get PRs merged as I do actually doing the work.
I'm on a project with 4 other people working on 4 or 5 microservices and I would get more, better, work done if I were on a team alone managing all 4 or 5 microservices myself.
happy-go-lucky 6 days ago |
PeterStuer 6 days ago |
iaanix 6 days ago |
Stevvo 6 days ago |
abc42 6 days ago |
rowanG077 6 days ago |
pmdr 6 days ago |
grumbel 6 days ago |
It's not even just AI, Gaussian Splatting has a similar issue, amazing tech, amazing tech demos, but what's the modern equivalent to what Myst was using Gaussian Splatting? The tech is amazing, but somehow we seem to have a hard time making good use of it, everything is stuck in tech-demo land.
kolinko 6 days ago |
tonymet 7 days ago |
Legal has much more authority , and far less familiarity with the product, or even the customers. So they demand orthogonal, complicated and impractical requirements that are not even beneficial for risk mitigation. And they are slow at providing them – usually the bottleneck.
It’s not a simple LOC/day formula. If Southwest Airlines wanted to make major software improvements tomorrow, it certainly wouldn’t be the engineering team armed with Claude Code holding them back.
saberience 7 days ago |
Anything that makes code more available to "normies" is something Jonathan Blow will absolutely hate. Why? Because Jonathan Blow HAS to be the smartest guy in the room, if he's somehow not the smartest guy in the room, there is something wrong with the room, nothing is ever wrong with Jonathan Blow.
So of course, Jonathan Blow thinks AI coding is terrible, only Jonathan Blow can be the best coder in the world, anyone who thinks otherwise is a total moron.
If you don't hand-roll your own programming language and game engine to make your own game, you're a moron. Hell, he even has a video where he basically says if you don't make your own version of JSON and associated parser, you're a fucking idiot.
What I'm saying is this, Jonathan Blow's ego only sustains itself on the idea that he is right about everything and the smartest person on any given topic. The idea that AI might be better at coding than him causes him to implode in a narcissistic rage.
bdparrish 6 days ago |
1. Blow is arguing that paradigms haven't changed which means software is still being produced and delivered in the same way. How do we get beyond "Clean Code", "Gang of Four", etc.?
2. AI is trained on human code. Inherently it is going to have bugs. Proper context, concepts and design will eliminate a lot of vibe-coding and AI slop, but if you are learning from bugs, then they will be there. It will be less.
3. There is going to be chaos for a junior engineer or a fresh graduate that has not experienced and built full systems. Where do they fit in now with AI doing the perceived grunt work? How do they get mentored? There is going to be a place for hungry software engineers that are getting out there and just figuring it out with a GSD attitude.
sreekanth850 6 days ago |
MetroWind 5 days ago |
medellin 6 days ago |
ozgrakkurt 6 days ago |
While the guy created a programming language, game engine and a game. And sold thousands of copies of that game.
Is this not much compared to working at big tech to adjust a button and drinking coffee at work. Because the team is bigger and there are more customers?
NSUserDefaults 6 days ago |
Also, regarding Blow, let’s ask a stupid question back: if his language solved game development, why did his game take so long?
I suspect only a few people will use the language. With attitude like his, it is a risky proposition. Unreal Blueprints are gone, and that is coming from a big company. He could turn his product into a liability on a whim.
eska 5 days ago |
jdlyga 6 days ago |
iotage 6 days ago |
Surely, it is because AI uses the same practices and techniques used by human programmers. Despite AIs being highly capable, programmers are unable to provide structure, rules and examples of how to architect, design, write or refactor consistently better software.
Given this, it’s quite amazing that AIs do so well.
robeym 6 days ago |
wayeq 4 days ago |
Rantenki 6 days ago |
Until a few months ago when Solidcraft came out. It's very similar in appearance to Autodesk's Fusion360 package, and operates like a combination of Fusion360 and Solidworks. I've been trying it on every release, and it's making RAPID progress towards replacing Solidworks for my CAD workflows. I've been a Solidworks user since 1997, and I can confidently say that Solidcraft is advancing with biweekly releases which are more feature-rich than Solidworks annual releases. All of this is driven by AI/LLM development.
The tricky part here is that somebody has a good vision for the product they want to build, and they're doing it using an LLM, but not missing the jobs of product/project/engineering/release management. AI hasn't _solved_ coding, but it's reduced friction in ONE part of the development cycle. In most cases, that hasn't increased throughput very much (if at all), because it's just revealed the next slowest "rate limiting step" in the process. In cases where there is less overall business friction, and a strong vision without slow moving bureaucracy, it seems clear to me that LLMs _can_ greatly increase throughput. It also seems obvious that the advantage here lies mostly with very small teams with a great deal of experience actually delivering products. Great time for startups to do disruption, bad time for large slow-moving enterprises to get disrupted. Go capitalism or something.
hugodan 6 days ago |
kylehotchkiss 7 days ago |
The people who said building software wasn't the hard part before were right, you still need interesting problems to solve to find interesting things to build. Gotta get out of the tech bubble to find those. There aren't many interesting problems left to solve for other tech bros
polarsanel 6 days ago |
If (thing that is ambiguous and probably not true) why is (something ambiguous, subjective)
unrented7977 6 days ago |
Brilliant argument as always.
_pdp_ 6 days ago |
dimavolo 7 days ago |
And yet... the app works efficiently, has features like shape-smoothing for hand-drawn freeform annotations (I wouldn't even know where to start if I were tasked with this on macOS, for example), it's designed far more beautifully than I could have done, even after a decade of studying UI/UX, etc
Yes, AI solved coding... mostly. At least for indie devs.
gchamonlive 6 days ago |
maxrev17 6 days ago |
shevy-java 6 days ago |
Quality may be an issue but one could assume that any models will be improved. Complexity in the software itself is not really a huge issue for any good LLMs, so I don't understand this take he presents as "humans will always be better". It's like standing on the Titanic and saying "nothing to see here" while it is sinking, just as in the old movie Naked Gun (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NuAKnbIr6TE).
ankit9673 6 days ago |
undefined 6 days ago |
undefined 6 days ago |
indymike 6 days ago |
iloveyoutwo 6 days ago |
I do think it's accelerated enshitification of closed-source software and services, but I've never used less closed source software thanks to AI, and the open source software I'm replacing it with is more secure than ever.
My average Android app has way less permissions than it used to, less or no Network permission, and is smaller. It's excellent for my privacy.
New good software:
T3 Code is the best way to interact with AI coding. Fluxer is a great Discord alternative which has excellent UX. Fuck matrix btw.
glennfiedler 6 days ago |
ellyagg 6 days ago |
jdw64 7 days ago |
Realistically speaking, AI raised the average quality. Among today's AI slop games, there are many that would have been "at this level of quality, this game could succeed" in the past.
Realistically, that's how it is. So there will be many people telling bad-luck stories like "ever since AI came out, GitHub has stalled," but I think that's closer to the opposite — AI increased production so much that the supply chain itself can't keep up.
The thing is, I can't really agree with the claim that software is the same. I don't know about open source, but when I think about the state of code in code delivered to clients, I think there has been a dramatic rise. Separately from that, because products are pouring out, I think consumers' quality demands are rising far faster than production. Comparing early smartphone games with today's AI slop games makes this even more palpable.
iloveyoutwo 6 days ago |
I added self-hosted E2EE sync to the greatest (closed source) to-do app of all time (Things 3) and I'm working on an Android clone of the iOS version which is already fully functional but has quite buggy UI.
None of it is slop. I am obsessed with Android UX so I fiddle a lot. All of it has greatly picked up thanks to Opus 5.5 and Sol 6.1. Sol is good for the premium unlocking while Claude models refuse.
I haven't released any of it yet because I have to sort out my opsec for the copyright stuff although I'm not particularly worried.
I did release the best way to make a dumbphone on Android: https://beeswax.getflourish.org
superkuh 6 days ago |
This is one of big changes with useful coding LLMS: each human person can have their own software to scratch their own itches. Corporations don't need to provide them. It's okay if they only work for me on my machine because they're only for me. They can be slop and still fulfill their much more limited goal(s).
exabrial 7 days ago |
threethirtytwo 6 days ago |
dominotw 7 days ago |
My friend is in managment at faang and he said ai has changed how tech coders now behave at work. he is enjoying the fact that "their tails have been cut by AI". Made his management job infinitely easier.
why is this downvoted?
ChrisTrenkamp 6 days ago |
The part that I find extremely valuable is using LLM's as a replacement for searching code documentation. If you're new to something, you don't always know how to phrase your search query. The LLM's do an excellent job at translating your novice-level language into the precise terms you need. This saves a lot of people's times. You don't have to ask your question on a forum or to your colleague, saving not just your time, but everyone else's time. That's a big gamechanger. We can spend more time on the task you care about and not on all these tertiary side-trips.
What I find extraordinarily disappointing, however, is the industry's reaction was not "Oh wow, look at how much more productive we can make our programmers.". The industry's first reaction was to tokenmaxx and make the LLM's do everything, from writing code, submitting issues, design, etc. It leads to codebases that seem fine on the surface, but as you study the code, you find all sorts of issues. As these issues get discovered, the LLM then has to fix a bunch of different code, which leads to these infamous thousand-line PR/MR's. Even if LLM's produce code that works, remember that the quality of the LLM's output degrades when the context window reaches a certain point, which will start costing you more in terms of technical debt, bugs, and the literal token cost. It's also worth pointing out that companies that provide LLM's are still not profitable, so when the arms race between Google, OpenAI, and Anthropic settles, we're going to see the real cost to run these LLM code harnesses, and it just might make you pause and think before reaching for the LLM again. On the other hand, if the cost of hardware finally comes down, running your models locally would be a viable option, so you only have to worry about the upfront costs and the electricity bill.
With all that said, I think there's a bright future with LLM's. They are extremely good at pattern matching, and I think the real business value is in the use-cases that fits cleanly into that role. LLM's might not be the best at writing code, but they're exceptional at finding issues with your code. Case in point, OpenAI recently published a ton of fixes for root privilege exploits in the Linux kernel. I think spending our time constructing and training LLM's on how to discover issues for your particular domain will provide far more value that simply having the LLM write code for you.
datadrivenangel 7 days ago |
tonii1123 3 days ago |
urios 3 days ago |
ReDress 6 days ago |
matthiasforstr 6 days ago |
imranjavaid 6 days ago |
alazsolutions 6 days ago |
mollyrasmussen 6 days ago |
BuildPeter 6 days ago |
LdBaringSwallow 7 days ago |
Blow and coders have a hammer so all they see is nails; it didn't "solve coding" AI solved "machine state management". Totally different; human tagging/coding will still exist just at the presentation layer cause we don't need a bunch of syntax like:
def sumAllCustomerAccounts() { Some desired physical state of machine based on mathematical axioms }
AI solved naming that function (the coding with human context part) with
f() { generate a function to add all customer balances}
We moving on from 1960s and 70s machine state management, pushing context coding to the presentation layer
Blow is just doing that thing humans do where they wrap their entire identity up in who they were 30 years ago and still think that's who they are today and will be tomorrow; rotary phone companies, bowling alley equipment manufacturers... new generations are superseding them... circle of life Simba
Not really gonna put Blow and Carmack on a pedestal; they never invented computers or software dev. They came along in the middle of the hype. The read the manual for old machines. We're just moving on to new kinds of machines.
People flipped out over the printing press too. Nothing to see here; it's just the upper bound of the middle age generation having a mid-life crisis
movzart 6 days ago |
blini-kot 6 days ago |
there are many people to take their opinion on code seriously, and mr.Blow is certainly not one of them
In the last 3 years, there have been a lot more indie games of far higher quality than we used to get. I'm thinking of the RTS space right now. The Scouring for example. We went from having nobody but Blizzard able to make something that complex to several games with outstanding performance and complexity, often with their own custom game engines that are not only working but working better than I remember wc3/sc2 working at launch.
I don't know how much of a role AI is playing in those games, but I think the performance and complexity of indie games is shooting up and we are seeing very, very small teams make things that large teams struggled with in the past. Honestly, I think indie studios are outperforming AAA in most ways besides spend and length and art budget --and yet, it's the indies who are making their own game engines these days, isn't it?
(btw, we have to also admit that many of these game engine builders look to blow for inspiration (to carmack too), and their architectures are not what you'll find at typical saas companies. Game coding is complicated in a really fun way I didn't get doing plumbing on web projects, speaking for myself)