Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Too Many Stadiums with Roofs (https://sharptext.net)

57 points by colinprince 6 days ago | 65 comments | View on ycombinator

mchusma 5 days ago |

Why wouldn’t you build a roof? It means conditions inside are great at all times.

I will say sofi is not great because they don’t go far enough m. The translucent roof and no ac (it’s got open sides in some spots) as far as I can tell make it really uncomfortable at times, almost worse than roof or no roof. So in my opinion if you are building a billion dolllar facility, put a roof on it.

Jeremy1026 3 days ago |

For football it all comes down to one day in early February. They want to host a Super Bowl. Aside from MetLife, nothing open air in a cold climate has hosted the Super Bowl in the last 20 years. I'm not sure what deal the Giants/Jets had to do to host in 2014, probably only happened because it was new that year, and I doubt they host another at MetLife ever.

RankingMember 3 days ago |

Teams with indoor stadiums have been found to do worse in away games played outside, which isn't super surprising to me, but is an interesting aspect to note:

https://ww2.amstat.org/meetings/proceedings/2014/data/assets...

I think the prevalence of roofed stadiums boils down to the NFL usually choosing roofed stadiums to host Super Bowls in the modern era. Cities want to host Super Bowls, and so if they're going to invest in a new stadium, they're usually going to choose the stadium type that gets them in the mix for a Super Bowl.

thehappypm 5 days ago |

Does the author not realize that other things happen in stadiums besides football? It’s much better to be able to have concerts and other events reliably and with comfortable customers, people don’t want to bundle up in 35° DC winter weather to go see a concert

olsondv 5 days ago |

Lambeau Field will never have a roof. The shareholders are too proud of its Frozen Tundra reputation.

dfxm12 3 days ago |

A roof allows ownership groups to build in the capacity to host concerts all year long, as well as conventions, NCAA Tournament games, or any number of other public events that may require a controlled weather environment. The roof also helps reduce ongoing capital costs around maintenance, wear and tear, etc.

This [money] is certainly the crux of it. It doesn't help that extreme weather feels like it is becoming more common.

All things being equal, players would probably prefer natural turf, but modern artificial turf is probably worth the trade off vs the risk of injury in extreme weather. Weird weather is fun for fans, too (and who doesn't love the NFL Films video about the Fog Bowl?), but they'd probably also not want their starting QB getting hurt, like what happened to Caleb Williams in the rain...

ssharp 3 days ago |

If you're spending billions on a stadium (and generally the taxpayers are paying for a lot of that), it makes sense to build it for maximum local economic impact and return, which means a roof so you can use it year round and for events that you can't really do outdoors, even when its warm and not raining.

However, football, more than any other sport, is made for television. Those wild element games, especially in the playoffs when much of the country is cold and snowy, or the Tampa Bay monsoon games, made for entertaining television.

throw0101c 3 days ago |

I found this video enjoyable "Why Some Retractable Roofs Saved Stadiums and Others Failed":

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=64KKZwtRTvk

Retractable grass pitches (fields) is also neat:

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6m6h2ukSU0&t=8m57s

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=doaiTzW58Ns

world2vec 3 days ago |

I think the weather unpredictability is part of the fun in sports. Sometimes it's too windy or rainy or cold and the game changes, one team might suffer more than the other. Maybe players will need to briefly adapt, new game plans. That's a core part of sports and controlling as many variables as possibles makes every game look and feel the same.

shermantanktop 3 days ago |

I wish this were only a question for football fans. But the public finances part or all of many of these stadiums, typically after an extortion campaign waged in the media by billionaires.

The private companies in space travel are often held up as vanity projects for billionaires, but sports stadiums have been playing that role for decades.

In case it’s not obvious, I don’t care about professional sports and don’t see why my tax dollars should fund it. Put a roof on it, or don’t, with your own money.

paxy 3 days ago |

The author is (probably deliberately) skipping the fact that the majority of stadium roofs are retractable. If they want to play in the rain or snow there is nothing stopping them. The choice is intentional, not a limitation of the stadium.

rurban 5 days ago |

Too less stadiums with roofs

scaradim 2 days ago |

if we have roof, we can think about next step: air conditioning at stadium scale.

settsu 3 days ago |

Welp, TIL "salience inversion"...

toast0 3 days ago |

> Last week I was on my way home from a conference in downtown D.C., and when I was stopped at a red light I checked a text message from a friend who’d sent me a video rendering [...]

> But sitting in traffic last week, I found myself seething when I got to the 21-second mark of the Commanders’ preview video. It happened again at the 26-second mark, the 28-second mark, the 38-second mark, and the 51-second mark: why in the WORLD does that stadium need a roof?

Ugh, why are so many people watching videos while driving??

codazoda 6 days ago |

“Las Vegas … almost no inclement weather”

Welp, try going to that stadium in July when it’s 112F. The NFL isn’t playing at that time but these stadiums aren’t just used for football.

undefined 2 days ago |

undefined

jmpman 3 days ago |

"I don’t want to watch all 32 teams play on a pristine field, in pristine, climate-controlled conditions." - does the author also want to sit in the stadium in a blizzard, or in a tropical storm? No, he wants to sit on his couch and watch the players run around in the weather, while the local fans have to endure the blizzards and rain.

the_kaiser 3 days ago |

I'm a football fan and have begrudgingly accepted the roofs. The product on the field is better to watch with dry, healthy players. That doesn't mean I didn't enjoy watching Tua Tungovailoa freeze his tush off in Arrowhead a few years ago, though.

sloped 3 days ago |

I personally prefer my billion dollar buildings to be useful for more than maybe 12 events a year, so I support roofs. Even if privately financed, it would be crazy to leave those buildings empty for so many days when there is an easy solution to make them useful for hundreds of events.

But the point that capitalism pushes things toward boring is spot on. Weird things that start making money slowly become less weird.

luckydata 3 days ago |

Is this really something anyone except the author cares about?

brandonmenc 3 days ago |

The NFL is slowly becoming the AFL, sadly.

fiffa 3 days ago |

This is requirements of the corrupt FIFA.

pfdietz 3 days ago |

Why even have football? It's an engine for producing chronic brain injury.

I don't watch football for the same reason I don't watch boxing.

People who downvoted this should touch astroturf.

undefined 3 days ago |

undefined

etempleton 2 days ago |

Reading the hot takes on hackers news about football is like watching national media talk about the tech industry. The number of bad and uninformed takes is staggering.

memcg 5 days ago |

[flagged]

readthenotes1 3 days ago |

I don't understand why someone would pay so high a price to go to a stadium to watch the game.

Parking, tickets, concessions. All incredibly expensive.

And no instant replay or pause while you go to the bathroom.

Plus, You get the added negative of having to put up with drunks