Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

SpaceX catches the Starship to end Flight 15 (https://www.spacex.com)

1763 points by ls612 6 days ago | 1494 comments | View on ycombinator

Zigurd 5 days ago |

I've been a frequent critic of starship. But the significance of this milestone is clear: it's the first demonstration of a reusable upper stage of a rocket system since the space shuttle.

Part of the importance is due to the fact that while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive. It required a lot of expensive refurbishment between missions. Launch cadence had a fairly low upper bound. And it wasn't safe enough.

The true believers will claim that catching a starship upper stage marks a new era. It marks the possibility of a new era. It proves it is plausible that a vertical landing upper stage could possibly be a better approach than a space plane. But it hasn't proven any of that. There are about a dozen major milestones between here and actually having a rocket system that meets all of its claimed specifications, both technical and financial. Here's just one big hairy example: to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.

In my estimation, it will take at least another five years to know what starship really can do and what it will cost.

small_model 6 days ago |

If the heat shield holds up then this changes everything. Next step is double catch and re-flying the same ships and catching again, then payloads to orbit become significantly cheaper opening a new era in space flight.

ChuckMcM 5 days ago |

Huge congratulations to the engineering team on this one! It's been quite interesting to watch the evolution of Starship. Had they put another couple of tonnes of propellant and oxidizer on the Booster they might have caught both of them. It is still unclear to me what the final mass fraction to orbit will work out to be, but something that is 100% re-usable is better than something 60% reusable[1].

[1] Estimate of Falcon 9's booster + fairings being 60% (by cost, not by mass) of the launch package.

BiraIgnacio 5 days ago |

To everyone who works at SpaceX and read this. You are all amazing.

I hope other great minds at SpaceX are well remembered into the far future.

DarmokJalad1701 6 days ago |

Insane achievement! It is the dawn of a new era! One that has been 10+ years in the making.

codeulike 6 days ago |

I like that they wrote "dont panic" on the fuselage above the s42 badge

GMoromisato 5 days ago |

Starship is, essentially, Space Shuttle done right: fully reusable booster without solid boosters (avoids Challenger disaster) and orbiter stacked on top instead of on the side (avoid Columbia disaster).

The original designs for the Space Shuttle had the booster (with wings!) return to the launch site, but the cost for two new crewed vehicles was too large, so they scaled it back to the compromised version.

Even more revolutionary, compared to Shuttle, Starship is built on an assembly line. They can build a booster ever 4 weeks and a ship every 2 weeks.

The future we were promised in the 1970s is about to become real.

m4rtink 5 days ago |

Just watched the catch stream live on the dome of a local planetarium - really feeling history is being made.

It was all so symbolic, they just had a talk about the Voyager probe reaching one light day from Earth accompanied by screening of the Startrek movie (which includes V'ger/Voyager) and ad hoc decided to stream the catch just after the movie ended.

Was a really surreal experience, first watching the tiny Enterprise zooming around the vast V'ger spacecraft only to see Starship zooming through the clouds and getting caught, all on the same planetarium dome projection! :-)

thinkingemote 6 days ago |

If this makes even me want to go study engineering I know it will inspire millions of youngsters into making the future we all want. Bravo!

reactordev 6 days ago |

The engineering of this is just mind boggling awesome. The culmination of so many fields, so many factors, to this. Congrats!!!

edekozar 5 days ago |

Interestingly, there's a similar large "block" recovery rig in the South China Sea. They use two sets of steel cables running in the X and Y directions — visually it's a lot like the Japanese cat's cradle string game. From a quick search, it appears to have shown up after SpaceX's chopsticks catch. Different engineering approach, but the same idea of catching the returning stage in a grid rather than with arms.

losvedir 6 days ago |

Watched it with my 5 year old daughter (3 year old son was sadly uninterested), and we were both cheering and high fiving. Very exciting.

claude-ai 6 days ago |

So precise it was almost boring - incredible work. Kudos.

niek_pas 5 days ago |

Does someone with more knowledge than me know if the co2 emissions from these kinds of rocket launches are big enough to make frequently launching and re-launching rockets into space a problem re. climate change? That’s a refrain I hear frequently but have no idea how true it is.

delichon 6 days ago |

Congratulations to the steely eyed missile men and women of SpaceX.

gdubs 5 days ago |

The "Baby Come Back" soundtrack really brought this home for me. What an incredible achievement. Very moving.

somebudyelse 6 days ago |

I imagine this is what it was like to witness Apollo 11 55 years ago.

brianzelip 5 days ago |

Unbelievable that this post is about a video showing technical history being made, but the video[0] doesn't show in Firefox.

[0] Clicking the "Watch" button (`.spx-button.primary`) on the OP.

ryzvonusef 6 days ago |

Holy ship, it was picture perfect capture!

Narishma 6 days ago |

Do we know why they didn't try to catch the booster?

tweakimp 5 days ago |

What is the advantage of catching over just landing it?

andsoitis 6 days ago |

That was incredible to watch!

Huge congratulations to the team.

lovvtide 6 days ago |

We witnessed history today

rpmisms 6 days ago |

The heat shield looks very good. Excited to see how much work it will take to fly this again. I'm in awe. I like the future sometimes.

anuptalwalkar 6 days ago |

This is absolutely incredible!! I can’t wrap my head around this.

yokoprime 6 days ago |

That was incredible impressive, what a feat of engineering!

pbw 5 days ago |

If you ignore the scale it doesn’t seem all the impressive. But the scale is bonkers.

comrade1234 6 days ago |

Ah man I just missed it. The live feed is just stock footage. Any links to the catch?

inglor_cz 6 days ago |

Damn, that looked smooth and glorious. This is how I'd like the future to be.

ceejayoz 6 days ago |

Damned impressive.

iharhajster 5 days ago |

Anyone else have trouble watching this 8 hours after? I tried on SpaceX page, X, only YT seems to work fine.

I connect from EU.

james_anderson 6 days ago |

Best thing ever built and it works!!!

le-mark 5 days ago |

What amazes me is how many Raptor 2 and 3s are sitting on the bottom the gulf and the Indian Ocean. Dissecting a Raptor 3 in particular would be a real cheat code for anyone wanting to know how to build something similar! Metallurgy alone would be huge!

ETH_start 5 days ago |

The amount of stress that these vehicles go through as they ascend to orbit and then descend back through the atmosphere to the surface is mind-boggling. To create a rapidly usable vehicle that can do this pushes the limits of material science.

ml_comms_eng 4 days ago |

You can pilot Starship to try to land it too https://www.dockship42.com

childintime 6 days ago |

How many years until the next milestones?

- in orbit refueling

- moon landing

- Mars rendez-vous

- Mars landing

- humans on Mars

Nah, the game is to put data centers in space. Plus the Space Force dreams.

kristofarkas 5 days ago |

There hasn’t been anything like this in humanity for a very long time. It’s so emotional to watch and see what we are capable of and the bright future ahead of us. Thank you for everyone who made this happen.

undefined 5 days ago |

undefined

rvz 6 days ago |

This is exactly the most impressive feat of engineering I have ever seen.

Only catching both the booster and the rocket would top this one. But the rocket only being caught is still impressive regardless.

SpaceX below $1T is criminally undervalued.

pxmpxm 6 days ago |

You can see a plane passing underneath it at video timestamp 22:44:43!

aksss 5 days ago |

Once the drone ship landings were incredible (they still are!), but now they’re normal.

I can’t wait for the time in the near future when catching starship and its booster is old hat.

Amazing day today!

quotemstr 6 days ago |

Impressive how reliable they've made those engines!

hinkley 6 days ago |

I know engineering is about expediency, and price, but I’m still bummed that we aren’t getting ships with landing gear in this or likely the next generation of rockets either.

Seems that the heavier the rocket the more ground clearance to need to self-land, and so you can’t scale up the dragon’s landing system. I don’t think there’s anywhere near enough weight to shave off of the next rocket or enough specific impulse to add to bring the size back down.

t1E9mE7JTRjf 5 days ago |

does someone know what is different about this compared to them catching the thing they did before?

formvoltron 5 days ago |

Radiators are too big and too expensive for space datacenters to make sense. Also rather than depreciating a GPU, you'll be depreciating a GPU, massive solar array, massive radiator, electronics and housing, and the launch cost to get it all there.

AI likely becomes much more efficient on earth than making sense in space for the foreseeable future.

proee 6 days ago |

i wonder how much fuel was left over after landing? What is their safety margin in seconds of burn remaining?

freddealmeida 4 days ago |

While the real name of the rocket is 042.Don't Panic.

maxdo 5 days ago |

Curious what will be next 10x design? Nuclear propulsion? Same rocket made by robots ?

t1E9mE7JTRjf 5 days ago |

23:21:40 is when it happens

rpmisms 6 days ago |

Holy cow.

fierycatnet 6 days ago |

It's very impressive

arjie 6 days ago |

Magical era. What a feat!

sidcool 5 days ago |

Amazing, kudos SpaceXAI. You folks just don't give up!

abhikul0 5 days ago |

Picture perfect catch with amazing views all along!

extraextra 5 days ago |

Amazing achievement for SpaceX and for humanity

soorajsanker 5 days ago |

I feel the website deserves special attention!

jhrmnn 5 days ago |

It’s very cool and an amazing technological achievement. But I cannot stop thinking - do we need it? I know that’s a minority take. How much of a minority?

teravor 5 days ago |

will scaling the size of the rocket continue to be the way to go? will doing a three stage setup make sense?

jdprgm 6 days ago |

It's crazy how far you have to scroll to even see this on the front page of NYT.

traviswingo 5 days ago |

This is incredible. Huge respect for the engineering team. What a time to be alive.

As an aside, it’s been fun watching the number of UFO posts on Reddit while Starship orbited Earth. They all refused to believe it was SpaceX.

flowerlad 5 days ago |

Congrats to SpaceX engineers! But for those who are not fans of the guy at the top here's a video of Blue Origin landing their rocket. Competition is good! https://www.youtube.com/shorts/XjSmNf3y37U

panick21_ 6 days ago |

Kind of crazy to reduce the hardware on ship so much and move so much complexity to the ground. This can really only happen in a situation where anybody can throw out any dumb idea, because if you suggested this 20 years ago people would think you are an idiot.

neverrroot 5 days ago |

What great top comments in here. The others finally keep quiet. Facts speak for themselves.

thomastraum 5 days ago |

my 10 year old: "shame they can't fix their video player though" (the one on the x website)

iJohnDoe 5 days ago |

Amazing. Doesn't even look real.

Rover222 6 days ago |

New tech tree unlocked for humanity.

undefined 5 days ago |

undefined

dantheman 5 days ago |

truly an amazing accomplishment, such an exciting time. go spacex!

dejongh 6 days ago |

Legendary ♥

maxglute 6 days ago |

Feels good.

alcomatt 5 days ago |

I wish them good luck. Now we wait and see how many times they can do it without accident for either the ship or the booster. Propulsion by a controlled explosion is a fickle beast so I suspect the mileage will vary and I wonder how would future launch and landing failures (which I expect will unfortunately happen) will impact the programme in general.

Culonavirus 5 days ago |

Honestly if this thread had the actual number of points it deserved based on the kind of milestone this represents for humanity's future and access to space, it would be in the millions.

If you don't follow rocketry you can't possibly understand what this means.

This was the Trinity test.

And even if you hate Elon and all his businesses, this knowledge will proliferate. Either by talent movement / osmosis, by espionage or just being inspired ("if they can do it, maybe we have a chance as well").

Within a decade the average cost to LEO will drop 20x-50x and if you're not recovering both of your stages, you don't exist.

hparadiz 6 days ago |

This achievement likely changes the course of life in this solar system.

clivedup 5 days ago |

Can anyone explain this to an idiot like to me? I follow information tech, but am pretty ignorant on engineering/space.

I recall the SpaceX chopsticks catch from about a year ago, which looked great.

This looks similar (heavy thing lands smoothly on a platform) but I gather it's very different from the comments?

bluecalm 6 days ago |

SpaceX made me watch engineering feats live on stream. I love it!

ionwake 5 days ago |

Congratulations

metalman 6 days ago |

perfect. hyperbole failure moment

narayankunal92 5 days ago |

Nice, great

motionlessveloc 6 days ago |

It's difficult to underline how huge this is. This marks the first time in the history of rocketry that the upper stage of a rocket has returned home from orbit to a safe, upright landing.

(And to preempt the obvious objection: yes, maybe you can call the Space Shuttle an "upper stage of a rocket" if you squint hard enough, but it didn't do upright landings, its external tank was not reusable and even the Shuttle itself was effectively rebuilt from scratch at exorbitant cost each time.)

It's sad to see a lot of media missing the point, eg as I type this BBC is reporting this as "SpaceX successfully catches part of Starship rocket on its return to Earth".

Edit: corrected to note that the SRBs were reusable, but the ET was not.

laichzeit0 5 days ago |

Congratulations Elon Musk and to those who work at his company. He is a true visionary.

soiax 5 days ago |

"pls make a reusable rocket, make no mistakes!!" This is probably some AI slop rocket XD

Choad_20261104 4 days ago |

bee eff dee

kambleashitosh0 5 days ago |

nice

undefined 5 days ago |

undefined

WalterBright 5 days ago |

Congratulations to SpaceX and Elon Musk! Another huge step to the stars!

bmartin13 6 days ago |

I hope they can make significant progress before the socialists take over. They were practically begging for launch permits under Biden.

mipo256 4 days ago |

[dead]

Zerovault 5 days ago |

[flagged]

ahmedketata 6 days ago |

The most amazing thing i've seen in a while.

ethan_yue 5 days ago |

[flagged]

videcoder40478 5 days ago |

[flagged]

crib-award-cont 5 days ago |

[dead]

edging5198 5 days ago |

[dead]

temptemptemp111 5 days ago |

[dead]

AVTizzle 5 days ago |

[dead]

Zerovault 5 days ago |

[flagged]

seoaranks 5 days ago |

[flagged]

CurbStomper5 5 days ago |

[dead]

HAL3000 6 days ago |

Nice! I wonder how the engineering involved here compares to the engineering behind manufacturing TSMC chips (including ASML machines, Zeiss optics etc.). Which is harder?

As it seems building rockets has historically been a capital intensive business with low profits and limited demand, so there just wasn't much competition in the space industry.

quertyrecord74 5 days ago |

I am trying to understand what's the big deal about this, other that massive weight and the money involved. The way I see it is software controls the fuel output and motion control. The only other challenge I have been hearing about is the heat shield. Other that this what's really special about the spaceship. The number of modules and the complexity seems not that huge. Any error or miscalculation in here is very costly and that is the only thing seems to be the bottleneck here.

plussed_reader 5 days ago |

The traitorous handling by SpaceX of the starlink product with our allies makes me greatly anticipate nationalizing this corrupt business entity.

LunaSea 5 days ago |

Impressive feat of engineering but I have troubles getting excited about this and don't see the point in this endeavour.

madduci 5 days ago |

Has anybody access to.measures like how much CO2 (and other material) emissions costs this kind of Rocket Catch?

hsnewman 5 days ago |

They only have a 60% catch rate on the booster. The elimination of the landing feet has reduced it's reusability.

fnoef 5 days ago |

just finished watching the new documentary about musk. not that ive learned anything new. its so sad that engineering achievements like these are being shadowed, at least for some people like myself, with the figure that runs these companies.

nevertheless, the people who made it work should be proud of themselves.

cwkoss 6 days ago |

Reusable stages is very neat, but seems a little crazy to pay the tyranny of the rocket equation twice. I heard one person say that carrying fuel to land over the whole flight means it takes 23x more launches to get an equivalent payload to orbit.

Using modern technology, couldn't disposable first stages be produced much more cheaply than during the space race?

How much of modern manufacturing disposable booster's cost would be fuel vs metal?

MiroslavPokorny 5 days ago |

Starship is finished - jsut ask Elon, thats why he sold it.

baw-bag 6 days ago |

Do we just look past the failed primary booster objective? (I didn't write the brief)

Edit: Yes, ignore that bit.

ck2 6 days ago |

bet they used lidar

(let's see who gets the joke)

seriously though, do we know the names of the engineers who made this possible or is it a secret?

fghorow 6 days ago |

Congrats to the engineers.

(But lose the bastard at the top, OK?)

hgoel 5 days ago |

Congrats to the everyone involved (more than just engineers!).

Here's hoping Musk gets kicked before he sinks this project too, as he's already severely burdened it with his short-sighted fascistic endeavors. As a formerly very enthusiastic follower of SpaceX's activities the specter of Musk's evil beliefs really ruins the messaging of making progress for all of humanity.

nstents 5 days ago |

Elon Musk is a real life version of D.D. Harriman, the protagonist of Heinlein's The Man Who Sold the Moon. An excerpt taken from Wikipedia:

""I", he says, "would cheat, lie, steal, beg, bribe—do anything to accomplish what we have accomplished". Children donate money for a promise of all contributors' names engraved on a plaque left on the Moon. The names, however, will be microscopic in size. Harriman sells land and naming rights to craters, and plans to sell postal covers canceled on the Moon to collectors. He starts rumors that diamonds exist in moondust, intending to secretly place gems in the rocket to convince people that the rumors are true."

And anyone who's read Machiavelli knows what kind of man it takes to succeed at this level in non-fiction.

Given the fact that men of his abilities and motivations have existed throughout history, and will continue to exist as long as we have men, for all his perceived flaws I'm quite pragmatically relieved he is ensconced with a Western power rather than any other in the world.

Jtarii 5 days ago |

[flagged]

bambax 6 days ago |

[flagged]

7e 6 days ago |

[flagged]

varispeed 6 days ago |

[flagged]

amelius 6 days ago |

[flagged]