Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Zoltraak and the Dynamics of Military Innovation (https://jgeekstudies.org)

56 points by zdw 5 days ago | 14 comments | View on ycombinator

hatthew 3 days ago |

Listen I love Frieren but I'm not convinced this is a useful case study from a real-world perspective. The general idea of "innovation -> reaction -> adaptation -> reflection" is not particularly obscure, so I'm not sure we can learn anything from complete fiction. At best, it feels like an introduction to this concept for people who have already watched Frieren, in which case I'm not sure it needs such a formal tone.

I would be more interested in a detailed military tech case study in the real world, or a literary analysis of Frieren, both of which I'm sure already exist.

cdot2 3 days ago |

As someone used to reading more conventional articles about military innovation, this was quite the shock!

Another good example of this principal is the introduction of the use of offensive gas during WW1. This and other innovations being introduced and then countered lead to armies holding off on field testing of new weapons and TTPs until full utilization could be fielded in an effort to prevent the other side from being able to develop counter measures. Most notably, when the BAR was developed, General Pershing avoided fielding large numbers of the new weapon to US troops in the anticipation of building up large enough stockpiles of the weapon that it could be fielded en mass before the Germans could develop counter measures. Although it was developed in 1917 it was only briefly fielded in the last few weeks before the truce.

aizk 2 days ago |

As much as I enjoy the show and will click on anything on hn with content from the show, I feel this would be more approachable maybe as a substack, and slightly less formal. The the way the info is being conveyed feels dissonant, like a tritone. Though maybe that's the point? But you're doing something different / feels a bit like the old internet so that's a plus at the end of the day.

srslyskptcl 3 days ago |

7 points front page, no comments. What is this.

ptek 2 days ago |

I wonder if programmers have used Zoltraak as the name of some new US cyber tool? I guess we'll have to wait for the next leaks to find out.

They must be running out of names from Lord of The Rings?