Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Comcast's "fiber-powered Wi-Fi" is cable, AT&T says in false advertising case (https://arstechnica.com)

263 points by jaredwiener 4 days ago | 257 comments | View on ycombinator

bob1029 3 days ago |

Fiber is so much better than cable in an emergency. The equipment consumes significantly less power and is likely to stay up longer during a power outage. You get way more customers on each battery / generator.

I had an FTTH provider with 100% of their network on natural gas standby generators. Went through a week long power outage without losing a single packet. You can support something like 100k households with well under 50kW of power. There are homes with larger generators than this. Docsis 4 would put you somewhere around half a megawatt.

userbinator 3 days ago |

While Comcast has deployed plenty of fiber throughout the US, its cable Internet service makes the final connection to homes with coaxial cable. This results in upload speeds being far slower than download speeds. In contrast, fiber-to-the-home service can provide symmetrical upload and download speeds.

You can get symmetric DOCSIS, and apparently Comcast do offer that service[1]. Likewise, FTTH can be asymmetric if they set the traffic shaping that way. IMHO the only things that matter to the average user about an Internet connection are bandwidth, volume, and availability. As long as it terminates in WiFi or a standard Ethernet connector and passes IP traffic at the rate I paid for, I personally don't care what the physical infrastructure beyond the demarc is.

In fact, anecdotes from a few people I know have been that service interruptions actually increased after they upgraded to FTTH from DOCSIS.

[1] https://corporate.comcast.com/press/releases/comcast-multi-g...

ben1040 4 days ago |

Back in the days of rolling out U-Verse (their FTTN service), AT&T's advertising used exactly the same strategy of weasel-words to say "fiber" without making an actionable implication that it was fiber from A to Z. Phrases like "fiber rich network" and "U-Verse uses fiber optic technology."

cornedor 3 days ago |

This has been a thing in the Netherlands for years. Ziggo has been advertising with terms like "Glasvezel-Kabel" (Fiber Optic - Cable) to indicate that the fiber goes up to a switch in the area, but then goes over coax cable to the residential buildings.

They got a lawsuit, and for some weird reason they even won it. I don't know it it really matters in the end, they lose some (technical) customers, they win some customers. But it feels like a nasty tactic anyway.

Dutch: https://www.rechtspraak.nl/organisatie-en-contact/organisati...

trevithick 4 days ago |

The advertising in this space is terrible. I constantly see ads for "gig wifi" and similar terms and have no idea what the actual internet connection type is.

segmondy 4 days ago |

TMobile of all companies started offering fiber in my area. They ran fiber lines into the house. Real fiber too, I saw the install. 1000Mbps up/down. I hate Comcast & AT&T. TMobile for now can have all my money. So check your area if you are wanting to get one.

0cf8612b2e1e 4 days ago |

Consumer protection via companies calling out their competitors for lies.

I wish there were more effective options in play, but this could be a positive outcome, up until they all agree to stop directly attacking each other.

jacobgold 3 days ago |

Oddly, I'm kind of sympathetic with Xfinity here.

They now offer DOCSIS 4.0 1 gigabit and 2 gigabit fully symmetric connections over cable lines. Obviously it's not fiber, but it really does meet the average person's understanding of what "fast fiber optic internet" is in every way.

bdcravens 4 days ago |

Yeah I've started seeing Xfinity's billboards for this around town (a growing Houston area suburb), and it's odd to me advertising this as some new development, since I've had AT&T fiber for 4 1/2 years.

arjie 4 days ago |

GFiber (formerly Google Fiber) is also often microwave. We have some of their radios on our apartment building roof.

excalibur 4 days ago |

> “Comcast should be required to restore to AT&T any and all profits earned as a result of its false and misleading advertising or provide AT&T with any other restitutionary relief the Court deems appropriate,” the lawsuit said. The lawsuit asked for a permanent injunction “requiring Comcast to cease describing its hybrid fiber-coaxial service as ‘Fiber-Powered.’”

The people Comcast is swindling with their false claims are their own customers, not AT&T. In what universe should this money be refunded to AT&T? It was never theirs! They are not entitled to other people's money!

dataflow 3 days ago |

Taking for granted that they're right about this being misleading...

> AT&T demands Comcast give AT&T profits it made from advertising cable as fiber.

...is that really how it works? Your competitors get your profits? Are there no competitors beside AT&T?

kittikitti 4 days ago |

AT&T also marketed their 4G network as "5GE" which was flagrant false advertising. I don't think corporate really cares, they just want to harm the other corporation. This is just the status quo of telecommunications and tech in America. It's all a scam and marketing, and if you complain, then you're fired.

dehrmann 3 days ago |

On one hand, it's misleading. On the other, upstream and downstream capacities, quotas, and oversubscription ratios at different points in the network are what actually matter.

undefined 4 days ago |

undefined

octol 3 days ago |

I really don’t understand why Charter bought Cox Cable, and why Comcast is considering a merger with Charter. Yes it’s a shame that billions in RF cable infrastructure will go obsolete, but fiber really is that much better on several levels. I’d pay 10 bucks a month if my local cable company delivered a reliable feed of the digital tv signals, because my digital TV antenna is terrible.

mock-possum 3 days ago |

Oh that’s funny, I had the same gripe with Comcast - they kept saying they’d deliver fiber to the house, they’d install it, then it’d turn out to be coax/cable.

My roommates and I had them out to install, then canceled and refunded, like three times over the course of our ten years of living together. Each time, comcast and the installers lied about the service they were selling us.

martinald 4 days ago |

I mean Comcast is "fibre powered" from the CMTS onwards.

And DOCSIS4.0 can offer higher speeds than AT&Ts older GPON FTTH.

But regardless it is extremely odd Comcast is spending so much to do a DOCSIS4.0 upgrade, given the costs between that and eg XGSPON are not huge - both require a lot of new equipment and fibre laid.

I am unaware of anyone but Comcast that is adopting DOCSIS4. Afiak all European cable companies are moving to XGS-PON.

phoghed 4 days ago |

Retention guy tried to convince me that Spectrum was “mostly fiber”. Like yeah I’m sure there’s fiber in your network, let me know when it’s touching my house and I’ll switch back.

0x457 3 days ago |

I got frustrated with my spectrum docsis and decided to look for fiber providers in the area (One Wilshire is two blocks away, but no fiber around in residential buildings). Found Earthlink, went through hell trying to sign up with their voice llm bot, and then final ToS is something like this "just so you know, while plan called 'a gig', you probably going to get 400/20 at most".

Reminded me of a Spectrum guy crimping coaxial cable in front of and me telling me its fiber.

xp84 4 days ago |

lol. The only company lazier than Comcast at building FTTP[1] is throwing stones at them. Hilarious! AT&T barely showed up with fiber outside of big buildings when I lived in SF, topping out with 20Mb UVerse as recently as 2017. Now, I live in another area in their footprint and they just aren’t even playing. If you put my address in, in a high-priced suburb, they suggest cellular internet. I’d still be happy to see any big telecom ISP lose a lawsuit like this, because they’re all scum.

[1] edit: I should’ve said “building out infrastructure” since Comcast to be fair doesn’t build any FTTP to speak of, whereas AT&T builds a tiny bit. But if the question is “percentage of your footprint that can access a speed of 1Gbps over the infrastructure you’ve laid to their house” Comcast wins by a (last) mile.

expedition32 3 days ago |

Cable in my country had the advantage that it was already in every home- it was installed all the way back in the 80s to replace the infamous antennas.

But no matter what you do it is ancient tech that can't beat fiber so dig dig dig!

diggernet 3 days ago |

No love for Comcast here, but I'd be a lot more sympathetic to AT&T's argument if they were actually willing to offer their fiber service to me.

joquarky 3 days ago |

I was wondering how Comcast was going to fulfill their mailer ad to serve fiber to my home while there has been no digging in the ground.

zhazhaBooey 3 days ago |

Att took my $50 deposit, cancelled install day of.

Week of asking for a new date went by without receiving one.

Cancelled service order.

Att only sounds better in their PR releases.

slow_typist 4 days ago |

PoE, but over fiber. That would be fiber powered.

faefox 3 days ago |

Kinda rich coming from AT&T, the people who brought you "5Ge"

souenzzo 3 days ago |

Do USAians still believe in free market?

hefner1456 3 days ago |

Spectrum does this as well. "Fiber" sounds bettet then "Same Shit" I suppose

adamtaylor_13 3 days ago |

Funny enough, I got an ad in the mail from AT&T and saw the strange wording and used Claude to dig into it.

Immediately I was like, "Ohhh. They're full of shit. Got it."

I use AI to disambiguate all sorts of marketing nonsense these days. It's amazing.

slopnt 4 days ago |

well, it IS fiber-powered (fibers of copper wire)

undefined 3 days ago |

undefined

cmiles8 3 days ago |

Common sense says anything other than “FTTH” is not really fiber. Having some fiber in the network backbone (which is basically everything in 2026) doesn’t count as “fiber.”

Fiber is a pure and fully symmetrical signal in just your home. Coax is basically just RF over a wire and highly susceptible to all sorts of issues. That includes anyone in your neighborhood doing any of a long list of things including something as simple as having a cable not plugged into anything… which causes chaos on RF networks.

Coming from Comcast though, I suppose we shouldn’t be surprised at this nonsense.

dreamcompiler 3 days ago |

"Fiber-powered" reminds me of when you see an inverter advertised as "modified sine wave." Or something in the dairy case at the grocery store labeled "cheese food product."

trekkie99 3 days ago |

Pot calling the kettle black.

valleyer 4 days ago |

Both of these companies are doing the same thing. Yes, obviously Comcast is using the word "fiber" to try to piggy-back on the layman's shallow understanding of that word as "fancy Internet thing".

But so is AT&T. The practical limits of optical and DOCSIS are basically equivalent to a home user, but AT&T pitches their product as "fiber" to dazzle the uneducated customer.

In an ideal world, they'd compete just on latency, throughput, and reliability.