Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Mem Is Shutting Down (https://get.mem.ai)

79 points by qainsights 3 days ago | 127 comments | View on ycombinator

dvt 3 days ago |

First of all, I really do think people got a bit carried away with the "ChatGPT, summarize this email" meme. AI really is a revolutionary technology, but low hanging fruit like note-taking, summarization, etc. are not even remotely a killer product.

Second, I also think that (outside of search), we'll look at the chatting interface of today's AI tools in 5 years and laugh at how antiquated they seem.

Finally, Obsidian (not to mention Apple Notes) is free. So to be competitive here, your value prop has to be an absolute home run. I'm never going to root against fellow entrepreneurs, but this just seems like a more pricy, maybe more stylish Obsidian (without all the plugin ecosystem? and you also need a browser extension?). Obviously, hindsight is 20-20, but if I were to release a productivity app today, I would do a few things:

1) Open Source it. Especially in the age of agents, people want to make sure that no shenanigans are being done with sensitive data, especially when it involves private notes.

2) Dual license it. Folks have done this since Red Hat, and I think dual licensing for personal & professional use (or have a revenue cutoff like Unreal or Unity) is the move.

3) Create a plugin ecosystem around it. I think the great thing about agents is that even non-technical folks can come up with stuff and vibe-code a plugin. Incentivize people to do this and build a community.

maplet 3 days ago |

Reminds me of kepano's File Over App [1] philosophy.

> Apps are ephemeral, but your files have a chance to last.

1: https://stephango.com/file-over-app

mrweasel 3 days ago |

Nothing against Mem, or people trying to built something, but this will become a problem for the larger AI companies. Much of their current revenue is coming from smaller startups building product on top of e.g. ChatGPT. While useful, I question if these smaller players will survive, especially if they have to pay the actual cost of their token usage.

On the other hand, OpenAI is releasing Dot, so maybe they'll just service those customers directly in the future, or at least some of them.

futuraperdita 3 days ago |

Roughly $29 million in VC went to this product.

talmr 3 days ago |

I’ve been talking to (small/mid) business owners, consultants, etc.

Many of them say they don’t care about integrations or AI.

skeledrew 3 days ago |

Happy user of org-mode for the past 10 years. Nothing else is a flexible IMO.

kepano 3 days ago |

It's always difficult to shut down gracefully but Mem seems to be doing a better job than most. Their site offers export options and migration guides for Obsidian and other apps. Looking back at the history of the company, I was surprised to find they'd raised $29 million in funding. That made Mem among the most funded VCware apps in the space. For comparison:

- Notion: $340m (that we know of)

- Evernote: $290m

- Mem: $29m

- Tana: $25m

- Craft: $20.8m

- Anytype: $13.4m

- Roam: $9m

- Logseq: $4.1m

- Obsidian: $0

I have always admired silver and licat for knowing early that they would shun the VC path and build Obsidian without investors. Having watched the downfall of Evernote from afar, and experienced the pressures of VC first hand, I was afraid they might be swayed by investors waving big checks at their noses. It's one of the reasons I wanted to join Obsidian because I felt it was possible to build a 100% user-supported company in this space [1].

Being bootstrapped has many downsides. It means Obsidian can't subsidize pricing, can't make big speculative bets, can't hire as many people, can't parallelize projects as much... There is certainly survivorship bias, but as I look at the landscape six years after launch, Obsidian is still alive and well. I think building without investors made us stronger.

It's a twist of irony that OpenAI's VC fund was one of the biggest investors in Mem, yet the app never adopted Markdown as a storage format. I could have never predicted that Markdown would become as popular as it is today. Even before LLMs, I felt confident .md files would outlive Obsidian. Now I feel more confident than ever that "File over app" is a philosophy that will outlive us all [2].

[1]: https://stephango.com/vcware

[2]: https://stephango.com/file-over-app

rgdevment 3 days ago |

I'm a privacy fanatic, not to say obsessive. With Notion, one day I put in my card and didn't notice how much they were charging me until the end of the month. My home is an anti-telemetry bunker. But why should I be the one putting up the bars and living locked in?

I got tired of it and built my own app: very basic at first, but it met my requirements: private, no account, no subscription, no telemetry. Little by little I kept adding things. Everything is a .md file (documents, ideas, tasks), and everything is stored locally; if you want, also encrypted in your own cloud. There's nothing else behind it.

I realized I wasn't the only one with this problem and, learning from colleagues, friends and the internet, I kept adding features to work with agents, because another thing I hate is every app forcing you to pay for its own AI when I already have my favorite agents.

Today I have a huge list of improvements and features that I add little by little in each version. My goal is a local store of shared memory between you and your agent: for us, something visual (drag, drop, decide, delegate); I confirm what's done and what isn't, the agent works for me, and we keep everything organized, each speaking its own language, across many projects in parallel.

Take it with a grain of salt, I'm the developer so of course I'd say this. It's called Tisty and it's open source: github.com/rgdevment/Tisty. If you're curious, take a look: in the end everything stays on your machine and all the .md files are still yours.

(English isn't my first language.)

pulkitsh1234 3 days ago |

I have been building a note taking app which can launch Pi agents, running fully locally, backed by markdown: https://solipsist.sh/

privacyishuman 3 days ago |

Is there any cross platform open source notes app with as good UI as Apple Notes?

NoboruWataya 3 days ago |

I don't really understand the variety and complexity of note taking apps that have emerged the last few years. Taking notes has to be the simplest thing in the world, why over-engineer it like this? I used to use Joplin, recently I've realised that a text editor + git gives me everything I need.

FinnLobsien 3 days ago |

My theory on this is that Mem existed in a weird middle ground:

1. Note taking as a mechanism to organize one's knowledge or learn things faster is (in my experience) largely useful because the process is manual. The linking between notes and conscientious note-taking is useful because it forces your brain to be attentive and resurfaces knowledge you may have forgotten.

When AI does the connecting, you lose part of that, which the personal knowledge management crowd probably didn't fully connect.

2. ChatGPT memory, AI meeting recorders, and similar apps united the more utilitarian aspect of "remember stuff I need to know" in tools you use for direct work so you didn't need a separate AI note-taking app.

-

I do applaud the Mem team for making a genuine attempt at something genuinely interesting and new.

andrei_gusev 2 days ago |

Considering how much we talk to AI agents now, I think a separate notes app is no longer relevant. Ideally, the agent should remember everything. Though there are still a lot of problems here. I ran into this when I was renewing my Japanese business visa, and that thing is very bureaucratic. So I spun up a RAG in the cloud and connected it to my Claude over MCP. It made me happy, I got really hooked on it, then got my colleagues hooked, and in the end turned it into a full service.

ziofill 3 days ago |

Ha, I didn't know about this. A few months ago I built an app to capture fleeting thoughts without breaking you flow: https://getquicklog.com/

pelcg 3 days ago |

Does anyone still use Mem? Haven't heard from them in a while until now.

ares623 3 days ago |

And on the horizon, I saw a pale, white horse. And its rider was Death.

nxtfari 3 days ago |

Mem was so exciting to me when I first heard about it. Unfortunately they just shipped the most compelling features too slowly, and had too much you couldn’t try behind the sub. Didn’t get traction with me and I imagine a lot of people felt similar.

Wonder if we’ll see the scavengers of Bending Spoons descending shortly.

tulo 3 days ago |

Nice that they gave a 60-day export window, though shutdowns like this are why I keep long-term notes in plain local Markdown/SQLite.

mellosouls 3 days ago |

Best wishes to the mem team - good to see what looks like a smooth and well-signposted export process as they close.

charcircuit 3 days ago |

I don't understand why it can't just be read only forever. It's just notes.

panja 3 days ago |

Anyone looking for an alternative, I think Voicenotes has some overlap.

andsoitis 3 days ago |

> difficult decision

What made it a difficult decision?

cowpig 3 days ago |

Odds your memories will be sold to Mercor?

orliesaurus 3 days ago |

Surprised they lasted this long TBFH.

weikju 3 days ago |

Queue Google/etc buying up all that data on the cheap for AI training...

iLoveOncall 3 days ago |

Seeing the AI bubble slowly deflate is truly a joy.

undefined 3 days ago |

undefined

jocelyner 3 days ago |

[dead]

markjgx 3 days ago |

[dead]

thegliby 3 days ago |

[dead]

sreekanth850 3 days ago |

This show how brainless and broken is investor ecosystem. How the hell they invest 29 million in a product with saturated market with 1 product launching every day?