Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Aristotle Expands into Rust (https://www.harmonic.fun)

122 points by maufl 4 days ago | 69 comments | View on ycombinator

fuddle 4 days ago |

Is there an open source alternative to this?

maxbond 3 days ago |

They don't specify what draft of the Rust spec it will conform to, but isn't the Rust spec still a work in progress with no comprehensive definition of undefined behavior? This is cool I just don't see how you can do this for Rust writ large rather than a subset, at this moment. My impression is that this topic needs 1-5 years to finish cooking. What am I missing?

conqrr 4 days ago |

Can someone who undertands verification systems better explain how the spec/intents are created for such usecases along LLMs? Does a human form the spec or the system generates one based on human's natural language intent? I haven't followed this area but it seems like LLMs are used to bridge and form a hybrid spec?

OreganoTrail 4 days ago |

> Aristotle can prove that your code has no undefined behavior ... even inside unsafe blocks.

That's crazy, I haven't seen any other system that really tries to do that.

jan_m_savage 3 days ago |

>>> "With support for Rust, Aristotle can prove that your code has no undefined behavior and does exactly what its spec says"

Finally the industry is coming back full circle to the days of program-by-proof--a concept at least several decades old.

scorchin 4 days ago |

Is there a way to help Aristotle support more languages? Is there a specification (OSS) that can be provided in PR form to onboard them?

expectfun 4 days ago |

"Feels like in the future the only languages would be Rust and Lean"

ajasmin 4 days ago |

There are a lot of verification tools for rust popping up recently it's getting hard to navigate the space.

5555watch 4 days ago |

Maybe a hot take, but I don't think Aristotle is a good name for an AI.