Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Old Bitly links are being hijacked (https://ransomnews.com)

380 points by hspeiser 5 days ago | 205 comments | View on ycombinator

xp84 4 days ago |

Link shorteners that are outsourced are in my humble opinion an order of magnitude worse for the internet than they would be if in-house.

The way they accrete URLs over time, and then time passes, and anything can happen (your account gets deactivated, shortener company goes out of business / experiences catastrophic data loss / etc) is just asking for permanently broken links which may be unfixable.

Especially when you consider how these services can, unless they're spammy enough to inject gross interstitial ad pages, make 0 revenue from you if you aren't currently paying for a premium service, it's easy to see how they can go under.

Note: Clearly with the kind of ephemeral crap these 2011 tweets were, I'm assuming the 'attacker' publicized "Hey guys look at these funny tweets" because obviously who cares about 15 year old McDonalds marketing messages. But in general it's sad to see these still being used. To be fair to bitly, they do offer the ability to use your own domain at least, but sadly, with a service targeted mainly at marketing departments, usually they don't have the ability to work with the in-house tech team(s) to even set up DNS.

101008 4 days ago |

Short anecdote: Famous author (with huge fanbase!) used a Bit.ly link in one of their books (the narrative needed a fake tweet with fake link). Editor didn't notice/care and never registered it. I noticed on release date, caught it and redirected it to a website that referenced the book, a few people tweet about it thinking the author used the link on purpose!

silisili 4 days ago |

I think the biggest surprise to me is that a URL shortener makes enough money to have a Trust and Safety team. I assumed it was just a side project a person or two ran.

g-b-r 5 days ago |

Somewhat related, I've been getting a lot of spam with links to urls of big, reputable, organizations, such as universities.

You'd think that the organization was hacked, but in all these case instead these were old domains that used CNAMEs.

The domain that the CNAME pointed to was once owned and used by the organization, but at some point it was let go, and it ended up being purchased by the spammers.

So, the spammers were able to use links that looked safe, and maybe that also helped with passing spam filters.

Thus, if you manage domains, please keep track of the ones with CNAMEs, recommend the users to tell you when they stop using them, and maybe check every once in a while (better if automatically) that the domain they're pointing to hasn't changed hands.

I'd be curious to know how the spammers find these old cname domains, by the way.

Alive-in-2025 4 days ago |

There's a lot of abandoned url ownership things on the internet. We need something like a bureau that keeps track of what it was for. We do have archive.is or .org to save the content at a url (side note - are these archivers legal or in some country that allows this?).

I do often come across an article occasionally where someone is writing about a narrow topic that I'm interesting in, but I can't find them any more - maybe they had a vauge user name that isn't resolvable.

You have sites trying to block spammers, but you have over-active groups like Reddit that seem to delete accounts aggressively with no information about what you did wrong. I want a meta id that I own, that people can check I'm the real "foo-bar1418", and that can't be deleted or taken over.

It feels like there's still room for a super-crosssite-ID. But there are also spammers, haters etc that sites have to deal with.

5kyl4b 5 days ago |

this is why i have always been against link shorteners :)

itintheory 4 days ago |

This reminded me of the fact that bit.ly links used to be (maybe still are?) case sensitive. I got a bill in the mail that suggested to pay I could got to https://bit.ly/SomeCompanyPayBillOnline so naturally I tried registering bit.ly/somecompanypaybillonline and sure enough, those were considered separate shortlinks. I suspect most that when typing in a URL, most people assume it's case insensitive, so this was probably pretty effective.

sparkling 4 days ago |

>"and is disabling the affected links."

Wouldn't it make more sense to restore the original destination URL?

__MatrixMan__ 4 days ago |

Globally unique human friendly names are more trouble than they're worth. Sooner or later their referential integrity falls to corruption or neglect. We'd be better of with cryptographic hashes on the wire and user configurable pet names in the UI.

logicallee 5 days ago |

What's the value proposition of link shorteners? I mean, why do companies, or customers, use them?

cubefox 4 days ago |

A bigger issue perhaps than some old links now redirecting to scams is large scale link rot. The scam problem does already exist for normal links when the domain is not renewed and the new owner points it to a shady website. But link rot is a wider problem: if one link shortener ceases operations, a huge number of links will just no longer work, and it will usually no longer be possible to find out what content they were linking to, because you can't guess it from the domain name and URL slug as you would from a normal dead URL.

1potato 4 days ago |

This sort of thing is not rare; link rot is how a lot of websites get compromised. I recently had to clean up the Shopify site for a client that's been on the platform for quite a few years. The site was occasionally redirecting visitors to all sorts of shady domains.

The cause was an old Shopify app, which pulled resources from an external domain that had expired and been reregistered.

I’ve seen it on WordPress plenty of times, but I kind of thought that Shopify apps were held to a higher security standard.

iamthejuan 4 days ago |

Mine was hijacked by bitly itself, I have a username "username" and they just decided to delete it without any notice and make it unavailable.

hspeiser 5 days ago |

rvz 5 days ago |

Link shorteners are just waiting to get abused.

Imagine if someone is using curl | bash on a shortened URL because "it's too long" and you can't see where the link is going.

undefined 5 days ago |

undefined

1970-01-01 4 days ago |

Isn't this just a subcase of people thinking all links are diamonds (permanent and forever)?

kinduff 4 days ago |

I remember when link shortening services were a thing. I built my own around 2008 due to Twitter content limits.

tonymet 4 days ago |

This is a lesson for any entry point including usernames , subdomains, url slugs. Anything of value will be abused.

j45 4 days ago |

The convenience of link shorteners is one thing, running them on your own domain seems to still make the most sense.

OgsyedIE 5 days ago |

The tweet that McDonald's Sweden is proud of what they've achieved, redirected to the Wikipedia page for 9/11, is probably the most quintessentially 'Gen Z' joke to the point that dictionaries ought to use it as the example.

Seattle3503 4 days ago |

Is there a version of this "article" not written by AI? Feels like this was just an AI scraping twitter and writing an article.

sodapopcan 4 days ago |

Isn't Twitter's original "feature" or short "content" how URL "shorteners" (dang technology making us say ridiculous non-words with a straight face) came about? With that framing, this is pretty funny, at least to me. Well ok, I find this very funny regardless of how we got here.

zygentoma 4 days ago |

This "article" is just direct LLM output ... Not even from a prompt like "write an article"

joshu 4 days ago |

rustygorgon 4 days ago |

My god. Who could have seen this coming.

zekodun 4 days ago |

Oh good.. maybe they can take over some of those old Rick rolls, 2 girlz... and goatse meme links.

faheen12 4 days ago |

Thats really bad nowadays with the help of AI many big websites are taken down

ares623 5 days ago |

We used to worry about link shorteners. We still do, but we used to, too.

tgsovlerkhgsel 3 days ago |

This is likely but not certainly on Bitly: They claim that their shortener behaves in the sensible way (links are permanent and URLs not reused), but it doesn't seem to.

The only way for this not to be primarily Bitly's fault would be if the links were in accounts that allow links to be edited (as I understand it, that only applies to paid accounts) and someone hijacked the account using stolen creds.

The "article" mentions "At 09:18 UTC another user described the method in a post that has been viewed more than 46,000 times." but doesn't link the post or explain it (unless I missed the explanation in the slop sea)...

globular-toast 4 days ago |

Boring article about some pretty funny jokes.

thrownaway561 4 days ago |

The whole issue could be resolved if bit.ly just actually did what they said rather than lie.

aanesn 4 days ago |

that's why you should use https://shorter.dev to find your own short link(:

slopnt 3 days ago |

> We tested the method on links nobody disputes. A link whose creator says he made it in 2009 shows a 2009 creation date. A custom link tweeted by a YouTube channel on 21 June 2017 shows 20 June 2017. Among the Trump links that are still original, 32 of 40 were created on the day of the tweet or the day before.

Fucking AI prose

chostetler 4 days ago |

dawoodfr about 6 hours ago |

[dead]

jsonsocket 4 days ago |

[flagged]

Krea8ly 4 days ago |

[dead]

jazaff 4 days ago |

[flagged]