Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display (https://trmnl.com)

543 points by geerlingguy 4 days ago | 440 comments | View on ycombinator

Calvin02 4 days ago |

I was a huge fan of Trmnl when they first launched. I even convinced my friends to buy a few.

Then the QA started to go down or the devices wouldn’t ship on time. On top of that, Ryan’s politics were a big turnoff.

I would not buy another device from this company.

origini 4 days ago |

Yada yada 1.2k :(

Man how long and often do I need to get my hopes up?

You can't tell me that the company having the patent is so bad in making it cheaper and better so that the mass market would kick in?

Or is there 0 mass market for things like that?

Or is it really that expensive to make them bigger?

Lets see who wins in a few years: The price going down or my wallet

RGS1811 4 days ago |

I’ve been wanting something like this for a while. $1200 is more than I’m ready to pay for it but it’s cool that this exists!

car 3 days ago |

For a smaller, more affordable version I've been very happy with the Soldered Inkplate 6-color 13SPECTRA display [0]. Sold by Crowdsupply [1].

The technology common to all these displays is Spectra™ 6 by E-Ink [2,3].

Hacked a newspaper front-page rotation with Claude, and it looks great. With 10 minute refresh, the battery lasts for 2-3 weeks.

[0] https://soldered.com/collections/inkplate-e-paper-displays/p...

[1] https://www.crowdsupply.com/soldered/inkplate-13spectra

[2] https://www.eink.com/product/detail/EL133UF1

[3] https://www.eink.com/product/detail/EL253EW1

schlap 4 days ago |

This is a new J curve for product pricing that ive never seen before

5x the price of the next cheapest product is incredibly steep and with how the X released, I dont have a ton of confidence for the product even though i really want to.

If this was closer to $500 it would make sense

Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.

Make it easily frameable for all types of frames instead of requiring a handmade wooden one that likely increases production costs

vunderba 4 days ago |

I have a second-hand Samsung Frame connected to an old laptop that periodically wakes up, generates a couple dozen images daily, and then transfers them to the Frame TV via the Samsung Frame’s WebSocket API. It automatically changes the picture every 30 minutes.

The "Art Mode" setting along with its matte finish makes it non-reflective, so it just acts like a nice little gallery on my wall. It’s using older models, mainly SDXL, so a lot of the pictures can be a little goofy and its been humming along for several years at this point.

I’d love to pick up one of these TRMNL devices and do something similar but the price at $1200 (soon to be $1300) gives me pause.

https://imgpb.com/EZmRX

TechPlasma 4 days ago |

I have a use case for this. I want it. I can use it in my daily life. It's what I've been hoping for for years... But this price is crazy. I can't justify owning this at 1.2k. Maybe at 400,id even go for 500, which is a crazy amount of money for a wall display/calendar. But I'd justify the utility at that price.

porphyra 3 days ago |

I feel like e-ink displays are the ideal way to chat with an AI coding agent. Less eye strain, more suited to reading prose. Theoretically, if you chat with it by voice, it doesn't even need high refresh rate. Too bad the technology remains expensive.

layer8 4 days ago |

This is basically only usable as a picture frame for paintings and drawings and/or some text; photos don’t look too well.

Full frame updates take 20-30 seconds.

Content needs to be dithered to the six fixed colors (no gradations) at the already fairly low 93 PPI.

Contrast is something like 25:1.

jdprgm 4 days ago |

This looks dope but at that price is just a neat accessory for the wealthy. Is there a feasible route to it being about a tenth the price, like $150? Is it just a scale thing? You can get new dell monitors around that size for $200 or less.

It seems expensive because it is niche, and niche because it is expensive. At a dramatically lower price I think loads of people would love two or three of these around the house.

asenna 4 days ago |

Slightly relevant but I was just researching a smaller eink-display to place in a hotel room for a client and I discovered the `ReTerminal E1001` - pretty cool if anyone is looking for smaller (7.5") hackable solution with mics and beep for $69.

I hope the prices of the larger displays come down a bit at some point and become more popular.

rhim 3 days ago |

It makes me sad that ePaper displays are still at low availability and very high prices. There are so many opportunities to craft cool projects with such a display, but 1.2k bucks for a such a display is a lot of money for hobby projects.

majidmir 3 days ago |

Could this be the cheaper version directly sold by the Chinese supplier? https://www.epaperia.org/Mall/13.html Current price: $880

schainks 3 days ago |

Oh man I was really hoping it was using this tech under the hood: https://www.crowdsupply.com/modos-tech/modos-flow

dmitrygr 4 days ago |

Looked interesting, until I saw that you had to pay an extra $20 for unlocking developer mode. At the $1300 price point, nickel-and-diming me for $20 was such a completely unneeded snap in the face, that i closed the purchase tab. Good luck I guess, but i will not be a customer, out of principle.

IAmGraydon 4 days ago |

FWIW, you can get a much cheaper/smaller version here that uses the exact same display technology (Spectra 6):

https://www.seeedstudio.com/reTerminal-E1004-p-6692.html

Also, apparently Samsung's version uses the same Spectra 6 panel as well:

https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1963755-REG/samsung_e...

coppertuft 4 days ago |

Looks great! Love the wood frame. Would prefer it to be in a different aspect ratio tho, this ratio just says 'screen'.. but perhaps a e.g. 5:7 panel wouldn't be that easy to find?

denysvitali 3 days ago |

If you want something smaller, with fewer colors: https://www.seeedstudio.com/reTerminal-E1002-p-6533.html

(Just a happy customer, this thing has both a battery, an ESP32-S3 and some buttons - it's fantastic and doesn't cost 1k)

flaburgan 4 days ago |

I am not interested about art nor colour screen but if I could have my grafana monitoring refreshing every 10 sec that would be quite cool. They seem to have other products that are targeting this but I am confused about how the image should go from my browser to the device. You even have to pay extra for the "developer" feature that allows you to access the API (?!).

fennecfoxy 3 days ago |

I just got the 7.3" Pimoroni one to use for a small project. I would like one this size for my entranceway but all are prohibitively expensive. Makes me wonder how cheap they'd be if a proper display manufacturer like Samsung etc got onto them.

windex 3 days ago |

Ive learned one thing about e-ink. Prices never fall. This is one tech that refuses to figure out how to scale orders. If there is any alt tech or low power display, should check that.

IAmGraydon 4 days ago |

I would buy one at $1200 if the colors look good/rich in person and if you can change for a different frame. I have a feeling I'm going to be disappointed though - most of the pictures make it look like it has a bit of a washed out appearance.

neom 4 days ago |

Not quite the same but FWIW I just got a 13.3" SwitchBot Art Frame original and I really like it, I think I'd prob find more use/enjoyment from x2 13" vs a single 31" (SwitchBot have a 31" for around $1,100).

proee 4 days ago |

I'd personally prefer a larger frame with mat. Most nice looking art is framed this way.

vivzkestrel 3 days ago |

- stupid question

- why does everyone want one more screen in their house?

- what is the research, intuition behind this?

- smart mirrors, this, wall screens, why are people obsessed with more screens?

close04 4 days ago |

At 31.5” and 1440p resolution this display has a PPI of 94. So it’s probably best viewed from a distance. I’m waiting for my 13” version (~150 PPI) to see if it makes sense to go bigger.

lazzlazzlazz 3 days ago |

Seems it doesn't support wifi or any internet connectivity (zero mention of any of these on any of the sites), which makes it essentially useless. Tough for the price.

micromacrofoot 4 days ago |

Everyone's making the same mistake here... eInk and ePaper are not necessarily the same thing. eInk is a type of ePaper. eInk is a brand.

wavey-throw 4 days ago |

This would be a heck of a lot more interesting if they'd worked with Modos on the display controller instead of just putting up with eink's glacial pace of, well, everything (development, improvement, actual image refresh on the panel). There's so much possible with the multipigment screens that's yet to be unlocked with better driver hardware and software.

See https://github.com/Modos-Labs/Glider/blob/main/README.md#fas... for an old example of what they've managed to do with an old CMYW Gallery Palette panel (512 colors instead of 7), or https://www.eniacelec.com/pages/tickey for an actual recent product that's pushing 48 native colors on a spectra 6 panel.

For a product that's designed for static images where repaint speed isn't a major consideration, there's no excuse for putting up with eink's cruddy driverware at the cost of quality. Missed opportunity for differentiation.

rendleflag 4 days ago |

I really dislike the muted colors, soft spoken, quiet music, product videos that seem to be everywhere, talking about how "different" they are. Showing someone hand-carving into a piece of wood, talking about "made in the USA", like some third-generation craftsman with a beard and a cap. It all feels like artisanal firewood. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBb9O-aW4zI

bdcravens 4 days ago |

I'm sure it's a high quality product, but given that "hacking" a random screen is just a Claude prompt these days, I think it's a hard sale. I think most consumers don't really care about the advantages of eInk versus a cheap display.

https://wesbos.com/hacking-smart-photo-frames

lampiaio 3 days ago |

Why does the "transparent supply chain" list "Overseas" instead of the actual place of origin? The US-sourced parts go as far as saying the city for some entries. It just looks like a ridiculous avoidance of saying China.

Aunche 4 days ago |

I've been eyeing the TRMNL X for a while, but I heard the launch was very unreliable. Has anyone here had any experience with it?

fwip 4 days ago |

LLM slop in user-facing UI. "Stays on screen until another screen's time comes." :/

joshstrange 4 days ago |

> $1,299.00

Whoa, no thanks. I _love_ e-ink and as I was reading I was bracing myself for $300-400, 3-4x that doesn't work for me. I get it's large, I know that large e-ink (even b/w) are not cheap but $1.3K is too rich for my blood.

I was going to buy it as just a nice all-in-one I could flash my own firmware on but not at that price. I guess I'll keep playing with my 7" e-ink screens run by ESP32's or BTLE boards.

mclanett 3 days ago |

Love the e-paper display concept. Also the wood frame is nice. On top of that all I need is an API.

malshe 4 days ago |

I see a few comments mentioning the price is 1.2k. But I saw $1,299 which is basically 1.3k, even more expensive!

albertgoeswoof 4 days ago |

I made a 13 inch version myself for about $300, battery powered, esp32

So those complaining about price, it’s not bad tbh

david_van_loon 3 days ago |

This looks like something I would love to have, but certainly not at that price.

geerlingguy 4 days ago |

It's a bit expensive, at $1,299.

mboehm 4 days ago |

Haven‘t tried it out yet, but isn‘t the Samsung em32dx an alternative?

amelius 3 days ago |

Any ideas about where he sources his panels from?

purpleidea 4 days ago |

$2,000 ! zomg, I wish. I am not this rich haha.

sleepybrett 3 days ago |

colors are crazy washed out, epaper just isn't there for this stuff yet.

drcongo 4 days ago |

I hate this childish, deliberate, lower-case style even more than reading something an LLM has written. Unbelievable that this is on a corporate blog.

crystaln 4 days ago |

I’m disappointed it’s missing adware and spyware.

What’s the point of an art frame if it doesn’t scan and profile your network to sell ads?

stronglikedan 3 days ago |

Yikes, now I know why it's customary to capitalize the first letter of a sentence, even if it's grammatically correct either way! I literally cannot follow that style for more than two sentences at a time.

worthyrae 4 days ago |

What’s fps on this?

fhn 4 days ago |

"we spend our time looking at screens" invents another screen

jiveturkey 3 days ago |

94 dpi

eink-lover 4 days ago |

To all those decrying that this device is USD 1200 - you should look at the Samsung EM32DX and Samsung EM32DX-A displays. They are likely the same panel in a (flimsy) digital signage frame, and the EM32DX has gone for EUR 500 recently. Both devices started at EUR 1200 as well, so I guess that is just the cost for the eInk panels.

https://geizhals.de/?in=&fs=samsung%20em32dx

Likely, they will also show up on eBay soon.

bijowo1676 4 days ago |

only wooden frame is made in the US

the display itself is made in China using Chinese technologies

fwipsy 4 days ago |

The tl;dr should include the price. That is the one thing I click on the page looking for.

jllyhill 3 days ago |

It so strange to see a slop-coded refresh Web app in an advert of an artisinal screen.

yeah879846 4 days ago |

[dead]

shen 4 days ago |

16:9 no thanks.