94 points by Skyfall106 5 days ago | 62 comments | View on ycombinator
II2II 3 days ago |
kqr 3 days ago |
I think we could be a lot better at using human sound, visuals, and spatial navigation abilities in understanding software systems too, but I've never gotten around to implementing anything despite plenty of ideas.
My latest experiment is using tones and/or speech synthesis artifacts to get insight into LLM agent operation -- ongoing reasoning, tool call success/failure, etc. Still haven't really dialed it in (hah!) to be useful yet.
ssl-3 3 days ago |
- Monitoring to minimize DTMF duration (S11 register, IIRC) and maximize redialing speed[1]
- Doing the same thing with dialtone and busy tone detection times
- Recognizing BBS callers by the unique sound of their modems, and using this to be annoying
- Surprising other BBS sysops who were themselves trying to call out, by issuing an ATA and dropping them into my BBS's login screen when I heard dialing instead of busy, ringing, or carrier tones
- Wardialing (I gave up on that forever when the voice from the machine said "911, what is your emergency?" and the usual automated hang-up-and-try-different-random-number routine did not disconnect the call, and instead produced an increasingly-agitated 911 operator)
[1]: A firmware update to the SupraFAXModem v.32bis allowed this timing to be so tight that the phone switch would miss digits, so tuning was in orderweinzierl 3 days ago |
I'm sorry I can't you give any of these either but I can give you a completely different explanation which makes a lot more sense to me (having lived at the time).
Early modems were so called acoustic couplers. That meant that they did not connect electrically to the telephone network but acoustically. Mechanically they were a bay you put the handset in and it had a microphone opposite the speaker and speaker opposite the microphone.
So, the speaker was already there[1] when (pure) modems became popular, it's just that the microphone disappeared over time.
[1] And so was all the software infrastructure to support it, like ATM and ATL commands.
glimshe 3 days ago |
It was the Discord of the 90s.
oivaksef 3 days ago |
DougN7 3 days ago |
paulstovell 3 days ago |
As a parent now, I wish my kids devices had such a feature.
curiousObject 3 days ago |
If we directly connect a speaker to a different data network format, such as Ethernet, we probably will hear nothing useful. Maybe some clicks and pops, or the smell of a blown speaker.
globular-toast 3 days ago |
mrheosuper 3 days ago |
I miss that era. Now if a mlcc can be cut to save a fraction of cent, it sure will be.
jleyank 5 days ago |
soneil 3 days ago |
> At one point, the NCC staff picked up on a particular modem that appeared to be malfunctioning whenever the auto-dialer ran its check. Someone suggested placing a call through the auto-dialer to the troublesome modem, while a technician listened in; perhaps he could diagnose the signal coming back. So he placed the call, listened for the modem to pick up, and heard an angry voice on the other end of the line. Before slamming down the receiver, the voice is reputed in countless retellings to have said, “Hey, Martha, it’s that nut with the whistle again!”
hallgrim 3 days ago |
jwrallie 3 days ago |
I was still using a 56.6 kbps modem long after with a Windows XP era machine, it sounded much worse, and usually had a longer negotiation beep sequence that ended up with an actual speed a little bit short of its maximum.
russfink 3 days ago |
browningstreet 3 days ago |
Also, if there were issues connecting, you could get a sense from the sounds. Sometimes it told you there were hardware issues afoot and you’d be better off taking a BBS out of the dial rotation for the evening.
(You could redial a group of BBS’ to increase your odds of connecting, as opposed to redialing a singular BBS continually…)
timonoko 3 days ago |
tomkarho 3 days ago |
mannyv 3 days ago |
I still remember the 'bung bung' of either the f.fast or the other 56k protocol.
ChrisArchitect 5 days ago |
If you're going to be posting old things, add dates to them please
spl757 3 days ago |
edit to say
CONNECT 9600
that was elite back in the day.
edit 2: the sound was completely optional, and could be toggled on and off with an AT command.
GenerWork 3 days ago |
Mashimo 3 days ago |
ehnto 3 days ago |
gjvc 3 days ago |
snthpy 1 day ago |
undefined 5 days ago |
jmspamerton 3 days ago |
gjvc 3 days ago |
Those speakers were there for diagnostics of various types. One of them was figuring out when a person picked up on the other end.