844 points by harrisonpage 4 days ago | 353 comments | View on ycombinator
AceJohnny2 about 13 hours ago |
dietsche about 18 hours ago |
I recently installed a Chaimberlain garage door opener in a location that required three buttons inside the garage. They limit the buttons in software, so that each garage door opener can have only two at any given time!
After some tinkering, I discovered that the Chaimberlain buttons transmit their signal wirelessly these days, even when "wired" to the garage door opener... the wires only provide power. So...
I worked around the problem by placing a dab of solder on one of their security+ 3.0 buttons so that it is always "pressed." Then I wired up the three old school garage door momentary switches to send power to it. When pressed, they power up the Chaimberlain button, which then sends a wireless signal to open the door.
wallst07 about 21 hours ago |
I will sell/replace/throw every device if I see a ad in the ecosystem. Almost every IOT manufacturer does this crap so it gets more difficult. Moving the device to Home Assistant helps a little.
Ecobee you're next, and I hope you go down in flames having such crap software.
superultra about 18 hours ago |
The notification marketing spam is really bad right now. I can literally turn off every marketing toggle in the Uber app (buried as it is), save it, then swipe out of those settings, then back in, and the notifications are all enabled again. Same goes for a lot of other apps, like the Dominos pizza app.
It’s gotten to the point where I just install the app, use it to order a pizza or a ride, the. uninstall the offending app (though sometimes I still get ghost notifications!)
But for apps like those for garage doors, that’s not a viable strategy.
I know why these notifications happen. The open rate ranges from 5-20% (though up to half of these can be accidental, but at least you got them back into the app, right).
But it really feels like an intrusion on the iOS and Android in ways that can compromise usage of the phone. It seems like at least Apple used to care about this and maintain UX standards but it seems like that has gone out the window.
For people who can’t jury rig a solution to their garage door opener, what can they do?
teekert about 18 hours ago |
I am of the persuasion that a smart home should never require whipping out your phone, but I have not been able to brush away all occurrences yet. But the Hue app always motivates me to either do things via Home Assistant (including just coupling the bulb directly using ZigBee) or get a switch ASAP.
Yes Signify (former Philips), you got an ad in my face, congrats, but you also got me super annoyed and I'll be on the lookout for alternatives.
gbdubs about 18 hours ago |
- does not have a subscription fee
- does not sell data
- does not have ads or remarket
- follows basic cyber security hygiene
- is simple to set up (thinking of my parents)
- interacts purely through standard protocols
I have long delayed wiring my home with IoT devices, but would be interested in doing so if I could have some basic assurances about the experience of using it being pleasant and safe. Almost everybody that I know who has invested heavily in IoT has had to treat it like a side project to avoid the various pitfalls.
dj68k about 20 hours ago |
Since the code was put in a "best-effort basis" for future updates, it's gone from version 2.2 to 2.2.6 with numerous fixes. Most notable was software-configurable "debounce" functionality which finally solved my problem with the door tripping the magnetic reed switches several times quickly when the door comes to a stop and confusing the board about its current up/down status.
I bring it up because I have tremendous enthusiasm for people who take an idea, a cheap microcontroller, and put together a solution for people who prefer to stick with older, simple appliances but still want some sort of smart functionality. People who "make cool stuff and put it on the internet." That the creator disclosed that he's putting his focus on the newer boards and will maintain/fix issues with the older ones on a "best-effort" and then actually does it... it's fantastic. Because of this continued support and fixes, I can't recommend Ratgdo boards enough.
100percentjake about 18 hours ago |
variety8675 about 18 hours ago |
chang1 about 18 hours ago |
Technically it is against app store review guidelines to use push notifications for ads, unless the user has specifically opted in. I'm guessing it's difficult to catch during app review, or reviewers don't care.
> 4.5.4 Push Notifications must not be required for the app to function, and should not be used to send sensitive personal or confidential information. Push Notifications should not be used for promotions or direct marketing purposes unless customers have explicitly opted in to receive them via consent language displayed in your app’s UI, and you provide a method in your app for a user to opt out from receiving such messages. Abuse of these services may result in revocation of your privileges.
https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#:~:...
There is definitely no way to opt-in our opt-out in Feit or Arlo. My guess is the same with all these other apps.
stickfigure about 17 hours ago |
I bought a house that came with a Chamberlain garage door opener. At $20 I figured I would try the MyQ device to see if it's as bad as people say. It is that bad.
I bought the Tailwind device and it is exactly what I wanted. I can tell Google to open/close the door. My only complaint is that Google makes me tell it a code to open, but you can put it in one voice prompt "hey google open the garage door with code NNNN".
modeless about 12 hours ago |
Someone should start a business ripping this crap out of garage door openers and replacing it with something sensible.
lukeschlather about 15 hours ago |
Of course the flipside is that if your thing depends on an app you need ongoing maintenance, but if you've got an advertising-riddled app spamming notifications it seems like the prophylactic is indistinguishable from the disease it prevents.
Aboutplants about 18 hours ago |
pastor_williams about 19 hours ago |
thatonehack about 18 hours ago |
MatekCopatek about 19 hours ago |
benmorris about 19 hours ago |
tw04 about 6 hours ago |
ryandrake about 20 hours ago |
jeroenpe about 14 hours ago |
It just need to give a short pulse to start and open/close the door.
And to read out the door state I added a LDR circuit on the GPIO that is attached to the motor LED.
Has been working very well last three years using HA. no need for any of that expensive cloud connected hardware.
brynnb about 14 hours ago |
blantonl about 18 hours ago |
I've never understood how technologists, product managers, and marketing people can sit in the same conference room and collectively decide, "Hey, let's start sending unsolicited marketing push notifications to our users, and while we're at it, we can make another $1,000 a month by stuffing Google Ads into the app."
And then everyone around the table nods their heads and says, "Great idea, let's do it!"
If I were in that room, I'd be throwing chairs. I'd be so vehemently opposed to this kind of garbage that the meeting would come to a screeching halt.
I genuinely cannot comprehend the decision-making process that leads an entire room of supposedly intelligent people to agree that deliberately degrading the user experience for a few extra dollars is a good business decision. These are not freemium products - these customers paid for these products!!
wingspar about 21 hours ago |
qazxcvbnmlp about 17 hours ago |
philips about 17 hours ago |
newguytony about 20 hours ago |
Intrepidatious about 18 hours ago |
YackerLose about 15 hours ago |
skiing_crawling about 7 hours ago |
flysonic10 about 6 hours ago |
fourneau about 18 hours ago |
Chamberlain used to have a HomeBridge, that connected to HomeKit, device that would sit in your garage and sit on your wifi network. It would pair with the opener similar to how a normal wall-mounted garage door panel would. Not only was this setup a little clunky, it was slow. The Siri -> Door open process would often take 5-10 seconds. This wasn't great, but it worked. Sort of.
Then, they did two things that made my blood boil: they discontinued support for it and prevented you from repairing the device with their myQ app, then started using notification for ads.
When I was about to sink an unhealthy amount of time into a garage door opener, ratgdo came in and rescued me. Not only was it simple to install but it was lightning fast. On the same network, it started opening and closing the door the second the Siri command went off. I can only assume that the previous system used to do roundtrips to Chamberlain and the connection wasn't the fastest in the garage.
Ratgdo man, if you read this you have my thanks (and my money, obviously.)
ceocoder about 17 hours ago |
harrisonpage 4 days ago |
torginus about 15 hours ago |
Meanwhile there are Zigbee solutions you can order from Aliexpress for like ten bucks, and those only need to be wired into your existing opener, so install consists of an hours's worth of fiddling with wires.
ww520 about 16 hours ago |
polyterative about 17 hours ago |
cdurth about 17 hours ago |
hn_submit about 17 hours ago |
And if everyone's doing it what choice do you have? If someone actually starts selling these devices there's a good chance the manufacturer will sue for patent infringement, DCMA reverse engineering or some other guff.
amluto about 17 hours ago |
I assume this is because commercial users have control stations that use dry contacts, and the modern crap is simply a nonstarter.
luisgvv about 17 hours ago |
js2 about 11 hours ago |
(My openers themselves are 20+ year old Wayne Daltons, and I've revived one of them from a lightning strike and the other from a broken gear, but they've otherwise been trouble free.)
jawns about 19 hours ago |
I use NextDNS, which allows me to block ads (including a lot of mobile ads) at the DNS level.
I disabled all notifications for myQ.
And I configured the garage door to auto-close at 9pm.
herf about 16 hours ago |
cryptoegorophy about 8 hours ago |
whiskeykilo about 17 hours ago |
I'm keeping it simple now, HomeKit or bust for the smart home.
doawoo about 16 hours ago |
chung8123 about 15 hours ago |
digitalsushi about 18 hours ago |
I have LG washtower thinQ enabled, and the phone app was maybe worse than the garage door opener app. But, at least, the app can be deleted, and the data endpoints are still emitting sensor data enough for home assistant to pick it up. No spam because no app. I get an email when the washer/dryer finishes, I know to plop wet clothes into the dryer, and that works great. That's a good experience. Getting phone ads for soap at 2am is not a good experience.
seshagiric about 14 hours ago |
You see when you install MyQ, by default it opts you in for in-garage delivery. And here's the beauty, you also need a PHD to figure out how to disable the setting in Amazon. (reference: https://support.chamberlaingroup.com/s/article/myQ-and-Amazo...)
otter-in-a-suit about 19 hours ago |
I have a zero tolerance policy for spam - notification permissions get taken away on the first offense, emails get marked as spam. I've had the ratgdo on eternal to-do list for a while, so this post speaks to me.
anticorporate about 20 hours ago |
A few weeks ago, I noticed my Apollo-1 Air quality sensor was seeing some strange behavior in the basement. Home Assistant showed an unexplained temperature spike and humidity drop a little before 1am.
I managed to figure out from other sensors that nothing was actually awry (no spikes in draw of nearby devices, no telltale gas signatures of the water heater kicking on, no motion or CO2 indicating human or other large animal presence). Was the board malfunctioning? Fortunately the device has an internal temperature sensor and an ambient sensor which are separate. Logging confirms the temperature spike originated on the board, probably from the WiFi chip.
But, why?
It turns out, after inspecting the signal a bit more, than the MyQ was broadcasting so loudly between the WiFi and BLE, screaming for someone to talk to it, that my air sensor was having to increase its power to still be able to communicate over all the noise. Switching to a different channel for the crappy old downstairs AP fixed it, but still, c'mon!
I'm a little wary of connecting any sort of ingress/egress to my home to the network at all, even locally, but an honest appraisal of the basement is that smashing a window is probably a much bigger threat model than hacking the door opener. Or in other words, https://xkcd.com/538/
wayeq about 13 hours ago |
We went from:
"gee, it sure would be nice if I didn't have to get out of my car and lug this heavy door open with my bare hands"
to:
"we can use the garage doors to advertise unrelated products to the owner, and/or participate in massive bot nets to ruin other people's lives!"
mdarens about 19 hours ago |
i've been meaning set up a dedicated domain/website just to collect complaints about this company's behavior, alternatives, workarounds for their failures like the one posted here recently [1], and importantly, laws. we need laws.
mentioned already in these comments: granular control over notifications between marketing & functional, and no circumvention by intermingling the two. home automation devices may be allowed to traverse wans to offer remote control for non-vpn/sd-wan users, but should not have their core functionality _or_ initial setup depend on an internet connection.
finally, locked devices produced by companies over a some market cap or another and their subsidiaries should be required to offer a bootloader for user/open firmware after some reasonable period of time to mitigate some of the mountains of ewaste we are producing with this stuff.
asveikau about 16 hours ago |
The way around it is to solder onto the contacts of their proprietary buttons.
Anyone have updates on that situation?
sc970 about 15 hours ago |
Although it only triggers the button. So no information on whether it is opened or closed.
jsisto about 17 hours ago |
corndoge about 17 hours ago |
dllu about 13 hours ago |
alexfromapex about 14 hours ago |
jareklupinski about 17 hours ago |
it should be illegal for someone who had a good idea once to be allowed to leave that good idea in the hands of others
jfengel about 14 hours ago |
On Quora there has been a slew of spammers trying to sell garage door openers. It's probably just a scam, but it seems a pretty niche scam.
lostlogin about 16 hours ago |
This hack could be monetised at this step, by allowing adverts at this step. This would complete the (tech) circle of life nicely.
bob1029 about 16 hours ago |
I don't know why we approach everything like this as a challenge. Certainly, we can make this work. Technically there's nothing stopping us from integrating anything with anything else. But, what is the cost of maintaining this? How many others in your household are into your hobby as much as you are?
etatester about 19 hours ago |
I need your business notifications, I do not need or approve of your advertising/product updates.
For my mobile OS, all notifications look the same. "AI priority" is the only attempt at this but I don't need AI priority if I have a very tight-knit circle of apps that can send notifications.
Then one important app sends me spam and I turn it off immediately.
gimlichgu about 13 hours ago |
jadar about 14 hours ago |
For the OP, do you really need to fire off expletive-laden rants at these people? Why harbor such hatred in your heart and words when you could just say, "Here's what bugged me, and how I fixed it. Now I don't need your product." That's all you need to say.
ricardo81 about 19 hours ago |
windex about 1 hour ago |
1970-01-01 about 16 hours ago |
traviswingo about 18 hours ago |
The reason ads come at us from every fucking angle of life is because they work. That’s unacceptable, imo.
They don’t work on me, they don’t work on you, so who the fuck do they work on?
The answer: most people. And that’s why they keep showing them.
All of the anti-patterns we all hate only perpetuate because they work.
We really need to figure out a way to educate people better so that these practices stop working. And I’ve no clue how to do that (tried with my parents, failed miserably in a cloud of “this is too confusing I don’t care.”)
pmg about 5 hours ago |
Hey, look I’m sorry. Wish I was at liberty to say how things got here.
On a lighter note, you may want to try rat-ratgo32 instead of ratgo32.
throwitaway222 about 15 hours ago |
elbistec24 about 17 hours ago |
TazeTSchnitzel about 15 hours ago |
yakshaving_jgt about 21 hours ago |
When I eventually buy a house with my own garage, I'm totally adding the garage door to Apple Home so that I can operate it with my voice while inside my helmet on my motorcycle, and not have to take my gloves off and get the remote control out. I hadn't thought of that possibility.
bluedino about 18 hours ago |
Uses your existing wiring, etc.
switchbak about 14 hours ago |
Be sure to turn off/disable their old school RF stuff too.
Not surprising that they're pulling a John Deer and making simple things proprietary so they can enshitify you into their ecosystem.
dkobia about 17 hours ago |
howunfortunate about 17 hours ago |
johnea about 8 hours ago |
What could possibly go wrong 8-/
Siri, let me rob this house...
nticompass about 19 hours ago |
I also hate the amount of ads the myQ app has, like it's pretty much nothing but ads (and reporting this to the Play Store does nothing).
Currently, my garage door opener is connected to my WiFi (on its own "IoT VLAN") because I once had to use myQ to open my garage whilst away to let my friend into the house.
Normally, I just use a "normal" garage door opener remote (and my car's built-in HomeLink buttons).
SoftTalker about 18 hours ago |
Scene_Cast2 about 20 hours ago |
Using a pre-certified module doesn't let you bypass certification.
JumpCrisscross about 16 hours ago |
htrp about 17 hours ago |
sell it as a loss leader and make the money up on ads / revenue. Once you install something (physically), it's almost not worth it to uninstall it. Expect this with all "smart" iot devices
A MyQ costs 50$ (sometimes down to 19.99 on sale), there's a reason for that.
nikanj about 12 hours ago |
tonymet about 14 hours ago |
Wired and wireless layer 2 protocols have retransmission and your layer 7 app can receive duplicate commands. Be sure to add deduplication logic to the command e.g. using a nonce or transaction id. You have to be very careful that your layer 7 app doesn’t play the “open” command twice and close the door.
I’d happily buy your product to replace my MyQ. I hate the spam, and it’s just plain buggy. Plus the base station runs loads of unwanted services. I haven’t fully audited it, but I’m sure it’s a security nightmare.
jjtheblunt about 18 hours ago |
classified about 18 hours ago |
j117noai about 17 hours ago |
undefined about 16 hours ago |
modestnature about 1 hour ago |
juanpabloabadia about 5 hours ago |
ankur_misra about 15 hours ago |
Pastookh about 17 hours ago |
> Push Notifications must not be required for the app to function, and should not be used to send sensitive personal or confidential information. Push Notifications should not be used for promotions or direct marketing purposes unless customers have explicitly opted in to receive them via consent language displayed in your app’s UI, and you provide a method in your app for a user to opt out from receiving such messages. Abuse of these services may result in revocation of your privileges.
I am frustrated that Apple isn't using their gatekeeping powers for good. I wonder if users can file a complaint.
[1] https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#des...
Edit: yes, users can file complaints. If you are an Apple Developer, you can do so via https://developer.apple.com/help/app-review/safe-and-trusted...
You can also follow "Report A Problem" link at the bottom of the App Store's page for the app.