970 points by DeepLogin 4 days ago | 556 comments | View on ycombinator
ilamont 4 days ago |
akudha 4 days ago |
Walk into any store (JC Penny etc) half the items are on sale. Even groceries - go to Safeway, there is a newspaper style coupons - multiple pages. This whole thing is just bizarre and tiring.
yathern 4 days ago |
Not just jacking up prices and having fake sale prices (they do that year round) - but a specific pattern to throw off naive URL or SKU based price trackers:
They delist old models, and add them back in, sometimes with different model names, but the same specs. The week before the big sale, there were hundreds of delistings, and the average price rose nearly $80 - so that the $50 off becomes an increase.
https://minipcs.zip/aliexpress-11-11-pricing-tricks/
I've been tracking Mini PC prices on Amazon for months now and am excited to see if the same pattern repeats for Black Friday. (There's other weird patterns on Amazon, such as listing the same PC 10 times with different prices, all from the same seller, I guess to profit from consumers who don't research much?)
everdrive 4 days ago |
tehlike 4 days ago |
Also most things you can find on AliExpress for cheaper. Don't do edibles, beauty products etc though. I limit my purchases to tools and electronics
getfacl 4 days ago |
One of my resolutions this year is to always search for independent sellers (online or brick and mortar) to compare before buying products on Amazon. In nearly all cases I have found a webshop with a better selection and a lower price, even after paying shipping.
cwoolfe 4 days ago |
nilsherzig 4 days ago |
newAccount2025 4 days ago |
ArchimedesFrsby 4 days ago |
dhbradshaw 4 days ago |
I later learned that $0.50 was the standard price for a single taco.
999900000999 4 days ago |
A 10% restocking fee, plus a bunch of stupid questions. It should be illegal to charge a restock fee unless you disclose that to me when I buy it.
I’ve never been charged a restock fee with Amazon. In fact I recall assembling a table wrong, and simply telling Amazon.
They refunded the whole cost as store credit.
Buying online has way less friction than going to a store and arguing for 15 minutes about what I really need and turning down financing options.
RIP retail, not sure if I miss you or not.
rdtsc 4 days ago |
inanutshellus 4 days ago |
The hope (and result) was that you'd find an amazing "deal" that enticed you to buy at all and once you had that in your cart you'd stick around and see what else we had to offer.
So... keep pervasive cynicism at bay as best you can, folks. :)
acomjean 4 days ago |
It seems those store liquidations are a giant scam. They seem to work though as the store was picked through.
Except tower records, I got some good metal shelving from them.
1970-01-01 4 days ago |
nrightnour 4 days ago |
Now it's just used as a free advertising board. 50% of restaurants on there have fake deals, and 5-10% force a prix fixe menu that costs you more than you would have spent normally.
Any affordable distribution/marketing platform will get abused eventually.
bityard 4 days ago |
It attempts to be a damning report, speculating that many households are waiting for holiday sales to afford necessities due to inflation. However, while they are quick to point out that their own data shows nearly 1/3 of the items researched were the same price leading up to the sale, and that about 1/10 of the items were priced higher, the corollary is that 2/3 of the items were truly "on sale" as described. They also did not differentiate between items sold by Amazon and those priced by third-parties through marketplace.
So customers still have to do their own price research (as always), and trust me I have MANY gripes about Amazon, but this is far from an obvious scam.
aborsy 4 days ago |
dubeyaayush07 4 days ago |
giamma 4 days ago |
So when Amazon (or any other shop) says "20% discount" it's easy to spot that the 20% discount is related to MSRP and that the product is regularly discounted 15%, therefore the actual discount is just 5% more and not a whopping 20% over the regular price.
hn_acc1 3 days ago |
stevefan1999 4 days ago |
For big business brands like Costco or Walmart, not so sure. They have stable income and they can issue investment grade corporate bond, so they don't need to use black Friday as a marketing gimmick, they could do this all day every day if they wanted. It's just the cost to acquire customer is different and they have the volume to amortize the cost
kinow 3 days ago |
I track these with spreadsheets (I know) and camelcamelcamel.com and idealo.es searches.
Most of the things I buy are art supplies, so I don't really buy on impulse as I am normally looking for a replacement extra brush or paint, before I actually run out of it.
dsparkman 4 days ago |
patrakov 4 days ago |
Latest example: I bought a Calibrite ColorChecker Studio spectrophotometer. Amazon suggested that a photo camera calibration target is a good addition, and offered a Mini ColorChecker Classic Target as an additional item to buy. I did so, without knowing that exactly the same target is included in the box. Now I have two.
rs999gti 4 days ago |
The Groundwork Collaborative is a Washington, D.C.–based progressive economic think tank, strategic communications hub, and issue advocacy organization founded in 2018.
gwbas1c 4 days ago |
About a decade ago, the state I live in used to have a "sales tax holiday" where, for one weekend, they would waive sales tax.
What all the retailers did was stop having sales for that weekend. Everyone still came, even though the normal sales usually took much more off than the tax savings.
AlexMC 3 days ago |
But with tools like Keepa, CamelCamelCamel, and others specific to the type of article you are looking for, it is still fairly easy to pick up the real deals. I always try to avoid impulse buys and set an alert at the price I'm willing to pay; it's what works for me.
And I do believe deals are still worth it in most types of articles; you just have to define the right tool/data to look at.
voidUpdate 4 days ago |
abeppu 4 days ago |
eth0up 3 days ago |
I always look at product reviews, unless I know the product well. I have my own formula for weighing them.
Recently, as a Prime member, Amazon blocked my ability to read reviews. I noticed a little popup beneath the sample reviews informing me that because I was "suspicious", I must appeal or request my privileges be restored. I did so, as well as made reports with the FTC.
After about a week, I was able to see reviews again. Their excuse was that some users abuse reviews and they figured I was one of them.
Plausible deniability by a very narrow margin. But verily criminal.
adrithmetiqa 4 days ago |
wolvoleo 4 days ago |
I don't care so much, I'm not in any hurry with most of them. I'll just bide my time. The black Friday thing is something we don't really have much with here, it was the retailers that tried to promote it, bringing it over from the US. Same with the Chinese singles day and others. But it's not a big thing for us here.
cmiles8 4 days ago |
Some things are a good deal but lots of stuff is just 30%+ more than what it would cost at a local store or other online retailers.
Oddly it makes little sense at times why some things are a lot more and others are cheaper. With its logistics network Amazon should be able to offer the best prices, but it’s definitely not consistently the best price. Not even close.
A lot of this is driven by FBA stuff that’s just folks reselling stuff at a markup on Amazon. It’s a double whammy of higher prices and search results full of 90% FBA junk.
MuGlobe 3 days ago |
thraway3837 4 days ago |
However, deals now run throughout the year and prices are usually better on random days so it pays to hunt the deal sites or social media. Physical stores also have better deals and are the only authorized dealer for a lot of brands. Big hardware stores also have 2 hour or same day delivery which is amazing. And you’re guaranteed to not get fakes.
assimpleaspossi 4 days ago |
"2 out of every 3 shoppers got savings"
and
"9 out of every 10 offers were cheaper"
which makes me wonder what the article is screaming about. It certainly doesn't sound bad at all.
apparent 4 days ago |
testbjjl 4 days ago |
origini 4 days ago |
If you want to buy something, use a price search engine and research the market yourself to get a good price.
legitster 4 days ago |
Amazon also used to stock a lot of off-price or liquidated products back in the early days of Prime - as they've scaled up those days are long gone
whackernews 3 days ago |
undefined 4 days ago |
ejb999 4 days ago |
clint 4 days ago |
ZiiS 4 days ago |
j45 4 days ago |
Online retailers are about optimizing their profits at all times and cases, not what customers want.
People can simply not spend and it will get their attention.
Some years, theres no deals.
Inflation is providing enough boosts in profit that they might not care to give out sales to make revenue.
Retail is about creating profit, not the product.
contubernio 4 days ago |
Yhippa 4 days ago |
fanwood 3 days ago |
TNNick 3 days ago |
yipinwong 4 days ago |
hyperbovine 4 days ago |
atmosx 4 days ago |
kittikitti 4 days ago |
stronglikedan 4 days ago |
ncruces 4 days ago |
lavendermon 4 days ago |
Whether or not a slashed price is actually a lower price has been debated for a long time, I don't find this "research" groundbreaking though it does help confirm some hunches.
I did find it fascinating that this news site hyperlinked itself within the first sentence of its own article.
bix6 4 days ago |
dofm 4 days ago |
(I did find my regular pair of shoes in one of the Prime Deal Days; I basically always buy a pair at that time of year to get new treads for winter, and then wear them flat throughout the year)
lowbloodsugar 4 days ago |
This isn't illegal. Every company does it. If you want to stop it, change the law. Most passive voters on earth.
WaitWaitWha 4 days ago |
As in, the prices for Amazon products, the article makes sense, but what percentage of the stuff on it is still Amazon? I assume (and, i do not know) that Amazon has some influence on the pricing, but not full control.
jghn 4 days ago |
ex1fm3ta 4 days ago |
prmoustache 4 days ago |
inshard 4 days ago |
camhart 4 days ago |
red_green_yell 4 days ago |
This analysis focuses on the top 50 promoted items on BFCM, which means we're talking about massive sellers from massive brands like kitchenaid, bose, ninja, etc. So maybe those huge brands get special treatment around these rules. But for joe shmo small sellers like us, the discount policies are strict and real.
Considering the insanely huge number of SKUs sold on amazon, drawing such broad conclusions from such a tiny data set is irresponsible and clearly for clickbait purposes. Their analysis uses Keepa data, the most famous pricing data aggregator. They could have easily broadened their query to the top 10k or 100k skus with minimal extra work.
I say all this as a small seller who's planning to de prioritize amazon because we just can't make a meaningful profit on the platform. So I have no love for the platform and agree with the criticisms of its buyer experience etc. But this article is so highly misleading it only serves to destroy the credibility of its authors.
maerF0x0 4 days ago |
subhro 4 days ago |
It sucks. :(
yellow_postit 4 days ago |
If you need it, and can afford to own it, buy it.
If you can’t, don’t let a supposed deal entice your purchase.
temp-amp 3 days ago |
sillypuddy 4 days ago |
anjel 4 days ago |
nazgulsenpai 4 days ago |
Topology1 2 days ago |
DudeOpotomus 4 days ago |
frabia 4 days ago |
ChrisMarshallNY 4 days ago |
Havoc 4 days ago |
These days I’m buying a lot of tech off eBay and aliexpress anyway. Pricing tends to be better
Grombobulous 4 days ago |
I’m not even sure I would single out Amazon for this practice. Fake markdowns are a tale as old as time. Just look at what happened when JCPenney tried to eliminate sales in favor of straightforward pricing. Customers hated it because they felt like they weren’t getting a deal, they weren’t getting rewarded for scouting out a “find.”
ChuckMcM 3 days ago |
On the one hand I'd be ashamed if I worked at one of these places working diligently to get a bigger share of the pie, but I recognize that there is value there to be extracted and, sans regulation, people are gonna extract it.
lordleft 4 days ago |
PaulKeeble 4 days ago |
gavin_gee 4 days ago |
its just the new version of see price in cart
balls187 4 days ago |
biker142541 4 days ago |
croisillon 4 days ago |
xunil2ycom 4 days ago |
mring33621 4 days ago |
wolfi1 4 days ago |
mithr 4 days ago |
I also find it counterintuitively helpful that so many of Amazon's deals are obviously not actually deals, and that so many of their products are so obviously knockoffs, because when I do find myself scrolling through a "Kitchen sale!" list in the app, it only takes a minute for me to realize this is useless and close the app in disgust.
morelandjs 4 days ago |
aframemodular 4 days ago |
mech998877 4 days ago |
andy_b_84 4 days ago |
timnetworks 4 days ago |
Fuck amazon for doing that. Fuck amazon in general.
Also fuck uber for charing 'waiting fees' for the shitty taxi service, I'm not jumping into a moving car you soul sucking vampires, it needs to be stopped. Fuck uber in general tbh.
jjyycc 4 days ago |
mannyv 4 days ago |
mike_bob 4 days ago |
unsharted 4 days ago |
reactordev 4 days ago |
If you sell through them, you are not allowed to list your products cheaper than they do otherwise they delist you.
teeray 4 days ago |
beloch 4 days ago |
For those who wish to get off of Amazon, all it takes is a little planning or the willingness to go shopping in a physical store. It's no bed of roses for physical stores these days, but the reports of their demise have been greatly exaggerated. Malls are still alive and well in Canada. For things you need to order, don't expect overnight shipping. Plan a little further ahead.
For those who have decided to stick with Amazon a little longer... Do pay attention to the holiday price shenanigans that are about to take place. It's not just in your head when a book you swear you saw last week at $15 is now "on sale" at $40. Christmas is when Amazon becomes truly rapacious.
alienbaby 4 days ago |
prpl 4 days ago |
ginthian 3 days ago |
loki004 4 days ago |
zquzra 4 days ago |
josefritzishere 4 days ago |
jmspamerton 4 days ago |
fdefilippo 4 days ago |
Most online retailers (Amazon included) still give free shipping above a certain threshold ($35 per order or whatever) so for things I need, I wait until I reach that threshold to place the order, and often purchase at other retailers or directly from the brand.
Also, everyone does "Black Friday" sales nowadays, in many cases matching the same window as Amazon.