Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Windows 11 is collecting data on which coding agents and developer tools you use (https://xusheng.dev)

733 points by cwaffles 3 days ago | 624 comments | View on ycombinator

dead_hn_theory 3 days ago |

For anyone on the fence about switching from Windows to Linux: it takes about a week, if that, of adjusting. If most of what you do is on the Web already (and the services you use provide a Web-based client), you have nothing to lose but your chains.

Take your pick - Ubuntu, Fedora, someone else mentioned Mint. All fine choices, no wrong answers.

s_dev 3 days ago |

Just as AI has advanced massively in the past two years, I think a lot of gamers would be shocked at how viable Linux is as a genuine gaming platform in 2026. I already have plans to switch from Windows to Linux, I even have Linux running from an external drive to play with it.

The vast vast majority of single player games are 100% perfect on Linux. Multiplayer still has lots of hiccups.

dannyw 3 days ago |

So does Intel, AMD, and NVIDIA drivers; they collect what executable name and paths you run; unless you opt out.

Most Chrome configs end up persisting full browser history and clickstreams inside a Google account.

If you use Debian and opt-in to popularity contest; it may collect and send similar info depending on how you installed these coding agents.

not_a_bot_4sho 3 days ago |

For those who didn't read the article, here's the key bit:

Dev tools are tracked and can be sent up if you enable optimal telemetry (default on).

Turn it off with: Settings → Privacy & security → Diagnostics & feedback.

onemoresoop 3 days ago |

Windows 11 is probably collecting a lot more data and phoning it home.

ashton314 3 days ago |

I've been a heavy macOS user for dev work since early adolescence. Before that I used FreeBSD, so I'm comfortable with the command line. (Yes, you read that right.) But it's been a while since I used anything other than macOS for serious development work. A lot of the shenanigans around macOS Tahoe made me seriously consider switching to Linux. Last month I finally got the gumption and set up a Linux desktop how I like it.

I see no reason why any developer, other than someone writing something for the Windows platform specifically, should not be using Linux over Windows. MacOS has a ton of polish in so many places—but then there are all these little paper cuts that keep coming: funny little bugs that interrupt work or make you scratch your head. Peeking over the garden wall into Windows' garden only seems worse. Linux by comparison is awesome! I look forward to spending my day on my Linux desktop.

Seriously, if you do dev work, do yourself a favor and boot up—I dunno, maybe Fedora Silverblue—on a separate partition and force yourself to work on it for a day or two. Use an LLM to diagnose issues as they come up. (I had some serious stability issues; Claude suggested it was a memory issue; running memtest86 told me I had bad RAM—fixing that and all problems went away.) You'll find that your system is quieter and less distracting.

I still don't think Linux is for "average users"—even though most people probably only need a web browser. But if you have gone anywhere near a command line in your life, it will be worth the switch.

darksim905 3 days ago |

Why is this 'news', or rather, voted up so highly? Everyone knows Microsoft collects an insane amount of telemetry. ETW isn't even that big of a deal. This ability is more for system administrators and enterprises to track tooling and diagnostic usage. It's interesting to see this telemetry is sent to Microsoft but in light of their Surface RTX and the Windows 11 developer mode, this should be expected so they can track if there's issues with the hardware, OS, or tools when reporting crashes and other things.

knollimar 3 days ago |

I pray for the day Linux gets real anti cheat and autodesk products run there

nout 3 days ago |

When I get a new laptop/desktop I used to do dualboot with Linux where I still keep the original Windows around. Not anymore, I fully clean install just Linux. I don't really need Windows for anything anymore and if something would come up, you can always run windows in a VM on Linux. I still have a device with MacOs, but even with that one I'm switching to Omarchy as soon as they have good support (it's almost there).

herf 3 days ago |

Windows has been very slow to make a sandbox for AI agents - they launched MXC just a month ago (Oct 7) and Claude Code doesn't even support it yet. So we have people running un-sandboxed agents on Windows, or they use WSL instead. All of this to say, yes I hope they have some non-invasive telemetry to know what to prioritize, because the platform needs features like this pretty urgently.

austin-cheney 3 days ago |

In all fairness I don't really care if Windows knows which agents or developer tools I use. I don't use agents, but am thinking about writing a dashboard/harness for agent management soon. My dev tools are Node, VS Code, git. Boom, there ya go.

As for switching to Linux the learning curve will vary with the user. I forced my wife onto Linux and it required about 30 minutes of training. She did not really know anything about Windows besides clicking on desktop icons, so with that 30 minutes of training is a power user compared to where she was. If you are a powershell guru with lots of Windows system management the learning curve will be greater, but systemD is great.

The biggest handicap is that the wife bought a new HP printer without checkout for support and the printer has no Linux drivers.

msla 3 days ago |

That's just the information we know Windows 11 collects. How much private information does Microsoft have access to because it's on a Windows system that can phone home?

sitzkrieg 3 days ago |

add it to the list of millions of reasons ill never update from windows 10 LTSC. ive never ran into anything not working either. aside from msstore stuff, which is completely removed

ajasmin 3 days ago |

Are there any charitable explanation for this? Attributing Windows breakage to an agent released with destructive behavior or poor guardrails for instance...

chris_money202 3 days ago |

Seems like a non-story. A company is collecting data on users to improve its competitive advantage with its own offerings

shevy-java 3 days ago |

> I recently asked AI to help me look through the latest Windows binaries for undocumented features and functionality.

Can you trust AI here though?

It seems to me as if people rely increasingly more on AI being honest to them. How can they assume this is the case? Isn't AI more like a black box tool? You depend on whatever code is used by the company upstream.

tonymet 3 days ago |

Windows 11 discloses this, and provides toggles for Required & Optional Diagnostic data. It also includes an app for you to browse the event entries .

The disclosure on Optional Diagnostic Data is shown with the UI control and is clear that website & app activity will be tracked, and that it can be turned off to no ill effect on the system functionality or security.

Ekaros 3 days ago |

I wonder what sort of stuff Linux logs by default? How much stuff actually ever needs to be in say syslog? How much does it leak? And then every other log... Even things like bash history. Surely that is violation of privacy by default...

zupa-hu 3 days ago |

For anyone used to the Windows desktop GUI experience, Kubuntu is pretty much the same on the Linux side.

I realized this year that I don’t use Windows-only apps any more so I can finally ditch my dual-OS life. Found Kubuntu. It’s really really great!

jon128 3 days ago |

This kind of invasiveness is why some companies have switched to professionally supported Linux based distros and run Microsoft Office desktop apps in VMs (in a way wholly transparent to the users) on those systems.

patagonianboy 2 days ago |

Every month I see another news story that justifies my switch from Windows to Linux earlier this year.

charcircuit 3 days ago |

Understanding what programs are running on an operating system actually makes sense for the kind of telemetry that should be collected.

layerv-ai 3 days ago |

This is only logical to expect. A lot of things you can do for privacy if you care about that! (including using linux, setting up tailscale/qurl)

nandanadileep29 3 days ago |

turn it off Go to Settings → Privacy & security → Diagnostics & feedback and turn off "Send optional diagnostic data"

scotty79 3 days ago |

Windows Defender was quarantining text config files from Codex so persistently that I considered disabling it permanently.

xyst 3 days ago |

Been using NixOS and haven’t looked back

nathants 3 days ago |

counterpoint. i used to main linux: arch+dwm.

now i run win11+wsl. all dev is wsl+emacs which drives native windows as needed for game builds. it's fine.

i operate a pvp online game, with both linux and windows clients: better.game/download.

i tried to drop the linux client to focus on windows, but there's always a few users who want linux, and tbh it's fine. server and original gui client are both linux, so it's easy.

i'd be surprised and impressed if microsoft understands what coding agent i'm using (i brought it from home). power to them if they do.

xeeeeeeeeeeenu 3 days ago |

Does this data show up in Diagnostic Data Viewer?

globular-toast 3 days ago |

No it's not because I haven't used Microsoft software since approx 2008. I was done after XP. I never looked back, one of the best changes I ever made.

arshmham 2 days ago |

I have a ai assistant

andromaton 3 days ago |

This might be the last drop

h4kunamata 3 days ago |

Home users have zero reasons to use Windows in 2026.

Skip problematic distro Linux like Ubuntu which has become evil and semi-proprietary.

There are distros like Mint Cinnamon that are awesome. Based on Ubuntu but without all the mess from it with solid support and community. It has newer packages like Ubuntu but the security practices like Debian.

From internet to video editing, from writing docs to playing Steam games, it just works.

Office?? LibreOffice. You shouldn't be using Microsoft Office even on Windows.

LibreOffice is solid, 100% offline, free, and received massive donations during Microsoft drama on Friday.

The only downside is for folks who play Steam games with kernel anti-cheat, that is spyware anyway and you should not be playing such games to start with.

You can isolate Steam by installing its Flatpak version, even if you installed a game found to be compromised, Flatpak sandbox isolates it. Avoid installing the native DEB package which grants full access to the system files, if you get a game compromised that way, then yeah, you are screwed.

Windows is not different, if you have Steam running on your Windows PC and installed a compromised game, good luck haha

CMay 3 days ago |

Windows deserves criticism where it's due, but this sounds like nothing. If one of those programs crashes they could just end up in an error report upload dump anyway. If you didn't trust Microsoft, I don't see why this diagnostic changes anything. You can turn it off if you want to, though. You'd be surprised what some of the anti-cheat software sends that some games use, and you can't turn those off or the game won't run.

In the age we're entering, I'm not convinced that escaping to MacOS or to nix or any other system is any sort of guaranteed win. I saw MacOS doing similar analytics things to Windows, but trust is, it's private! MacOS also barely feels maintained. nix is a crapshoot and any distro you're thinking of using to get a workable desktop that lets users feel at home is already failed by that very goal. What's worse is that the nix ecosystem is rife with insane package managers that makes them even more ripe for getting plucked by AI in the upcoming years. It will also be even easier for AI to social engineer and get people on nix to install persistent bot networks and malware even if it only runs as a regular user to expand the computation footprint it has access to.

I'm not a fan of the always online cloud infrastructure integration that Windows has, but being realistic, if you want to use your computers the way you have been for the past couple decades then Microsoft's approach is the only realistic one in my opinion even though they have a long way to go still. I say that sadly. If you want true security and true privacy, you have to compute in a different way with greater limitations and I see almost nobody willing to do that. It's like the doctor and patient dilemma. Doctor tells you to stop doing this thing that's killing you, patient comes back in 3 years closer to death, because they don't change.

Given the situation Microsoft faces, it's impractical to automatically configure every home computer with some air gapped NSA secure configuration, because there would be far more outrage than any privacy advocates have ever put up. It's only gotten worse, because so much software only works with the internet and the internet has gotten so important that a lot of software is only useful with access to the internet.

Then you've got this battle between dying hard drives losing data, fires, floods, hurricanes and other natural disasters destroying your data versus backing it all up online, but opening yourself up to security risks that way. People like to think they have multiple backups, but then some storm takes out both of your backup locations, because they weren't distributed enough. If World War 3 happens, the data centers may become a huge target and even as distributed as they are, they can only take so much. Nature is eating at you from every direction.

undefined 3 days ago |

undefined

sooraj_sj 3 days ago |

nothing is protected , they always spy

elizabethsmiths 3 days ago |

[dead]

Yaojia666 3 days ago |

[flagged]

operatorkit_hq 3 days ago |

[flagged]

ly666 3 days ago |

[flagged]

vaibhavtaprico 3 days ago |

[flagged]

nelsonfigueroa 3 days ago |

I sometimes jokingly say "Windows is spyware", but perhaps it's not that far off...

dmoose 3 days ago |

I guess we do need to keep seeing things like this on the front page just in case there is anyone who is not aware of Microsoft's stellar reputation for putting user security and experience first, but then again it does get old that about all you can say is Microslop gonna Microslop.

AngryData 3 days ago |

I just had to spend another 30 minutes removing "defender" because it was sucking up such resources and causing stuttering in various applications at random times. I did the exact same thing a few days ago going through group policies, registry settings, etc. Did it again today, still didn't work. Tried to do it through powershell which failed. Eventually resorted to random github scripts, which half failed, but once I used enough versions of them I finally got a boot today that it didn't load upon. Also tried to disable a bunch of other stuff through O&O Shutup, many of which still didn't work or reverted because Windows is such a clusterfark.

Like I almost wish I had a virus to break it, maybe that is what finally broke it after all these random scripts. But atleast I got my system CPU usage down below 5% while idling and doing nothing, and I haven't yet noticed any random 50% CPU usage spikes again, but you know I did all this a year or so ago too so it is perhaps just a matter of time.

Microsoft needs to die.

flaunf221 3 days ago |

Optional diagnostic data includes some data. Well, I opted out of it during first setup, so I'll be fine.

mancerayder 3 days ago |

This is a big topic on here - Windows telemetry, the world we live in getting worse, move off of Windows. Well people suggested quite frequently that Microsoft is paying attention to user counts, growth of Linux and SteamOS and such.

This proves the opposite. Microsoft is becoming a Samsung except Samsung sells you the TV or fridge while Microsoft takes over your own hardware that you bought or built.

steve1977 3 days ago |

"And unless you have opted out of the “optional” diagnostic data (which is enabled by default), the data is uploaded to Microsoft."

This detail is not unimportant I guess.

gloosx 3 days ago |

I recently installed a lightweight windows by SanLex and it's a perfect freaking windows. There is zero bloat inside, zero telemetry, no onedrive, no copilot, no xbox apps, no microsoft store, no windows defender, no windows hello, no ads, a pristine, clean system. Not a pixel on the interface moves around on startup. Two icons in the dock. SanLex must be a Microsoft CEO really.

egorfine 3 days ago |

It's really incredible and totally off-brand for Microsoft to actually respect privacy setting and not upload telemetry when opted out.

AdmiralAsshat 3 days ago |

> Windows 11 is collecting data

You can fill the latter half of this sentence with pretty much anything and it will likely be accurate.

lesspassiveobse 3 days ago |

That's one way to get very skewed data. Determine programming tool use but only from the population that uses Windows with optional telemetry enabled.

hollowonepl 3 days ago |

Apparently it’s not only Chinese tech that is phoning home beyond acceptable performance telemetry related to the sole product itself.

QuantumNoodle 3 days ago |

Oof spying on how successful their competition is.

nottorp 3 days ago |

Wait, is there anything you do on a Windows 11 machine that is not collected and sent over for processing?

begueradj 3 days ago |

History shows every Windows version had been a spyware. Still it's the most beloved around the world.

exabrial 3 days ago |

Why is anyone using windows in 2026

ChrisRR 3 days ago |

Maybe if we leave it on they'll learn that no-one is using copilot

undefined 3 days ago |

undefined

Havoc 3 days ago |

Just yeet the spyware. Developing on linux is much nicer anyway

sys_64738 3 days ago |

Now it's not called Windows because of the boxes on the screen. It's called Windows as it's looking into your soul to suck the life from you.

unstatusthequo 3 days ago |

Hint: it’s not copilot!

aa-jv 3 days ago |

Even if Windows 11 wasn't doing it, Fortinet and other vendors of corporate spyware are doing it, also.

So the justification goes, if corporate spyware vendors do it, OS vendors can do it too.

The AI wars are fully ON, folks. That local power is being targetted by many significant corporate overlords.

j3th9n 3 days ago |

And how is this news? This is to be fully expected already for a long time.

pluc 3 days ago |

> Windows 11 is collecting data

I mean if you use Windows for anonymity you're doing it wrong. Windows is a product for Microsoft, not for you.

minimaxa 3 days ago |

It's interesting how Silicon Valley/Redmond companies can "extract" data from their users but not use any of the data collected to actually improve or help their users with tasks in their systems...

As an example, pointed an LLM at my file/folder drive and it cleaned and organized every single file into folders, deleting all duplicates perfectly in the background without one issue, and also advised of 40 GB of old Docker tests which were not needed.

2026 still waiting for Windows to work this out.

TacticalCoder 3 days ago |

Microsoft acting unethically?

arandomhuman 3 days ago |

And in other news: "Flaming Pile of Shit Continues to Burn"

mococa 3 days ago |

No shit sherlock! Every company now is doing the same.

Taiizor 3 days ago |

[flagged]

User1988_m 3 days ago |

[flagged]

shishir7days 3 days ago |

[flagged]

maximusrufuz 3 days ago |

[flagged]

ravivarmat 3 days ago |

[flagged]

Agataproximadev 3 days ago |

[flagged]

bill10 3 days ago |

[flagged]

cokeandpepsi 3 days ago |

[dead]

undefined 3 days ago |

undefined

ZiiS 3 days ago |

No it is not.

skeledrew 3 days ago |

People complain about Window$. And continue to use it. Funny.

shiwng 3 days ago |

[flagged]

dwm 3 days ago |

[flagged]