289 points by Brajeshwar 4 days ago | 262 comments | View on ycombinator
mikekij 4 days ago |
coreylane 4 days ago |
seizethecheese 4 days ago |
0erofootprint 3 days ago |
lizknope 3 days ago |
This part is true for every big chip company. I've been designing large complex chips for 30 years. This is how long it takes from architecture, design, manufacturing, testing, mass production. Even just fab production is 4 months at TSMC from GDS delivery to finished chip.
> Kress, or whoever replaces her permanently, will have to chart the course that the chip industry will take two years from now, the CEO says.
That's true of every company in this industry. If you want a product to sell 2 years from now you had to decide on what it is last year.
sigmoid10 4 days ago |
irthomasthomas 4 days ago |
I guess they mean Groq. Anyone know what nvidia did with groq btw?
1vuio0pswjnm7 3 days ago |
No CAPTCHA, no geo-blocking, no Javascript, no cookies, no user-agent header required
FTPUSERAGENT=unnecessary
x=https://www.wired.com/story/nvidia-was-already-in-trouble-before-the-jensen-huang-mess/
tnftp -4o"|grep -Eo 'body lead-in-text.*(</div>){3}<div class=.G' \
|sed 's/.\{19\}/<meta charset=utf-8>/;s/.\{13\}$//'" $x > 1.htm
firefox ./1.htm
Text-only: links -dump ./1.htm
Two headers only, no user-agent header: w=104.18.3.159
x=https://www.wired.com/story/nvidia-was-already-in-trouble-before-the-jensen-huang-mess/
y=$(echo $x|cut -d/ -f3)
z=${x#*$y}
{
test ${#z} -gt 0||x=/
printf 'GET %s HTTP/1.1\r\nhost: %s\r\nconnection: %s\r\n\r\n' \
${x#*$y} \
$y \
close
sleep 1
} |bssl client -connect $w:443 -server-name $y \
|grep -Eo 'body lead-in-text.*(</div>){3}<div class=.G' \
|sed 's/.\{19\}/<meta charset=utf-8>/;s/.\{13\}$//' > 1.htm
firefox ./1.htmhsnewman 4 days ago |
undefined 3 days ago |
empath75 4 days ago |
There's so much projection and wishful thinking about completely normal price movements in hyped stock.
capsudo 3 days ago |
undefined 4 days ago |
ksec 4 days ago |
On the article, most of the tech discussions make zero sense as many of the comments already pointed out. Some of those challenges is also one of the reason why Nvidia has accelerated the whole roadmap and doing iteration of GPU every 18 months of so to stay competitive. Capitalising on leading edge node early and securing larger wafer quantities than even Apple. Large commitments so TSMC is also building Fabs faster than ever. The whole thing filtered out to all the downstream supply chain. Financing it as well making sure the capital is well positioned rather than forcing their partner to raise capital on additional capacity. Same playbook as old Apple. And in case anyone is wondering, it is Nvidia that is now pushing and funding the development of leading edge node along with all the other leading edge tech. Without them, TSMC A14 wouldn't happen as early. PCIe 6.0 would be a year later, Optical interconnect is 2 years early if not more.
It is that Datacenter are put on halt that is the biggest concern. And that didn't happen before "Jensen's mess".
w10-1 4 days ago |
(a) making chips is not making datacenters (esp. the memory fabric). Nvidia is working up the value chain (racks, datacenters), backwards (by supporting customers), and sideways (by lowering the cost of related technologies). No one else is close.
(b) Nvidia profit margins are so huge they can destroy competition
(c) The main cited competition is from their main customers, who are just trying to get a better deal from them.
However, the China trouble is real: Huawei is making chips for model-building and inference that the Chinese labs are happily using (to copy models?) that are good enough to dump models and chips to make a monopoly. Stirring up anti-tech, anti-datacenter concerns at the start of this race makes that a real concern, hardly mentioned in the article. It is not possible to face down a cheaper substitute with infinite resources.
Not good that people are stirring false worries when there are real concerns.
jmyeet 4 days ago |
One of Tim Apple's [sic] big innovations was to take Apple's giant pile of cash and use it for vendor financing. Building a new fab or process or factory is expensive. Borrowing money is expensive and risk. But Apple gave favorable terms in exchange for a period of exclusivity to whatever the vendor produced. This was huge for the iPhone for years.
NVidia is kind of in that position now. One can say that there is circular financing between NVidia and the big AI companies but is it really that different to Apple's approach? I'm not entirely convinced that there's an imminent domino effect collapse coming as a result of all of this. And, even if it does, I don't see it taking down NVidia.
Boeing (and Airbus) is the other company NVidia reminds me of. The business of selling planes is complicated. Boeing gets to throw its weight around and demand concessions. Launch partners for new planes get favorable delivery dates but that's also a chain. Qatar Airways famously went to war with Boeing and lost its A321 orders. That's the kind of power NVidia has now over the AI providers. It gets to decide who gets to buy and when.
As for competitors, there are always wannabees. Remember the decade of Google killers? I do. What happened to them all?
It surprises me on HN of all places how many people think you can vibecode a GPU competitor to NVidia, basically. I'm sorry but no. Chip design is harder than that. Managing relationships with suppliers, vendors, the fabs (particularly TSMC), etc is hard. NVidia has been doing it a long time, has a lot of built up expertise and has a lot of volume and weight it can throw around.
Jensen Huang was correct about China (IMHO). Restricting the chipmaking from ASML is one thing. Restricting the chips was a mistake in foreign policy terms. It has created captive domestic demand for Chinese chips. And it's too late to unring the bell. Xi Jinping realizes that chipmaking and AI is of national security interest to China. Yes there'll be some smuggling in the meantime but I fully expect China's EUV to be producing commercial chips by 2030. China simply doesn't want to be beholden to Western companies in the exact same way that most US tech companies were banned in China. I believe history will vindicate Xi's long-term strategic thinking in this area (yes, blocking the likes of Facebook and Uber predated Xi, I know).
I also think AI isn't going to be ASICed anytime soon like crypto mining was. Crypto had a fixed algorithm. AI does not, at least not yet. It's constantly changing. Even in recent years we've tried different quantization methods (eg fp4, int4). Model architecture is still evolving at a rapid rate. It's way too early to fix that into hardware.
dogscatstrees 3 days ago |
Why didn't we get these drip drip stories about Tesla being in trouble after Musk impregnated women, including a direct subordinate?
josemanuel 3 days ago |
Wow, who would have thought 3 weeks ago?
undefined 3 days ago |
cmiles8 4 days ago |
tracerbulletx 4 days ago |
Betelbuddy 4 days ago |
SV_BubbleTime 4 days ago |
150g2 4 days ago |
quater321 4 days ago |
jmspamerton 4 days ago |
lenerdenator 4 days ago |
If you own shares in a company like that, you need to evaluate how that can be changed - either your ownership of the shares, or the corporate governance of the company.
wilsonjensen 4 days ago |
Not saying this author does. But senior leadership at Wired?
Everyone just using an obfuscated form of Elon's "GAMESTONK" strategy to boost their position.
shevy-java 4 days ago |