507 points by MacAnorak 5 days ago | 288 comments | View on ycombinator
legitronics 5 days ago |
Velocifyer 5 days ago |
Here are some other things that people are sensitive to: - CRI on white LEDs (and flourencents). CRI is how clean the spectrum is in comparison to the sun or a incandescent bulb, where the specturm is completely even. There are some CRI >=95 LEDs that are fine for most people however.
- Motion blur Motion blur on LCDs (such as ~50% of Nintendo Switch 2s) can hurt eyes trying to keep track of what is going on.
explosion-s 5 days ago |
It’s also odd to think about lack of ability to concentrate, and I wonder if screens cause this optically somehow but to a less noticeable degree even when less intense than this new one? (Independent distracting contents)
I noticed that adding a severe red filter to all my screens helped me significantly with the concussion and am also curious about that, would that impact the intensity of a refresh perhaps? Is blue light specifically the problem? I’m unsure but have a plethora of subjective experience.
I’m glad for this to enter public consciousness a bit and would love to see more research on the screen itself impacting our brain.
achr2 5 days ago |
kphorn 5 days ago |
I’m curious if this is a harmonic mode for a high speed PWM where pulses are either not even widths or the driver loses some power at the 240hz cycle. May perceive similarly.
I have a couple windows laptop workstations with high dpi OLEDs (one with 240hz refresh rate) that I love and don’t perceive this so I’ll have to check.
Telaneo 5 days ago |
I've never had issues with it other than when trying to film certain old displays, but then again, I've never had issues with PAL TV sets running at 50 hz interlaced, nor even old PC CRTs running at 60, which definitely was not 'flicker-free', so I'm probably on the far end of the spectrum compared to the PWM sensitive.
It's an easy thing to forget, as with many accessibility features. And it's going to suck to have the nominally best display be one you just can't use if want to not feel like gouging your eyes out.
LoganDark 5 days ago |
Zak 5 days ago |
amluto 5 days ago |
We’re no longer in the dark ages of flicker. There’s actual industry guidance: IEEE 1789. And 240Hz, at any respectable depth of modulation, does not meet the low-risk limit, let alone the no-observable-effect limit.
I am wondering whether this is actually just an amazing firmware goof: the reports seem to suggest that operating at full brightness mitigates the problem, which makes little sense for an OLED display. An OLED showing 50% (post-gamma) gray ought to drive the pixels the same way as an OLED at 50% brightness showing white. And this display supports HDR, so even 100% brightness white isn’t really 100%.
I’m wondering if a little engineering mistake snuck in: some (most?) LCD displays dim by PWM-dimming the backlight, and plenty of backlights have current-to-light transfer functions that inherently low-pass filter the light. If someone naively ported the same logic to an OLED (which doesn’t have a backlight), they might have implemented brightness controls by applying a 240Hz envelope to the pixel excitation waveform. This makes no sense at all as an actual implementation, but I can totally see an AI doing it and writing tests to validate it :)
Even if there is a genuine engineering factor that requires low frequency PWM, I bet Apple could mostly mitigate the problem by deliberately mismatching the phases. For decades, pre-LED stadium lights had rather extreme flicker at 120Hz, but it was tolerable because the overall system was engineered to roughly evenly split the lights between three electrical phases, giving an effective modulation depth near zero.
I haven’t seen one of these displays myself. I find 120Hz flicker to be extremely obvious and very very unpleasant, and if these displays really do modulate in a nasty way at 240Hz, I expect I’ll be able to see it, albeit rather less obviously than at 120Hz. Also, pretty much any modern phone can see this in slo-mo video mode :)
dbspin 5 days ago |
sobiolite 5 days ago |
tasuki 5 days ago |
orloffm 4 days ago |
snipem 5 days ago |
I had to return the Steam Deck OLED and LCD because their displays PWM was burning my eyes out. Sore eyes for days, having problems to focus properly. I hope this is a learning process and it will get better from the manufacturer side. But I hoped that after my personal Steam Deck fiasco as well.
Danox 5 days ago |
Another alternative, that Apple offered on their desktop screens was simply a higher resolution 5K or 6K XDR screen, which are some of the better screens you can get on a desktop computer depending upon what you are using it for, and I don’t mean to play time wasting games.
Single OLED in particular despite all its problems, is the favorite of gamers in the PC world. The previous screen, Apple offered actually is a better screen top to bottom… I prefer the 6K XDR but it and 5k despite being great screens have never been cheap. (the Internet is filled with people crying about the price most of whom thought Apple should sell it at the price of a cheap 4k screen). You got what you paid for which is a great Apple screen.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H43wnV-v7V0 Single OLED isn’t good enough long term. (Gamers will however claim it’s OK. 9 hours a day is 3285 hours in a year.
incrudible 5 days ago |
theSoenke 5 days ago |
xp84 4 days ago |
IDK if all such sufferers are this bad but I'm very grateful to not have this condition. There are soooo many things that trigger these migraines for them.
ltbarcly3 5 days ago |
On the other hand, half rectified LED christmas lights have noticeable flicker to me and can make me feel irritable and woozy.
My question is, when it's trivial to create a PWM circuit that switches at 20khz or higher, why do manufacturers continue using anything in the 60-500hz range that people seem to notice and complain about? Do they save 2 cents or something?
ggemac 5 days ago |
I got sensitive eyes and can sense even previous gens' pwm at 15kHz. At 240Hz, I can probably see the pixels turning on and off! Only joking obviously. But I can definitely perceive the unstable luminosity. I can easily spot the OLED screens from 15ft away.
Definitely not going to upgrade. Sadly, this is most likely going to be the standard for Apple going forward.
EugeneOZ 4 days ago |
iPhone: https://www.reddit.com/r/iphone/comments/xgan2y/iphone_14_di...
MacBook: https://www.reddit.com/r/macbookpro/comments/rh9bdm/semiwork...
And be careful with the mentioned "Display Pulse Smoothing (PWM)" option - it turns of "Reduce White Point" (and turning on "Reduce White Point" turns off the "Display Pulse Smoothing (PWM)"), but the UI doesn't reflect it - just close and open again the "Display" section in Accessibility to see it.
weinzierl 5 days ago |
My first computer had a 50 Hz (Hz not kHz) color monitor I spent hundreds of hours in very close proximity with and the flicker did not bother me.
When I fetched the machine from the attic some years ago and tried it I could not bear it for long.
It's hard even for myself to grasp, how my own perception could have changed so much.
wolvoleo 5 days ago |
Ps the reason DC dimming isn't used so much is because at least with white LEDs the color temperature tends to change when the DC level changes so it's complicated to calibrate the screen accordingly. In particular the screen gets warmer at lower settings. This can actually be welcome because these settings will be used more at night and a lot of people prefer warmer settings then these days. But it's something that the user should be able to control.
Not sure if this applies to oled too though.
whatever1 5 days ago |
My personal feud with OLEDs, is that even at very high resolution the fonts do not look as smooth and creamy as the equivalent IPS. It is like I can tell apart their subpixels.
For example I prefer text on my old iPhone 8 compared to my iPhone 17.
scottlamb 5 days ago |
Back in the CRT days, it always bugged me when a display's refresh rate was down at 60 Hz, but otherwise I think I'm not too flicker-sensitive.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/PWM_Sensitive/comments/1f9j3fi/pixe...
wahlrus 5 days ago |
For example, could we overlay a software dimmer while driving the panel at max brightness?
Or would it be possible to tune PWM settings from the OS?
Or would this be possible to tune with a firmware change?
Idk how these things work.
skocznymroczny 5 days ago |
Recently I switched from a 1440p IPS display which had no visible flickers on camera to OLED which has the flicker and the issues of headaches and dizziness came back. I can sometimes get used to it, but it's still straining more than the previous display did.
fumar 5 days ago |
a-dub 5 days ago |
it would be interesting to get a high speed camera and see if there's a difference in the temporal dimension as well as a careful analysis of the font rendering. it would be funny if there were some kind of metamer noise in there or something that only some people have sensitivity to.
i would also be curious if the matte display option solves it (or has solved it for anyone else).
undefined 5 days ago |
evanjrowley 5 days ago |
The only use case I can think of for this machine is testing iOS touch interactions without a physical phone. Just this one specific purpose and it's not one that would require prolonged use.
hypfer 5 days ago |
It's interesting but unsurprising that now _more_ technical issues creep in, given that the whole idea fundamentally was flawed. If given the necessary technical scrutiny, it would not have happened. Hence, that must've been disabled. Hence other such blatant oversights like this one became much more likely, given that any voice saying "dumb idea" was already pacified.
I of course have no idea how this actually went. I am just claiming that my headcanon is canon.
bob1029 5 days ago |
If you want to use PWM in an application like this you need to start at like 600hz. This is how fast the subfield drive on a plasma TV is.
I have to use incandescent lightbulbs for certain fixtures because I sometimes need a break from engineers who think they are smarter than me.
danbots 5 days ago |
jamesgresql 4 days ago |
I nearly took it back before my eyes settled. Good thing I didn't b/c best laptop ever.
ridiculous_fish 4 days ago |
klay_moon 4 days ago |
WhitneyLand 5 days ago |
In a rigorous blinded comparison, would the new OLED MacBook cause more physical discomfort than the mini-LED model? How to explain all the symptoms being experienced?
What’s most likely?
1. Real MacBook hardware issue
2. Nocebo. Expectation of PWM problems > real physical symptoms
3. False correlation. Real headaches/eyestrain but from other causes
How surprising would it be if the answer is not (1)?
grzes 5 days ago |
mono442 5 days ago |
behnamoh 5 days ago |
modzu 5 days ago |
gowthamgts12 5 days ago |
j45 5 days ago |
dostick 5 days ago |
alt227 5 days ago |
manoDev 4 days ago |
moose1300 4 days ago |
NetOpWibby 5 days ago |
doctorpangloss 5 days ago |
tomaskafka 5 days ago |
cnczeric 5 days ago |
neuroelectron 5 days ago |
danielliljeberg 5 days ago |
saldoran 5 days ago |
nullsanity 5 days ago |
lufasz 5 days ago |
temptemptemp111 5 days ago |
snypher 5 days ago |
intrasight 5 days ago |
So that tiny fraction of users would be well served with some other display and can either return their MacBook or use an external monitor if and when they find out that they're in that cohort.
logicallee 4 days ago |
Maybe they just let their rigol scope spit out 240hz, but 480hz worst case and I would actually say 960hz. I think what’s happening with the tandem oled is they both pwm at 480hz and 180 degrees out of phase giving effective 960hz when both are in use. Which appears to be most of the usable brightness.
Edit: I’m so confused.
“The PWM behavior is interesting, because we can see DC-dimming for all brightness levels. Usually, OLED panels use DC-Dimming only at higher brightness levels. The frequency is very low at 240 Hz, however, and this might be an issue for sensitive users, despite the DC-dimming. ” https://www.notebookcheck.net/Amazing-OLED-panel-Apple-MacBo...