240 points by nyc111 5 days ago | 154 comments | View on ycombinator
kmstout 5 days ago |
Arubis 5 days ago |
You can actually get other close-to-browser experiences with stuff like xwidget and embedded WebKit (https://emacsdocs.org/docs/emacs/Embedded-WebKit-Widgets) but generally it’s not worth the fight for commercial sites these days; everything is vibed and only tested against Chrome, so if you’re lucky they’ll load in other Chromium browsers and _maybe_ Firefox.
leoc 5 days ago |
jll29 5 days ago |
His motive is not mindfulness, but ideology.
krylon 5 days ago |
Then, recently, it hit me - w3m-mode has both tabs and session management. It somehow even displays images more reliably than Dillo. I wouldn't use it as my main browser on the desktop, but for my specific use case, it's perfect.
gib444 5 days ago |
cmrdporcupine 5 days ago |
I have more hope in projects like lem which implement new emacsen from scratch.
jmclnx 5 days ago |
I have yet to figure out how to get around those issues.
And a big plus, eww is great for resource limited systems like old 32bit laptops.
TacticalCoder 5 days ago |
I have a very easy solution for that: zero sound output from my main desktop/workstation computer. I mean: technically I leave the sound drivers and the sound on, but there's nothing connected to the output (so speakers / no headphone).
The deep underlying philosophical question being: "If a PC outputs audio to nothing plugged into it, does it make a sound?"
The answer doesn't really matters though. What matters is that it's a great way to not get distracted.
My main desktop emits, on purpose, no sound since... 20 years?
For the rest, I've got laptops.
meken 5 days ago |
Paired with a local on-device model would be pretty sweet.
sammy0910 5 days ago |
agumonkey 5 days ago |
stevenfoster 5 days ago |
hellllo about 17 hours ago |
shevy-java 5 days ago |
Well, he has a point - Google controlling so much of the www is bad.
On the other hand, it's not all bad only. While more and more youtube videos are crap, there are useful youtube videos. Many people use it for learning too and often that works as well. Using emacs as browser really does not fix the issue. Also, emacs needs a proper editor if it ever wants to be a good operating system.
jrmg 4 days ago |
pwillia7 5 days ago |
juujian 5 days ago |
keyle 4 days ago |
But emacs always felt like a whale.
xyst 4 days ago |
author clearly has spent any time in a discord server :)
ohaodha 5 days ago |
I think the idea that you do something in a more difficult or less convenient manner for the sake of "mindfulness" or "focus" is well-established, and what I hope for (and am always disappointed by the lack of) when reading such blog posts is an actually useful feature of the unconventional method in question.
The title of this blog post promises some usefulness from using Emacs as your browser, and upon reading, you discover that the "usefulness" is the inconvenience and impracticality of using it that way.
1vuio0pswjnm7 4 days ago |
"This has been momentously negated with EWW (or any terminal browser, lynx or browsh for the non-emacs users)."
"The internet is just a delivery mechanism, and for people that see it for what it really is, the internet has never been more alive. I truly recommend using the internet as if it was 1999."
"Even on my phone, I've stopped using javascript frontends and embraced using eww in emacs (in termux), only falling back to fennec for about 5-10% of usecases:"
"I find this way of using the internet far higher in signal than any other method, allowing me to look up information, read documentation, and produce more."
Every www user is potentially different so we cannot assume we know what websites each user needs to access
But the 5-10% figure matches own experience; in fact for me, it's less
I have been a daily text-only www user for 30+ years; I do not own a mouse, I stay in textmode, I don't use X11, Wayland or the like
From 1993-1999 I used lynx, I later switched to links. Today I only use links (customized, 1.4M static binary) as an HTML reader, I use other software to make HTTP requests and I have multiple self-authored programs to process HTML to SQL, CSV and plaintext
I rarely use the so-called "modern" browser. It's certainly not required to retrieve or submit information from/to HN
The so-called "modern" web browser is software controlled by so-called "tech" companies and/or companies advocating and enabling internet advertising. These entities promote "interactive" www use that supports data collection, surveillance and ad services
Perhaps that's why it's causing the author to be distracted
I prefer non-interactive www use
I use the www as a source for information retrieval (similarly, the author calls the www "a delivery mechanism")
The data collection, surveillance and ad services, tracking, telemetry and other BS targeted at www users by so-called "tech" companies relies on _interactive_ www use
Without Javascript much of the "interactive" BS disappears
The author calls the www a delivery mechanism
When using the so-called "modern" browser the www becomes a delivery mechanism for data sent involuntarily from users to so-called "tech" companies (data collection, surveillance, telemetry, tracking) and ads delivered to users
But the www can also be used a delivery mechanism for data from _original_ sources to users (information retrieval)
undefined 4 days ago |
serptail 5 days ago |
krishanjarvis 4 days ago |
enoch_hou 5 days ago |
jrootabega 5 days ago |
[1] https://www.reindeereffect.com/0002