140 points by waximabbax 5 days ago | 79 comments | View on ycombinator
lz400 3 days ago |
cloudbonsai 3 days ago |
1. You can contribute to rural areas in return for a tax credit, effectively allowing you to redirect a portion of your taxes to another town.
2. The most important quirk of the system is that you can choose any towns to contribute to. There is no requirement of previous residence or whatever. In fact, most people contribute to towns with which they have no personal connection.
3. This ended up causing tax competition among local governments. Quite a few towns started advertising expensive "gifts" to contributers ("Give us your taxes and we'll send you some goodies"). It went so far that some towns got banned from the hometwon tax system.
It was introduced with good intension, but resulted in a very inefficient tax system.
walrus01 3 days ago |
I've met several French people from small coastal villages who now live in Paris and it's been interesting to see that their perspective on Paris is basically:
a) The native Parisians think people from their area are country bumpkins.
b) The people who live in their hometowns almost universally think that Paris is dirty, crime-ridden, too crowded, too noisy, too expensive, etc.
It almost completely mirrors the attitude of certain small town Americans towards NYC or Chicago or LA.
guessmyname 3 days ago |
malikolivier 2 days ago |
As a farmer, Furusato Nozei is a great way to sell your goods. Basically, the town buys your goods at full price and send them as a gift to the tax payer. The town and middle men handle all the operations.
As a tax payer though, it seems to be a system that's very good for farmers and rural areas that can provide nice gifts in demand. However, it is probably a very inefficient way to allocate resources within the country as a whole. The system is obviously very good for the middlemen vendors, all taking their cut out of public money.
shioyama 3 days ago |
I live in a small city far from Tokyo, that desperately needs cash and that is bleeding youth to the bigger cities at a terrifying rate. But this is not the solution! Yes, paying taxes to where you live is not perfect. But furusato-nozei is so so much worse.
jubilee33 3 days ago |
I feel this is great system honestly and should be expanded.
It would be a direct public referendum of government behavior and spending through the only language they understand. Money.
zkmon 3 days ago |
This is really great idea and justice too.
For decades, the countryside in every country have sent off their youngsters to work for the country's economy. The real unsung heros are the rural families who spend everything on their children education and well being, only to be separated from their loved ones. It's not just families that got impacted; the entire communities, villages and districts became devoid of young work force who prefer to move to cities.
This was tolerated under the assumption that the cities provide better living conditions for the youngsters and the next generations. But cities survive in an ecosystem provided by the country side. Starve country side, you starve cities.
CarlitosHighway 3 days ago |
pastage 3 days ago |
https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kommunala_utj%C3%A4mningssyste...
andai 3 days ago |
I thought (briefly) about the consequences of this idea: different governments would then need to become concerned with "advertising"... or in this case ... sending their citizens cans of plums :) That's very cute.
stego-tech 3 days ago |
Love it. Would gladly do the same here in the States if it meant getting some delicious Pimento Cheese Spread from my hometown or tending to my grandparents’ gravestones.
Brian_K_White 3 days ago |
Schlagbohrer 3 days ago |
pinewurst 5 days ago |
cnczeric 3 days ago |
There's a limit of course, it's higher the more you make. The stuff in that page is typically overpriced by 3-5x but since its free, it's fine. In theory you buy meat and fruit and regional delicacies but lately there's lots of stuff including electronics and whatnot. There are some truly bizarre things too, especially if you sort by price and select the most expensive ones, my favorites are the 10m yen tier I'm going off my memory but I just can't forget these:
- A custom statue of yourself
- A sauna to install in your backyard
- A whole frozen cow
- A local celebrity from that town records whatever you want for a ringtone