Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

A family tree of software job titles (https://zwischenzugs.com)

463 points by umerf 6 days ago | 220 comments | View on ycombinator

probably_wrong 5 days ago |

Recently I spoke to someone who wanted to know what they should call themselves seeing as they never learned software development, formally or otherwise, but that's not stopping them from releasing AI-powered Python projects in GitHub. I suggested Project Manager, but they took offense to that because (I think) they wanted to hear Software Engineer in order to apply to those jobs. My counter-argument was that, legal rules aside, a S.E. should be able to differentiate good code from bad, but my suggestion wasn't super well received.

The point being: I'm always amazed at the cross-purpose impulse of arguing "the title is not important" while, simultaneously, really wanting to use the title.

siva7 6 days ago |

Scrum and Agile seem to be dying. I had a Product Owner and Scrum Master cert for years on my resume but i've dropped it from my current. Feels now like the ancient webmaster title of the mid 90s. Made for another timeline which is not more relevant.

DevOps is another sad story as it was a saner approach to get people skilled for both dev and ops but turns out people don't like learning new skills as much as they claim. So its meaning differed from org to org and even within the same company.

stroebs 6 days ago |

So far in my career:

- DevOps Engineer (Junior, Senior, Staff)

- Systems Development Engineer

- DevOps Team Manager

- Cloud Infrastructure Engineer

- Site Reliability Engineer (+Lead)

All have been meaningless except for Cloud Infrastructure Engineer. The rest described a generalist who knows how to deal with ambiguity and (usually) has the trust with things like AWS root account credentials. Most organisations have no idea what real DevOps is. If they did, they wouldn’t hire for a “DevOps Engineer”

verall 6 days ago |

The chart has "Systems Engineer" and "Systems Programmer" and te text even calls out different meanings of "systems engineer", but it misses both the independent field of systems engineering, which is not a software job and all, and the title "systems software engineer", which are SW engineers that write "systems software" i.e. drivers, kernel, OS.

rester324 5 days ago |

I need to point out that these titles are very much culture specific. For example in the japanese work culture regardless of whatever experience, skills and certificates you have, you are just a software engineer, an idiot who is treated like a low IQ moron and paid in peanuts (OK, I am strongly exaggerating, but not that much in reality sadly :/)

Zaheer 6 days ago |

Co-founder of Levels.fyi here. We think about this problem space a lot in developing our own taxonomy: https://www.levels.fyi/t

One of the hardest things is that the same title (and level) can mean very different things across companies, industries and over time. When collecting pay information, we take great care to merge titles that mean the same thing while distinguishing those that don't. There's other edge cases like at some companies a title will be more specific (Security Engineer), while at others they'll retain the general title (Software Engineer) but specialize in the same thing (Security).

Claude has been really helpful in wrangling this all and expanding our taxonomy :)

gmoque 6 days ago |

I enjoyed looking back at my 20 year career through roles. I've done a few of them crossing domains twice. The tree should be seen as a constant evolving graph. There will be a plethora of new roles in the coming years.

For those who think Software Engineering roles are extinguishing, they just need to realize roles will evolve into something new. My current role (SRE) was a nascent niche at the start of my career and I didn't even know about it for many years.

SoftTalker 5 days ago |

I've always just called myself a "computer programmer." Never was much concerned with what HR called me.

torh 6 days ago |

I can't see Operations Manager listed, yet I've had that title for the last 15(?) years.

chadk 6 days ago |

Surprised “Web Designer” didn’t make the cut. That is what we were often called between being a Webmaster and Web Developer.

temporallobe 6 days ago |

I’ve always been “software engineer” or some variant thereof, but always with the implication that you pick up any tech stack and learn it well enough to be productive. Often it was not the new programming language(s) that were challenging, but some really difficult black box tool (API, platform, database, framework, etc.), and even MORE challenging, the unnecessarily complex development environment.

ykl 6 days ago |

Where does “Member of Technical Staff” fit on this tree? At the bottom should all arrows just feed into “Member of Technical Staff”?

bluerooibos 5 days ago |

Cool! Not mobile friendly though - can you make the diagram zoomable with touch screens?

jsrcout 6 days ago |

It's fascinating seeing all these in one place with the relationships and over time. I'd love to see one with the less formal titles (I like to go by "developer" personally though it's not my job title), but it would be gigantic.

backend_dev82 6 days ago |

Would be nice if I could actually see it. I cannot zoom in, zoom out or do anything with it.

estetlinus 6 days ago |

I’ve not been in the industry that long, but feel it’s so awkward that devops is in the operations silo. What happened with Development & Operations? Every place I’m at, the devops team is a bottleneck and everyone kind of accepts it.

jensgk 6 days ago |

Before data scientist, there was data miner or data mining engineer.

smcleod 6 days ago |

In my 20 years I've been the following (in order):

  - Technician
  - Systems Engineer
  - Senior Platform Engineer
  - Lead Platform Engineer
  - Principal AI Engineer

yieldcrv 5 days ago |

I a/b test titles on my linkedin every other month to the trendiest of trendiest terms

sometimes I hypothesize terms and roles, like a astro physicist imagining celestial objects that cant be detected for another 100 years

and that works too sometimes, you have to assume there is a mismatch between what employers want and what talent does

my background remains the same just what I’ve been doing the last 2 years gets radically reimagined

fffrantz 5 days ago |

I guess telecom engineer has been kind of a grab-all title for all kinds of jobs that are telecoms related but not enterprise networking. I’m a telecom engineer (telecommunications eng. diploma and all that jazz) but I deal with such ancient (PDH & SONET, yay!) and arcane stuff that no current job title would work.

Funny how an almost 100 years old title is still relevant today.

ctrlaltdileep 6 days ago |

This was interesting to look at. I know it's not supposed to be perfect but it certainly does make one think about the career routes available. What surprised me was how short the path was for security to getting into the C-Suite. Although I do feel like most people become security analysts, then ISOs. Also I didn't realize that tape librarians were still a thing.

littlexsparkee 6 days ago |

IME, you see changes in numbers over time but the titles data analyst, data engineer, analytics engineer, data scientist are all still around. data platform engineer or SWE data seems to be stable as a systems role but anecdotally there is less demand for data roles now due to AI (either believed capability or deferred hiring to understand near term needs).

nkapias 5 days ago |

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21591441

Somehow linked, I find both resources complement each other.

livinglist 6 days ago |

I think there should be more domains included other than mobile/backend/frontend, there’s software engineers working on robotics/graphics/aviation but not necessarily embedded engineer

mgaunard 5 days ago |

What would be more interesting would be going deeper on the software engineer titles.

Team Lead, Engineering Manager, Architect, Head of Engineering...

Everyone has a different view

thomasqbrady 5 days ago |

Where my Design Engineers/Design Technologists at?

weinzierl 6 days ago |

As a kid I always wanted to be a SysOp. Not that I knew what it was, all I knew was it had to do with computers and sounded cool. That was enough.

giantg2 5 days ago |

I would say you're missing the whole Compliance spectrum, such as IT Control Analysts, Internal IT Auditors, etc.

yuppiepuppie 6 days ago |

These days I half-jokingly (it’s on my slack profile “position” field) refer to my self as a Serious Product Vibe’ineer.

Where does this fit in on the chart?

pkthunder 5 days ago |

Really digging the interactive graphviz diagram, would love to know more about how you threw it together.

undefined 6 days ago |

undefined

tayo42 6 days ago |

> When I’m asked what the difference is between a DevOps engineer, an SRE and a platform engineer, the honest answer is always a little history lesson. This is the shortest version of that lesson I’ve managed so far.

Unless you talk to a recruiter and they say something like your more of a SRE then a DevOps engineer and we really need a devops engineer. Insansity

CSMastermind 5 days ago |

The switch to the terminology of "forward deployed engineer" to replace consultant has been overwhelming. Almost certainly driven by the bad connotations that the title consultant has. Makes me wonder how long it will take to burn through any positives associated with that title before they switch to something else.

I've also seen a huge number of data scientists rebrand as "AI engineers" so I agree with that title's placement in the chart but I think that ultimately that's the wrong place for it to live. I'm convinced that AI Engineer will be a specialization of backend engineering since the work to integrate agents into production systems will be backend work not model training or other data tasks.

dmd 6 days ago |

My first paid job, at 21, in 1999, was "Senior Network Operations Engineer".

I've never been able to take "senior" seriously since.

zekenie 6 days ago |

Where’s member of technical staff?

kristianc 6 days ago |

> In 1947 coding was the clerical bit, and the real work was in the planning.

A tale which of course, flatters the planners…

janpeuker 5 days ago |

Odd that levels such as "Senior Software Engineer" are on a timescale (they should just be removed) but others such as "Technical Lead" are not even in the core. Classic Example why AI-generating this looks nice but doesn't actually offer much insight.

I'd much rather have seen how "Architect" developed and merged back; similarily how "SRE" (and Platform Engineer) following its idea "when you treat operations as a software problem" merged System Administrators with Software Engineers; or how Full Stack Engineer with AI now has gone back to Product Engineer.

b800h 5 days ago |

It's funny. As late as 1995, careers books in UK schools were still listing only "Systems Analyst" as a viable job in computing. Never pay any attention to school career advisors.

bee_rider 6 days ago |

Software is mostly human-defined. The complexity mostly comes from understanding the meaning of a large corpus of existing text, and then building your thing on top of existing human-created conventions. Therefore, I suggest we start calling ourselves Software Lawyers, Software Judges, and Software Legislators. This is a much more sensible set of titles than “software engineer” and “architect,” and it will probably cause less confusion and pointless bickering.

pmg101 5 days ago |

I'm glad someone's done this! I've been a paid programmer since graduating in 1999 and every time I change jobs I find that the title has changed behind my back and everyone is acting like today's titles have existed forever with an immutable and universally agreed meaning and scope, meanwhile I just turn up and be the human/computer conduit as always.

davidw 5 days ago |

"Forward deployed engineer" sounds like it comes from people who spent too much time fantasizing about military crap.

lorenzohess 6 days ago |

Where is Prompt Engineer?

oldjohnnylane 5 days ago |

I worked in SWE for 35 years and the only titles I was given were: junior, senior, staff, senior staff, principal, lead principal, and senior principal. All followed by “software engineer”. I guess I never worked at companies that used all these fancy names.

boredumb 4 days ago |

the last couple weeks i've started applying around after quite awhile of working somewhere full time and I've been kind of sitting back and only applying to places I'd be personally be stoked to work at and... the job titles are bordering on that old meme web site - startup job title generator or something to that effect. I'm just wanting to build cool stuff even if that means being a senior staff applied ML forward deployed customer success engineer.

logical3 5 days ago |

Funny how software roles keep splitting into specializations, then merging back under new titles. The responsibilities haven’t changed nearly as much as the names.

cobychapple 5 days ago |

Interesting how disciplines critical to good software like Product Design, Service Design, Interaction Design, Content Strategy etc are just… not represented.

bszczyglo 5 days ago |

I always have a problem to name myself, I've done too many things for too long..

scaramanga 5 days ago |

No systems analyst? Likewise, no rockstar ninjas or whatever? :)

undefined 6 days ago |

undefined

classified 5 days ago |

Great project! I love that you can download the Graphviz source.

ichorio 6 days ago |

Jokes on you, I'm a Senior Systems Engineer.

MuhammedBasith 5 days ago |

interesting how the same title can mean completely different things depending on the company.

andreygrehov 6 days ago |

Member of Technical Staff is missing

xstas1 6 days ago |

What's the source of this data?

bodash 5 days ago |

Another path: “fullstack” -> “product engineer”

undefined 6 days ago |

undefined

oh_my_goodness 5 days ago |

Folks. Job titles don't mean anything. You know this.

firesteelrain 6 days ago |

[dead]

undefined 6 days ago |

undefined

ZeroDayDreamer 5 days ago |

[dead]

joel-ryhive 5 days ago |

[flagged]

junglistguy 5 days ago |

[dead]