Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Chemistry is Actually Geometry (https://chillphysicsenjoyer.substack.com)

349 points by sebg 4 days ago | 146 comments | View on ycombinator

divbzero 3 days ago |

This post did not go in the direction I expected. From the title I thought the post would explore how chemical reactions depend on the geometry of molecules and the distribution of electrons, but instead it delved into how chemical kinetics can be graphed geometrically.

duesabati 4 days ago |

I do not question the author's expertise, and I find the post very interesting; however, we really ought to stop mistaking the map for the territory. While drawing such analogies is certainly very useful and powerful, assuming that this represents reality is truly a stretch, as none of it can be proven.

Also I find it a bit pedantic on the "theory" word, giving me the impression that the author have forgotten that there is no theory before practicing, exploring or experimenting that's why it's called theory.

jsLavaGoat 4 days ago |

I worked in a lab where a geologist was taking soundings to understand the geometry of plate techtonics. Smart guy but needed a geek for the Sun server, so I got to ride along.

Anyway, lots of things are "actually geometry" but chemistry is kind of the one science that really does just reduce to QED first principles pretty cleanly. You don't hear a lot of talk about emergent chemical phenomena.

Arithmetic can be "actually geometry" if you're good with a compass and straight edge and the use of geometry to understand numbers is old.

Anyway, I'd say chemistry is actually physics and that may or not be actually math of any kind. At least in part, probably.

mjburgess 4 days ago |

All of natural science is (dynamical) geometry, since it is just a time-evolution semantics over the reals. (Since all bodies are just geometrical extensions in space and time).

thelastgallon 3 days ago |

Probably a lot of material science is understanding how the molecules are structured in various shapes, crystals, etc. For example, this video shows cool visualizations: What comes after lithium-ion batteries? - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=huMZI_7iZKA

Proteins fold, thats also geometry.

smj-edison 3 days ago |

Reading this, it seems they're using the term "geometry" in a more abstract sense. Pretty much you can turn a reaction's state into an abstract point, and then you can plot that reaction point over time. It becomes concrete again when they plot the path of the reaction's "coordinates" and you can visually see what happened with the reaction. It's quite elegant! Like you can see a system oscillate if it circles forever, or you can see it converge if it spirals inwards.

gus_massa 3 days ago |

This post is only about a tiny part of Chemistry, probably only half of the topic covered in the fists two years of a degree in Chemistry in the university. Later there are like 3 more years, and you may add 5 more for a PhD, and then there comes the weird research stuff.

The article is interesting to understand some cases, but the title oversells the coverage of Chemistry by a lot.

For example, there is nothing about organic chemistry. Let's pick one at random: What is the difference between CH3-O-CH3 and CH3-CH2-OH? They have the same atoms, somewhat similar structure, but they are very different materials and have very different reactions.

andai 3 days ago |

I found the first reference very interesting:

https://www.buildacell.org/101

Hoffesnthal 3 days ago |

While I don't have the chops to appreciate this post, it reminded me of this recent lecture by Raymond Goldstein where he goes into how the distribution of cells in simple multi-cellular organisms looks a lot like Voronoi tesselations.

Here's a related paper from his group: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.11939

djierardi 4 days ago |

Chemistry includes geometry, but its not JUST geometry. Its far more complex than that.

QuesnayJr 4 days ago |

This was pretty neat. I didn't know oscillatory phenomena were so common in chemical reactions.

bethekidyouwant 3 days ago |

"we would be forced to study complex chemical systems on a case-by-case basis, and each new case would be fraught with terrible analytical difficulties" - oddly we are entering an age to brute force this

fritzo 3 days ago |

I think they called this "dynamical systems" when I was in school

nine_k 3 days ago |

(A physicist might say that the entire reality is actually geometry.)

treems 4 days ago |

I was going to say "of course chemistry can be simplified into geometry, since chemistry literally becomes real world geometry in the real world", but I've realised that that misses nuance. Even early into the article, in "Chemical systems have surprising behaviours" it becomes pretty clear how such a sentence misses nuance (I'm not entirely sure oscilation between PH and other properties has an obvious real-world-geometry analogue, for example). So yeah pretty interesting article, thumbs up emoji

thewileyone 3 days ago |

I recall Lewis structures from Chem AP in high school and the first three quarters of Chemistry at university, no O-Chem. I can agree with the argument.

zkmon 3 days ago |

Suddenly, the web pages became 10x longer with 10x more images, images turned into interactive animations etc. Usually the goal for the content of a page, that has a "Conclusions" section at the end, is to provide enough evidence to support the conclusions. The size of such supportive evidence usually depends on the cognitive abilities and contextual presence of the audience and effort required for producing the content.

Conclusion: Based on the above, the 10x increase in the page content is hereby concluded to be due to the drastically reduced effort in producing the content.

undefined 4 days ago |

undefined

Dwedit 4 days ago |

analog8374 3 days ago |

Crystals interacting with a fluid environment is weird and probablistic.

Consider rock candy growing in solution.

If only reality was cube based, like some kind of Egany Minecraft thing.

mxfactorial 3 days ago |

analog31 3 days ago |

Well, considering that geometry is actually algebra...

jk

esafak 3 days ago |

If only they'd taught chemistry like this in high school.

westurner 3 days ago |

This appears to be true quantum chemistry and quantum circuit simulation as well; Complex Grassmanian GrC geometry and Layer-Coded Plabic VRC-SPA Ansatz to solve the speed-accuracy barrier:

- "Layer-Coded Plabic Graphs, Complex Vector-Relation Configurations (VRC), and Unrestricted Grassmannian Quantum Chemistry (QCI-GXC) in MADNESS Multiwavelet MRA-PNO and Tequila for Computational Advantage" (2026) > "2.1 Master Taxonomy Table of Lower Grassmannians in Quantum Chemistry, MADNESS MRA-PNO, and Tequila" https://westurner.github.io/sustainablefactory/grassmannian-... , https://westurner.github.io/sustainablefactory/grassmannian-...

DoctorOetker 3 days ago |

> Unfortunately, if we experimented with such processes in a closed vat, it would be impossible to estimate these rate constants with any certainty.

Nonsense, check out FT-ICR

Fourier Transform Ion Cyclotron Resonance Spectroscopy

https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/sci/chemistry/research/oconnor/oco...

It is both eyes and hands, you can selectively energize the kinetic energy of species at a certain resonance frequency.

Suppose A- + B- <=> C- + D-

Then you can push the balance to the left by transmitting the ion frequencies for C- and D-, or to the right by energizing A- and B- ion species. So you can actuate reaction coordinates.

Sweep wit a frequency or white noise to identify how much of what is currently present in your vat.

This tool is both eyes and hands.

BSPtree 3 days ago |

I am just here to say that I love the visuals...

undefined 3 days ago |

undefined

dodger-dog 3 days ago |

It is architecture.

sooraj_sj 3 days ago |

cant understand whats the anology ...

sandworm101 3 days ago |

Mandatory Xkcd on the subject: https://xkcd.com/435/

undefined 4 days ago |

undefined

freebsd_lovefes 3 days ago |

[dead]