Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Dumping an AES key from a MyQ garage opener to stop rebooting when offline (https://kusha.me)

163 points by kusha 3 days ago | 70 comments | View on ycombinator

DannyBee 1 day ago |

Chamberlain actively fights all attempts at third parties buildnig tools to control/monitor/use their garage door openers so they can sell subscriptions.

Giving them money in the first place is a horrible idea.

blutack about 21 hours ago |

If anyone is in the market, the Hörmann basic openers are nice because they have basically a modbus port on them you can plug third party stuff into.

You can buy premade PCBs from a few open source projects to then connect the controller to Home Assistant etc. Because they speak to the controller over serial, they properly report the door position and can control the light as well as supporting partial opening.

I use this one: https://github.com/Gifford47/HCPBridgeMqtt and it's been rock solid for about a year now. It also has a temperature, humidity sensor and PIR sensor.

Also means you can then use Shelly BLE buttons or whatever as extra IP rated garage door openers.

VTimofeenko 1 day ago |

When picking out a jackshaft garage door opener a couple of years ago, I went out of my way not to get anything that has MyQ. Overhead Garage Door (the company) stocks what they refer to as Odyssey 2000, and it comes with an optional WiFi module, which I skipped. The opener is more than happy to just toggle open/close state if the contacts are momentarily bridged.

I paired it with Zen17, though in hindsight I could have just gone with an esp32 hidden right next to the motor.

Open/closed state is reported by a separate tilt sensor, which I might also swap for something else if only not to have to swap yet another battery

Namidairo 1 day ago |

If they didn't bother flipping the security flag in OTP to disable JTAG, then one has to wonder whether they even used secure boot and signed images.

One could just end up repacking the image with their own certificate chain, or patching out the reboot itself.

whatever1 1 day ago |

Get from Amazon a robo finger that presses buttons and have it press your garage door switch

don-code 1 day ago |

I'm happy it's possible, but I'm not sure if I'm sufficiently happy to offset the fact that it's necessary.

This also makes me wonder why it's necessary. What requirement were they trying to solve for? Does lack of Internet connectivity mask some bigger problem with the firmware on the device periodically needing a restart?

Polizeiposaune 1 day ago |

Ditching the MyQ and buying a ratgdo seems lots easier.

doodlebugging 1 day ago |

A lift spring on my old (1995) Chamberlain garage door broke one day. It basically shattered, sending a couple chunks of spring steel flying around the garage bouncing off of all the crap that I have "stored" out there. It was loud. We had no idea what had happened and I went outside trying to track the noise thinking that maybe a deer had run head-first into the garage door or...

Anyway, I decided based on the noises that it must involve something inside the garage. Good luck finding anything in there. I opened the door with the clicker remote and didn't notice any issues so I walked the "path" through all the accumulated things that needed new homes and as I was making my way back out the door I saw an unusual chunk of steel on the floor and a pulley that I know had not been there the last time I was in the garage. I began visually searching everything inside the garage trying to match those items found on the floor and that is when I saw the spring dangling on one side of the door and the lifting cables drooping.

That's when it hit me that I'm lucky our cars don't fit in there any more. All the energy stored in that spring when it popped could've cost me a couple of windshields, some body panel damage, etc but since my garage collects unfinished projects instead of automobiles all of the flying garage door parts bounced off of boxes and the sheetrock walls and did not damage anything important.

We briefly considered calling a garage door installer to deal with it so that we could replace both of the doors (two-bay garage). They had replaced a door on my shop a few years back and were reasonably priced and that Chamberlain door has functioned perfectly. Since the only parts compromised were the springs, pulleys, and cables on one side of the door I decided not to replace the door. There are spring kits available that allow a DIY replacement in a few hours so I went that route. Very inexpensive.

After reading comments here I am so glad I did not buy new doors. The last door we bought was produced before all the enshittified cloud crap. I replaced the remote panel controller this summer with a new, cheap control panel that looked identical on the outside but is slightly different internally since it is a generic replacement for the OEM part. Works great.

kusha 3 days ago |

A bit of context that didn't make it into the writeup:

The 819LMB is a HomeKit based device, meaning by HomeKit spec it is supposed to function 100% locally on your LAN with zero internet access. (most connect it to home assistant)

In their infinite wisdom, Chamberlain decided to cripple it anyway: if the garage door opener cannot reach their cloud, a firmware watchdog triggers a hard reboot every 30 minutes, taking down local HomeKit control along with it. Additionally, if you don't block the internet the right way, it reboots every 10 minutes in addition to the 30 minute reboot.

jmbwell 1 day ago |

There’s so little to these machines. Seems like an open source PCB to replace the proprietary would be feasible. Relays, limit switch inputs, obstruction sensors, current sensors, control input. Commodity stuff. I’m sure chamberlain is doing everything they can to make it seem more mystical than it is. Just to make number go up I suppose

tonymet 1 day ago |

very cool work. Clearly Chamberlain is very poor at writing software interfaces. I’ve witnessed duplicate closure commands that almost damaged my vehicle. There are many customers with damage due to MyQ on Reddit.

I now only use MyQ as a last resort.

ProAm 1 day ago |

My g-d I hate the MyQ software with a passion. Nothing works on it consistently except for the ads they show. Two-factor auth? You're going to have to do it multiple times. Set your security preferences, they'll reset them at will. Notifications about the garage door being open, closed, etc.... More like we'll notify you about ads and things we want to sell.

doctorpangloss 1 day ago |

do the Bosch Smart e-bike system next

God what fucking fuckwads

MalgorzataKowal 1 day ago |

[flagged]

bciuca 1 day ago |

[dead]