Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Michael Mann's 'Heat' Copyright Fight Turns on a Deal with Himself (https://copyrightlately.com)

107 points by speckx 4 days ago | 52 comments | View on ycombinator

lolcatzlulz 4 days ago |

Reminds me of a copyright case where John Fogerty was sued for copyright infringement of himself.

https://norselandsrock.com/john-fogerty-vs-john-fogerty/

keane 4 days ago |

Previously: “Disney Lost Roger Rabbit” (243 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45968827

shevy-java 4 days ago |

The movies of Pacino and de Niro often have iconic scenes.

In Casino, my favourite one is still the desert scene, but it has many other great scenes.

In Taxi Driver, I liked the scenes that showed the loneliness of the main character, including when the TV went down. Martin Scorsese mentioned this in a somewhat recent interview, how this still resonates with an audience today, even though Taxi Driver is old. Al Pacino in Scarface, the "say hello to my little friend" and various other scenes. In Goodfellas it was the "funny how" scene that was best.

In Heat, the table dialogue was the best scene IMO. Both kind of made it semi-ad-hoc on that day. Another great scene was when de Niro was driving home, but then decided to return, despite knowing it was a mistake. It kind of set a theme for the movie there.

It's a bit sad how copyright is used in general. I think more content would need to be given to the general public; the time and specifics may be up for debate, but I don't feel there should be that near infinite copyright of what ... 70 or 95 years or whatever crazy high number is used.

whartung 4 days ago |

I can't speak to all of the copyright wrangling. Its clearly difficult for a reason.

But, at least it looks like Heat 2 is finally going to start shooting.

I am hesitantly looking forward to Heat 2. It mentions a potential Heat 3, which I think sounds completely uninteresting.

I'm a Mann fanboy, but I've read the book, and its largely mashup of Heat and Miami Vice, making it all very familiar. I was hoping for something fresher.

I like Mann for his cinematography and attention to detail. The stories are the stories, but they're not why I watch his movies. I watch his movies to see his work.

Miami Vice is one of my all time favorite movies, I like it better than Heat. I also really like Blackhat, just to float my fanboy cred. Ferrari was good, but he changed his cinematic style that I enjoy. We'll see what happens with Heat 2.

toomanyrichies 3 days ago |

“Heat” is one of my favorite films, but it’s interesting to see how it evolved. The 1981-85 window Mann’s lawsuit hinges on starts right when “Thief” came out, and watching them back to back, it’s easy to believe he was already writing Heat.

Frank (James Caan) and Neil McCauley live by the same rule: don’t get attached to anything you can’t walk away from. Both break it by wanting a normal life anyway. Frank has his wallet collage of a wife, kid, and house, and Neil has Eady.

The father-figure is there too. Leo (Robert Prosky) tells him "I'll be your father", and then treats him like property. In Heat, Nate (Jon Voight) does Leo’s job but stays loyal, and the betrayal goes to Van Zant. And oof, Willie Nelson was such a good get as Okla.

Both characters end with the main character dropping his rule for revenge. Frank burns down his house and business to go after Leo. Neil is on the way to the airport with Eady and doubles back to kill Waingro.

In between there’s L.A. Takedown, which is essentially the Heat script cut to 90 minutes for an NBC pilot. It even has most of the same character names- Vincent Hanna, Michael Cerrito, Chris Sheherlis, Lou Casals, Bosco, Kelso, etc. They even cast Xander Berkeley, aka the guy in Heat who Hanna catches his wife sleeping with, as fucking Waingro! The latter is more comical than anything [1]. There's no Waingro like Kevin Gage.

And LA is as much a character in Heat as Miami was in Miami Vice, except instead of pastels it’s huge, empty at night, and everybody lives alone in it. Mann did the same thing with Chicago in Thief.

I'm really not looking forward to the sequel. I read the book, and it was mediocre at best. The whole thing feels like a cash-grab, and it's annoying that every single name-brand director is falling all over themselves to cast Leo in their films. I wish Hollywood would just let its classics be, but I'm not holding my breath for that to happen anytime soon.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nmjxmmc-1Do

RHSeeger 4 days ago |

> And in 1994, the loan-out sold Warner Bros. the Heat screenplay as material Mann wrote “as a work made for hire.” Mann signed for the company and again for himself.

> But none of those agreements dates from 1981 to 1985, and that’s the period Mann is focusing on. According to the complaint, Mann now says he wrote early Heat drafts in those years on his own

Taking both of those two into consideration, it seems like either

- He was scamming them when he sold them the content in 1994, or

- He is trying to scam them now

Either I'm missing something, or the obvious answer is to ignore the question and say "either they own it wholly now - or they don't, and you scammed them, and the compensation for that is granting them ownership of what they don't currently own".

topspin 4 days ago |

"The most famous scene in Michael Mann’s Heat is a six-minute cup of coffee."

No.

I suppose that's the scene the celebrity industry has spent the most time writing about, but I think most Heat fans would put three or four other scenes above it. Certainly the closing scene, just to start my list.

gamblor956 4 days ago |

The issue, in a nutshell:

- US copyright law allows an author to terminate a copyright after 35 years...unless it was a "work made for hire" because then legally the "author" is the company that hired you, and this allowance is only granted to individual authors (meaning, actual humans, not solo authors).

- Mann wrote the script for his own "loan-out company" which is an arrangement common in entertainment (film and music both). The talent works for the loan-out company, and the loan-out company is who signs the contracts with movie producers, etc. This means that legally, script was a "work for hire" and the loan-out company is the author, so the 35-year termination allowance doesn't apply. Courts have ruled consistently on this point.

- In order to win, Mann needs to prove that he wrote Heat before he formed his loan-out company, or else that he wrote it on spec and granted the rights to his own loan-out company. The problem is that he has no documentation of either, and moreover the WB screenplay purchase paperwork for Heat includes representations signed by Mann that the work was written as a work for hire.

- Mann is now claiming that he actually wrote Heat before he formed the loan-out company, and granted the rights to it after he finished it. The catch: there was no written grant, just allegedly an oral grant from himself...to himself...

In the past, Mann would have no chance of winning this case. But Trump appointed several hundred MAGA judges to the federal bench who don't understand basic legal concepts so well and so it's a tossup as to how this case will actually turn out.

squidmaster 4 days ago |

[dead]

Sigmazero60 4 days ago |

[dead]

ydlr 4 days ago |

We should just stop pretending that copyright exists to benifit authors and declare that only corporations can own intellectual property.

emmelaich 3 days ago |

Boring comment: I thought this was going to be about Prof Mann the climate scientist and global warming.

swader999 4 days ago |

Not about climate change lol. Great movie.