Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Grazing sheep in fields with solar arrays (https://news.cornell.edu)

329 points by PaulHoule 4 days ago | 354 comments | View on ycombinator

dogscatstrees 4 days ago |

There's a stretch in California Interstate 5 near the town of Coalinga where you will see acres and acres of cows baking under the naked sun in the summertime and they huddle next to each other to find a brief relief of nonexistent protection from the searing sun. You just wonder why their owners cannot come up with a single idea on how to give them shade. It's cruelty.

cprayingmantis 3 days ago |

The introduction of solar is something that my rural Appalachian county has dealt with recently.

There was considerable pushback from the 60+ crowd and NIMBY types just like there is for everything new and different, but we got three permitted and are waiting on them to begin construction.

The thing that got me was there was a lot of people that just made whatever argument they could to try and stop it. All kinds of arguments that people either didn't understand or didn't really believe in. They just knew they hated solar. I really couldn't wrap my head around it.

From my perspective. It's a net good for our ranchers. We're mostly small family ranches, 200 head or less and the lease paid by the solar company helps these folks meet the bottom line. Beef prices won't stay up forever so it's a good time to diversify.

thelastgallon 3 days ago |

There are lots of use cases for solar with livestock and livestock + agriculture.

China has fish farms with solar, reflection from water increases efficiency by 5%: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MgQVV0_75j0

Livestock need shade, and grass doesn't need continuous shade grows better in shade in most tropical climates. If its too hot, grass dies off. Livestock also need ACs when temperatures reach 50+ centigrade, which can be powered by solar.

Cows are ruminants, they lie down and ruminate for hours in shade.

Except for goats, solar works with most animals.

Solar can always be used as a fence (zero land use, zero interruption to machinery) and get paid at a higher rate in the mornings and evenings, extending solar production window by ~4 hours.

Farming is tough and low status. All countries support farming with subsidies. The best use of farms is solar+ anything else. Photosynthesis is 6% efficiency (and it goes down to less than 1% when we use it for livestock feed or ethanol with conversion losses), solar is ~25%. Solar has zero opex and can run for 3 - 5 decades, output can be used directly.

hunglee2 4 days ago |

This is the sort of geo-engineering which I think we can all get behind. Solar panels are really more like artificial trees than we might initially think, not only absorbing sunlight but also providing shade. Next step is to design in root like foundations, so that they can hold the soil together. Pretty much close-to-nature form of terraforming.

flerchin 4 days ago |

I took a drive through west texas last summer. Sheep grazing in the shadow of enormous windmills in the day, and lit by natural gas flares at night. It's not pretty, but the owners clearly put their land to work.

_heimdall 4 days ago |

I have very much wanted to try this with our cattle. We have around 20 head of smaller breeds and really need more shade in our field.

The main blockers I've had are (1) I haven't come up with an affordable racking solution that will hold up to 1,000 lb steers rubbing their butts on it and (2) our local power company sucks with regards to solar and its useless trying to back feed the grid.

sneurlax 4 days ago |

It'd be interesting to see this using those new translucent pink solar panels that let green light thru

tho I guess the sheep may appreciate the shade...

mlmonkey 4 days ago |

The world has plenty of barren, desert areas; do we really need to put solar panels in grass fields? I'm not against it, but just wondering why not just use barren land? Surely it's got to be cheaper than putting them grassland?

MC995 4 days ago |

Princeton University also uses sheep in their solar fields

https://www.princeton.edu/news/2018/06/28/sheep-shear-mainte...

htrp 4 days ago |

There was also that paper about transparent solar panels that allowed magenta light through for crop growth underneath the panel mounts.

steinwinde 3 days ago |

What the article fails to mention is that a key reason for using solar energy is the fight against climate change. In all likelihood, doesn't keeping sheep actually hinder this effort? What would sheep farming have to look like to be carbon-negative? And shouldn't we be focusing on other ways to utilize the land, given that any form of animal agriculture will, in the long run, contribute to climate change?

konschubert 4 days ago |

We have to internalise as a society that a corn field is basically an industrial site.

There is significantly more biodiversity in permanent grassland - solar panels or not.

And solar produces way more than 10 times more energy than energy crops.

So if you worry about nature and land use, you should focus on energy crops (and efficient ways of getting tasty protein).

hinkley 4 days ago |

The new hotness is double-sided solar panels oriented vertically to improve utilization and average output per panel versus peak output.

That also makes the groundcover more accessible for either mowing or grazing, since the footprint of each rack is however big you have to make the footing so it doesn't lever itself out of the ground in a wind storm.

xbmcuser 3 days ago |

Its not just sheep others are using the space below solar panels to grow stuff that was not possible in their climate before as the sun was to harsh. Now the panel give shade decrease water loss from evaporation.

abdullahkhalids 4 days ago |

The DRAO observatory in BC, Canada asks local farmers to bring their cows to come eat the grass under the array of telescopes. Same concept, similar results.

zach_moore 3 days ago |

The fact that this required scientific study. We need a lot more farms. People forgot about how useful that is. Farms don't need to scale they are not supposed to be scalable. It's about using every single inch of land.

SoftTalker 4 days ago |

Why sheep in particular, and not cattle or goats?

TulliusCicero 4 days ago |

Seems neat, but does having herds of sheep cause any negative impact/damage when it comes to the solar panels?

Apocryphon 4 days ago |

We're gonna make Frutiger Aero real.

einpoklum 4 days ago |

Isn't it mostly the same like sheep grazing vs mowing in fields _without_ solar arrays, though?

Onavo 4 days ago |

I have a question, how are they burying the power cables? Are they above ground or underneath?

undefined 4 days ago |

undefined

lifeisstillgood 4 days ago |

Side note - sheep suffer from a range of disgusting diseases mostly due to having coats of wool that are impossible to clean / maintain.

There is a ground swell of farmers who find that the vet and ancillary costs Are not worth the effort of holding normal sheep - so there is a growing use of “non wool” sheep - who just have coats as sheep did before we kicked about with their DNA. (Of course they still kill the boys and slaughter the mums for food but hey …)

ginthian 4 days ago |

Another alternative to sheep is goats, cows would probably be too big.

Goodliff 4 days ago |

[dead]

loki004 4 days ago |

[flagged]

reacweb 3 days ago |

[flagged]

mesm7903 3 days ago |

[flagged]

toomuchtodo 4 days ago |

plazmatic 4 days ago |

[dead]

bethekidyouwant 4 days ago |

"Compared to a plot that was mowed” - incredible.