Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Crows make decisions faster than we can (https://www.nytimes.com)

316 points by gumby 5 days ago | 216 comments | View on ycombinator

Animats 5 days ago |

Intelligence has evolved on Earth at least three times - mammals, corvids, and octopuses. All the mammals have roughly the same brain architecture. But the corvids are not on the same evolutionary branch, and have a different neuron design and a different brain architecture. "Such behavioral flexibility might seem unexpected because a layered cerebral cortex, the highest integration center in the mammalian brain, is not existant in birds."[1] So there's more than one way to do intelligence. Useful to know for AI purposes.

Octopuses have a much more distributed system than mammals, suggesting a quite different approach is possible.

[1] https://niederlab.org/Nieder%20(2017)%20COBS.pdf

WalterBright 5 days ago |

They might think faster because the brain is smaller - a shorter distance for connections.

For example, learning to play a piano is training the spine, not the brain. Because the feedback loop with the spine is shorter.

It's the same with dancing. One is trained to not look at one's feet, because the feedback loop is too slow.

whatever1 5 days ago |

They have to be faster than us. They casually fly at 40mph.

warrenski 5 days ago |

There's a wonderful book titled The Genius of Birds[1] by author Jennifer Ackerman which explores bird intelligence.

[1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25938481-the-genius-of-b...

taeric 4 days ago |

Speed of decision based on visual cues seems like it would have to be faster for anything that can fly? Would be neat to see them compared specifically to race drivers.

Similarly, I'd assume that any of the fast swimmers have a faster response time?

Is this not what people's priors would have been going into the idea?

xyos 5 days ago |

randomImmigrant 5 days ago |

Birdbrain should mean the opposite of what it does, for this reason, but for many others. Birds can sense the Earth's magnetic field and use it for navigation, a process that's about the one bona fide quantum biological paradigm.

Their body clocks are also significantly more sophisticated and decentralized than ours.

And in the end, the physical intelligence of flight itself demands a brain that's gotta be incredibly spatially and temporally aware.

I wish our brains had some of the skills and efficiencies of birds.

silverFork 5 days ago |

I have to agree but not just the crows.. The two parakeets that I owned as a kid were quite smart and would stir their own seeds to move the good seeds above the spent seeds with tooth pick that I had been using to scratch them. They would play with the tooth pick and grab it from each other. And they were affectionate and liked to snuggle.

They had complete trust in my family and not others. So they could tell the difference.

Intelligence is not about some IQ test.

0xBA5ED 5 days ago |

The title doesn't make sense because "bridbrain" doesn't imply slow decision making.

ljf 4 days ago |

I saw some slow motion footage of pigeons pecking seeds and what looks like mindless movement proves to be details sorting, choosing and then eating only the bits they select: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/fVoA5YxoqiM

Birds are hugely intelligent. I was lucky enough to have a pet magpie for a while, within a few days it was firmly part of the family and knew how to fit in with us.

inglor_cz 5 days ago |

Some of the traditional folk tale stereotypes seem to be correlated quite well to what we now know about bird cognition.

Hens/chickens are usually synonymous with "not very bright". Crows and ravens are usually depicted as smart and cunning.

bitwize 5 days ago |

I know more than one person who believe that certain birds, especially crows, ravens, and cardinals, are reincarnated loved ones bringing a message.

I don't share this belief, but the more we find out about avian intelligence, the less surprised we should be that people actually think this.

happyopossum 4 days ago |

Decision making speed is not correlated to decision quality in a deterministic way. Sometimes decisions that are made quicker have better outcomes than a 'more correct' decision made too late, but some decisions are more binary and time-to-decision doesn't change the outcome.

One would expect a creature with less ability to reason, and fewer factors to consider in decisions to make them faster.

chaostheory 4 days ago |

When you’re lower on the totem pole of life, aren’t your decisions much faster since there are less neurons and pathways to traverse?

Glyptodon 4 days ago |

Considering how quickly birds can move and how twitchy they are this does not surprise me at all.

undefined 4 days ago |

undefined

pineapple_opus 4 days ago |

Is it because they are more sensitive to the danger ? Given that they are "bird" they sense danger and fly immediately (which is in turn driven by their cognitive abilities).

NorwegianDude 5 days ago |

Despite the title, humans can react much faster than that. Gamers are commonly around 150 ms in visual response time.

Humans can make decisions and an action in less than 125 ms for very fast people.

Kinrany 5 days ago |

They really need to qualify "decisions" here, as quick decision making may very well reflect an automatic reaction with zero thought behind it.

bajard 4 days ago |

I remember the news when crows stole and collected anti-bird spikes to build their nests.

GreenLightGo 4 days ago |

I'd really love to have a pet raven. I've seen people keep them as pets.

hoppp 4 days ago |

I'm pretty sure cats make faster decisions than we can also

functionmouse 5 days ago |

Yeah, well... My SHARP pocket calculator turns on faster than my PC does.

amelius 5 days ago |

It's faster probably because their neural network is less deep :)

BubbleRings 4 days ago |

Aww, NYT or the researchers should have thrown together a website so readers of the article could test their own speed and compare it to the crows and monkeys’ speed. Show me don’t tell me! Grin. I would one shot vibe code it right now but it has been a long day. Who will be our hero?

InsidiousWombat 4 days ago |

But birdbrain doesn't mean you're slow, it means not very smart.

The "journalist" just really wanted to make article out of "smol brain processes faster"

wordsunite 4 days ago |

I had to double check to make sure this wasn't a new decision model. However, I do look forward to the new crow-themed models that will follow.

JackSlateur 4 days ago |

I am one of the faster decision-making living being on earth.

Bad decisions, yes, but decision-maker anyway !

partloyaldemon 4 days ago |

They can undercontribute to their retirement account at a speed mammals can only dream of.

newobj 5 days ago |

"eat like a bird" is also a misnomer. birds are so misunderstood

bozdemir 4 days ago |

Not just crows, chimps too, especially in memory tests.

tty456 5 days ago |

Maybe they use Jev

sooraj_sj 4 days ago |

does that mean you wann have crow as pet ? its a good choice just make sure it doesnt peck your head

randomNumber7 4 days ago |

The title is a misnomer. Redarded decisions are usually done fast. So birdbrain is very accurate for someone who does that regularly.

conartist6 4 days ago |

Another article I read recently said that Birds use anaerobic metabolism inside their eyes so that there's much less biological clutter in front of the rods and cones.

I wonder if this could also have something to do with it. The bird would presumably be sharper at spotting the pattern partly because our eyes are trying to pick it out from in the midst of other kinds of "floater" patterns that we're (very) used to filtering out

Havoc 4 days ago |

Vaguely related - yesterday I saw a crow dropping shellfish on concrete from a couple meters to crack it open.

...had heard about this but very cool to actually see it. Smart creatures

chiasabah 5 days ago |

Let me guess, must be either Jev or Clef

EmX_3000 5 days ago |

I hate popular science articles like this. Ummmmm listen sweetie, you're just ignorant and Ima police you a bit here... sit down for some really wild SCIENCEism!

Ugh.

vibebingo 5 days ago |

So can Jev!

dools 5 days ago |

Jev brained

likelybot 4 days ago |

[dead]

undefined 5 days ago |

undefined

Krea8ly 4 days ago |

[dead]