Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Bank CEOs, NSA Tell Congress That AI-Driven Patches Are Behind Outages (https://www.washingtonsun.com)

98 points by ryeights 2 days ago | 58 comments | View on ycombinator

skeledrew 2 days ago |

> AI-Driven Patches

This is very ambiguous and click-baity. Reading just that title gives - at least me - the impression that AI patches are behind the outages. Read the content, and it's the patching of legacy systems in a rush after getting AI feedback about vulnerabilities, that caused the outages; 0 mention of how much AI was used in the actual patching. The former places blame squarely on the use of AI for patching, and the latter places it on the rushed fixes.

Also I'm finding it pretty wild that all these outages are suddenly occurring within this short a timespan. It's as if there was something time-based, like the Y2k bug, except nobody had a clue.

nixosbestos 2 days ago |

People are reading the article, or the first few sentences, right?

> Wall Street executives and the National Security Agency have told members of Congress that this week’s widespread tech outages were caused by attempts to fix vulnerabilities identified by artificial intelligence, according to three sources familiar with the private conversations.

aka, possibly rushed patches/patching, in response to AI-discovered vulns. As far as I can tell "AI-authored patches" is not really mentioned in this article. (Whether that's true or not, I won't speculate, but it's weird to see the several comments just jumping on "AI patching bad".)

bg24 2 days ago |

I see this as following for many failing organizations.

- We used to take 1 month per patch. Mostly manual process.

- With AI, we implemented the process of 2 patches per week. Same old process. Solid verification is missing. Rollback is manual.

bagacrap 2 days ago |

> They’re trying to push through a lot of patches all at once — more than the system was designed for.

How is a system designed for a certain rate of patches?

paul_h 2 days ago |

AI-driven patches are nearly the proximate cause here, maybe. Root cause would be AI ttacks on infra that's dialed up in the six weeks. Automonous, fast acting on vulns including reverse engineering ones from patches ahead of their news embargo date. Thr challenge to CEOs is how to get dev and ops to respond as fast *with* good testing of deployment impact.

MiroslavPokorny 2 days ago |

Doesnt explain why stuff is down.

Big companies have been doing software releases for years, a release shouldnt take a company down.

Unless of course each and every one of these companies had a really bad vuln and they couldnt risk it and had to immediately stop business just in case.

Seems strange that they all managed too coordinate and decide to "act" at the same day at the same time and yet nobody else knows why.

dabinat 2 days ago |

I’m not sure where people got the idea that just because AI can write code now, it doesn’t need to be reviewed or tested.

TacticalCoder 2 days ago |

> Bank CEOs, NSA Tell Congress That AI-Driven Patches Are Behind Outages

Don't know about the causal relationship but the correlation between major software outages and devs turning their brains off and beginning to use LLMs is interesting.

metalman 2 days ago |

÷10 , not 10x

rurban 2 days ago |

So that's the inaccurate summaries the leaders are getting?

The flight outtage was from a contractor doing a router upgrade over day, instead of overnight. Has nothing to do with AI driven patches.

Microsoft is just too incompetent to run updates anymore. Driven by AI, yes, but failed by incompetence.