Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

A quest to create the perfect whiskey glass (https://www.nytimes.com)

105 points by Kaibeezy 7 days ago | 116 comments | View on ycombinator

Kaibeezy 7 days ago |

mickeyp 5 days ago |

Serious whisky collector (and drinker) here...

You don't need a fancy glass. Your sense of smell makes a huge difference when it comes to food and drink, as anybody with a nasty cold can tell you. You want something that keeps it from diffusing into the air so anything with a wide mouth makes it harder to appreciate.

So: a cognac snifter; sherry glass; a glencairn, which was ""made for whisky""; etc.

But of course it's down to taste.

If the aroma is too heady? Blow air into glass and then inhale the aroma. The burn is gone (important if you're drinking 62% rocket fuel single cask whisky) and you get a more dilute smell.

No need for all this pretension; this glass is that.

epiccoleman 4 days ago |

The perfect whiskey glass already exists - the "Norlan Glass," which sits in a beautiful middle between the prissy Glencairn and the manly, chunky rocks glass.

https://norlanglass.com/products/norlan-whisky-glass

Now, I haven't owned one of these for years, because my wife put both of mine in the dishwasher and broke them. $32 for one glass is too much for me to stomach given my middling level of interest in whiskey these days, and a rocks glass is good enough. But they were damn fine glasses. Someday when I'm rich and famous, I'll buy some more.

TacticalCoder 5 days ago |

For SciFi fans, there is only one true whiskey glass and it doesn't share power:

https://bladerunnerglass.com/

BigTTYGothGF 4 days ago |

I always just drank it straight from the bottle.

pavlov 5 days ago |

I bought two of these a few years ago:

https://savuglass.com/

Created by Finnish molecular chemistry PhDs. The shape looks like it too (an industrial designer would never approve this asymmetric lumpiness). But it does make a tangible difference.

nickpp 5 days ago |

It amazes me how accepted and ingrained in our lifestyle is consumption of one drug (alcohol). With attached rituals, passions, hobbies and dedication. It is acceptable to discuss it with pretty much anybody, in any setting.

Meanwhile other, much less harmful drugs (THC, psylocibin) are shunned, judged, even illegal.

There is so much hypocrisy and double standards in our rules that one wonders if we are a rational species at all.

fennecfoxy about 19 hours ago |

I use the Cibi bladerunner glasses. Probably not the best functional choice but I like 'em and they're very well (hand)crafted. Also grabbed the decanter, pricey but it looks sooooo good as a set.

ImJasonH 4 days ago |

Stealthisbook 5 days ago |

Solo cup

dcrazy 4 days ago |

The Teku is often considered the “perfect” craft beer glass: https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/teku-beer-glass/

There are definitely real advantages to the design. I’m especially fond of the flared lip; it avoids agitating the beer and making it aggressively bubble as you sip.

But there are of course competitors and alternatives to the Teku, including from Rastal themselves. I purchased a set of Craft Master One tumblers: https://rastal.com/en/product-search/craft-master-one-tumble...

All this to say, this article isn’t entirely bullshit. But if Zalto is truly successful, there will be plenty of clones vying to replace the standard snifter.

undefined 5 days ago |

undefined

shevy-java 4 days ago |

A very important topic.

NorrisFByrd 4 days ago |

[flagged]

zug_zug 4 days ago |

Pretty sure this is an ad.

rainbowzootsuit 5 days ago |

Mr. Zalto also recommended to me some $5,000 speaker cables. I could only afford the left channel so far. I really hope that the effects kick in when I get the right channel cable installed.

tiffanyh 4 days ago |

For a company so focused on perfecting the drink, I'm surprised they are offering both stem and stemless glasses for Whisky.

https://us.josephinen.com/collections/josephine-whisky-glass...

Stemless dramatically changes the profile of the drink since now your hand is warming it (hence why chilled wines are always served in stem glasses).

theDoug 5 days ago |

NYT continues to be a great venue for marketing your high-end products, including running your own photos. All while providing the thinnest layer of “but not all agree” counterpoints which only strengthen the perception that this is a product for not the riff raff but truly a thing “for those who know.”

adrianN 5 days ago |

I wonder whether they try do use objective measures at all when designing the glasses or whether it’s all vibes and impossible-to-blind taste tests.

kart23 5 days ago |

i really don’t understand wine or alcohol snobs in general. to me, ingredients and food freshness is so much easier to actually discern and objectively easier to say what food tastes better than arguing over fine minute notes in drinks. a pastry hot out of the oven will taste miles better than one made 4 hours ago and reheated, but it’s pretty hard to find truly fresh baked goods in a lot of places. (donuts especially are amazing less minutes after frying!)

fruit has huge differences in taste depending on the specific variety, where it’s grown, how long ago it was picked, especially stuff like stone fruit or berries. meat, fish, etc also have huge differences in quality and taste.

but maybe i just haven’t had the right glassware :)

SeanDav 4 days ago |

This to my philistine brain, sounds a lot like the audiophiles who back in the day used to argue that gold plated connectors were somehow able to deliver better sound...from a digitally generated source!

Sure, things like a wide glass vs a testtube would make a (probably small) difference but beyond gross differences, I struggle to take these sorts of conversations seriously.

fergie 4 days ago |

> Mr. Zalto says it is especially attuned to bourbon and rye

So in other words, not optimised for actual scotch whisky.

chalmovsky 5 days ago |

De gustibus non est disputandum, but for me, what matters most about a whisky is not "Is it in a correct glass?" but “Is it an Islay?”

undefined 4 days ago |

undefined

sandworm101 4 days ago |

And how many will buy these fancy glasses but still not bother to learn how to hold them? A long neck has a purpose. A short neck another. A cup without a neck a third method. Dont ignore the design.

alienbaby 4 days ago |

this smells like a thinly disguised 'buy your dad a whisky glass for christmas' ad

fractal618 3 days ago |

Spoiler: it’s a beer funnel

ReptileMan 5 days ago |

Next generation will just be Claisen flask. Or Soxhlet .

kittikitti 4 days ago |

Why is this on Hacker News? This isn't relevant at all. It's also the New York Times?!