Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

KDE: The documentary [video] (https://tube.kockatoo.org)

581 points by mrkn1 6 days ago | 147 comments | View on ycombinator

blinkingled 6 days ago |

Total KDE fan and that's all I run at home. It's an interesting study also in desktop environment and software written in C++ and just how hard it is to get something that works for most people. Mistakes, corrections, building the basic blocks like Qt in the early days and keeping a bunch of people with differing cultures / tastes / backgrounds/needs motivated to make it better every day - fascinating achievement.

Thank you KDE folks - I contribute in terms of bug reports and attempts at fixes sometimes but this time I am signing up for a monthly donation - I encourage people to do what they can to keep a good thing going! https://kde.org/donate/

esFran 5 days ago |

KDE is amazing. Outstanding performance, outstanding design, and endlessly configurable. But the most amazing thing of all is that you've achieved this while competing against teams like Microsoft's or Apple's, which spend millions of euros and are made up of thousands of people.

Congratulations, team. Here's to 30 more years.

mongol 6 days ago |

I am a bit prod of having seen the original post looking for volunteers to build a Kool Desktop Environment. I was obsessively reading Usenet groups at the time. And I remember there were quite early betas published, I did not run them at first, but I remember much enthusiasm about it. So I feel familiar with the beginnings although I never participated in the project development-wise. All the way up to KDE 4 I was quite close to the project as a user. But since KDE 4 was so unstable and buggy, I left it around that time. This is also around the time when the documentary makes a big jump ahead chronologically.

I feel the documentary explains less what happened the last 10-15 years. I recall Trolltech and Qt underwent a series of acquisitions. How is KDE and Qt developed now? Who are the main contributors and sponsors? Any big backers? This information I felt missing.

mrinf1nity 5 days ago |

KDE is how desktops should be. 'The Year of the Linux' is NOW, a few years ago. Linux and KDE have given me not only freedom over my own hardware, but freedom over how I interact with my desktops. Once you know the shortcuts, things become so much more fun. Much love to the KDE team.

Linux life, yo.

ezst 6 days ago |

I joined as a user at one point during the kde3 days, powerful apps like Amarok 1.4, k3b and konqueror with all kinds of crazy kio-slaves were the ones that really gave me pause on the boot screen and kept tipping me over towards mandrake instead of WinXP ("why can't it be that simple and as well integrated, why do I need so many ad-hoc shareware to do every basic thing like burning/ripping CDs, mounting ISOs, transcoding audio, sending it to my MP3 player").

The KDE4 days were rough, by then I had jumped over to fedora, and that one didn't shy away from shipping very early and unstable versions of it. That had me hopping for alternative DEs, I seriously tried several (and stuck for a while with some) of the minimalistic ones (enlightenment, XFCE, ...) and quickly ended up depending on either KWin, and/or some battery/networking/disks applet from plasma, or configuring something via systemsettings. The plasma desktop itself is fine (I don't mind it so much, I'm not crazy about shell theming and customisations, I do love my global menu on top, though), but what sells KDE for me is all the clever ancillary stuff that makes it "smart and usable" (dealing with Bluetooth, network setup, local and remote drives, audio output, ...), that's where the "environment" metaphor kicks in and elevates the experience above that of a "desktop shell".

mpol 6 days ago |

Really great documentary, very much suggested to watch it.

I had no idea Gnome was started without ever talking to the Qt and KDE people. If there was discussion and a solution about the license, the present would be very different I assume. Still, there would be many WMs and DE's, but KDE would be somewhat of a centerpoint.

Also, Aaron Seigo took the criticism of KDE 4 quite hard I would guess. It might be why he is not involved in the project anymore.

aeonik 6 days ago |

Wow, great job everyone. Love seeing all the faces being the scenes, and the humble beginnings.

I remember the switch to KDE4, and it was indeed brutal. I feel bad that they took as much flak as they did for that.

Plasma has come such a long way, y'all deserve so much for the perseverance and vision.

Thank you for sharing the story!

k0morebi 6 days ago |

Been using for over 20 years now. KDE is really the best. Consistent between releases, stable, infinitely customizable, but works great out of the box with features you'd expect and often years ahead of the commercial competition in terms of new features. Every moment I spend in macos or windows for work is pure torture.

kevinfiol 5 days ago |

Recently got a Macbook Pro for work, and was surprised how archaic MacOS feels compared to KDE. Switching to Linux full-time for personal machines and work has spoiled me.

sdwvit 6 days ago |

Wonderful quality documentary, just like KDE itself. Really nice to see people behind my favorite software.

flyerbird 6 days ago |

Their story is inspirational; if this were a commercial project, they would surely have taken over the market. Hearing about the challenges they faced with Qt, and how their HTML engine was adopted by Apple, is so interesting.

KDE deserves a lot more.

win95 5 days ago |

Btw it's also on youtube, just search KDE documentary. I've also watched other documentaries from this channel and this KDE one stands out.

shevy-java 5 days ago |

They seem to talk about the whole history of KDE.

I don't think this works well. For instance, KDE back in 2006 or 2007, give or take, was very different to KDE in 2026. Not only because older people tend to retire (or die), and younger people follow up, but also because of policy changes and different people pushing through with their ideas. Back in 2006, you would not be able to find someone like Nate who wants to push a donation-daemon into KDE. Fast forward and suddenly you have that. You also have people wanting to add a dependency on systemd (David Edmundson) - lo and behold, that is suddenly happening. I could bring more examples, but I feel that it is unfair to claim xyz at this point in time, is KDE or how KDE always used to be. That's simply not the case. It is no the case with GNOME either; see why mate-desktop was forked when people did not want to transition into a smartphone-centric UI (though there is no real way around that with GTK5 eventually, since it will be wayland-locked-down only).

So these videos are just happy-go-lucky. That's IMO very bad.

I'd much prefer a style such as in the old movie manufacturing consent. Now, the movie also had various issues and is also quite outdated now, but at the least you'd have a SLIGHTLY more balanced view rather than just a promo-video, which this video is ultimately about.

Edit: mongol shared a somewhat similar criticism; not about the above mentioned content, but with regards to KDE 4 and the promo-video totally ignoring that fact. Well, this is a sunshine-video. It has no real substance indeed so I concur with mongol on that part.

I also agree with iberator, though I was never that much a DE user per se. I did use KDE 3.x, naturally 4.x was a dead end, but already before that I transitioned into fluxbox. From a workflow-centric approach, I found fluxbox to be so much more productive than KDE. I would use KDE konsole on fluxbox, though, as it is a great terminal. okular is also ok-ish, though I found evince to be snappier and faster, so I use that for .pdf files usually (okular is more feature-rich though). Most other KDE programs I don't really need; I do most actions via KDE konsole and scripts.

anotherevan 6 days ago |

I must have used KDE for close on two decades, from the 3.x days onwards. I seem to remember I ran Suse for a long time as it seemed to be the best distro for using with KDE.

About eight years ago I wanted to try a tiling window manager, ended up settling on Awesomewm and still with it today, but I still use Dolphin as I've found no other file manager compares. (Or maybe I'm just too comfortable with it to change.)

Also still use Konsole, but honestly, as soon as Ghostty or similar implement being able to switch tabs in MRU order instead of round-robin I'll jump.

I have a low-priority todo to give Cosmic, Hyprland and Niri a go at some point. Would be nice to go back into a fuller desktop experience over what I've cobbled together around "just" a window manager.

einpoklum 6 days ago |

What is the country-of-residence distribution of KDE contributors? Originally, and today? Judging from the film, it seems like a lot of people from Germany and Finland (maybe other Scandinavian countries); but maybe it's just the documentary availability bias + my memory bias?

SiqingYu 4 days ago |

The coolest thing of Plasma is its capability for customization. You can customize the panels to look like Menu Bar and Dock in MacOS.

One particular good community widget is Panel Colorizer (https://github.com/luisbocanegra/plasma-panel-colorizer), which makes the panels look even more gorgeous.

madisp 6 days ago |

I recently switched to KDE on my main workstation and it has been such a breath fresh air. I can't exactly put my finger on it, but the mix between aesthetics, configurability and a bit of pre-2010s UX design is really good.

elendilm 6 days ago |

It is very hard to imagine what life would be without the awesomeness that KDE is.

mikemcquaid 5 days ago |

KDE is how I got started in OSS (GSoC 2007). Without it I doubt Homebrew or GitHub Sponsors would be the same. All in on macOS nowadays so so lovely to see KDE keeps shipping.

ddtaylor 5 days ago |

Big shout out to Harald Sitter at KDE.

I'm a long-time contributor to KDE, but my contributions are small and often times required jumping into a completely different project each time. Combine that with some of it being Qt related and how those libraries are linked and it can be a bit painful sometimes. Herald helps with this kind of stuff and provides a lot of very useful amplification where a minute of his time ripples out into many fixes and merges.

CrLf 6 days ago |

In a documentary about KDE, it's interesting how many (most) of the people shown using a computer are running macOS...

4thguy 5 days ago |

"doKumentary" was right there

noisy_boy 5 days ago |

I am just amazed how well designed the Plasma foundations must be for them to be holding strong for so many years. Incredibly impressive.

pelagicAustral 6 days ago |

I wish I could have a DE that looks like KDE 3 or before...

jordanarseno 6 days ago |

A great way to start my morning, thank you for posting

ElijahLynn 6 days ago |

I just watched the first 2 minutes and I didn't even know it stood for Cool Desktop Environment initially. And then it turned to KDE because they didn't want to use CDE.

At any rate, I'm busy right now, but I'm hooked and, and totally going to watch this. Thanks for posting it.

ladyanita22 6 days ago |

I wonder if it was edited in Kdenlive

simgt 5 days ago |

I really enjoyed this, the contributors seem to really like having worked together for all this time. I wish they had gone a bit more into the details of the governance and how they managed to resolve the unavoidable conflicts.

kmac_ 5 days ago |

KDE user here. It's fast, it's ergonomic, it's modern, it's stable, and the defaults are great. I use it on 3 different machines, at work and at home. Big thank you to the team!

dvirsky 5 days ago |

While I enjoy the productivity boost of AI coding for my work as much as the next guy, it makes me sad to think that this way of producing software is gone forever.

dumindunuwan 5 days ago |

solveproblemswi 5 days ago |

Never new about the origin story. Really fun watch.

utopiah 5 days ago |

All the way from there to the Steam Deck and for the last month on the Steam Frame, using KDE in VR. Amazing.

shmerl 5 days ago |

It's interesting that KDE originally stands for Kool Desktop Environment as the video mentions.

zer0zzz 5 days ago |

Amusing how the shots of miguel's terminal all show him coding in Swift on a mac

academicfish 5 days ago |

A big KDE fan here, and it's awesome to see real faces behind the project.

int32max 5 days ago |

love kde and first time trying out kockatoo which looks cool !

vlowrian 6 days ago |

I've become a big fan of CultRepo's documentaries. If you enjoyed this one, I highly recommend checking out their catalogue of free, high-quality content (https://www.cultrepo.com/films).

They cover a wide range of topics, from C++ and Java to Node.js, Kubernetes, React, and Vue.js. I particularly enjoyed the Java documentary, which offered fascinating insights into the differences between the Sun and Oracle eras, many of which I never would have expected.

sick_of_slop 6 days ago |

I was a Gnome guy since the 16.04 Ubuntu days even with the transition to 3 and whatnot. Stopped using a linux desktop for a while but came back and used CachyOS - when deciding what desktop to use, everyone online said KDE so I gave it a shot and haven't look back since.

A few times I had to do something on a Gnome system and now it just feels like you're being kneecapped by the devs for no good reason.