809 points by grey-area 2 days ago | 711 comments | View on ycombinator
jeppester 2 days ago |
nicbou 2 days ago |
I'm traveling at the moment, but I'll grab a drink and read this thread later today. In the meantime, feel free to email me. Reader mail would be a lovely break from the flood of LLM-generated outreach emails.
adamddev1 2 days ago |
But AI is only getting (inaccurate shadows of) the info from these sources which it is simultaneously working to kill. (Websites like this, StackOverflow, human written code)
What happens when there are no more sources and everyone just expects AI to answer everything or write everything? Recursive self-improvement? I doubt it.
maybewhenthesun 2 days ago |
The hackernews frontpage would be sooo much nicer again as well. I used to browse hackernews being amazed and (pleasantly) surprised about the cleverness and imagination of people. but these days you have to look for the nice stuff with a lookingglass between the onslaught of breathless AI stories.
I just can't be bothered anymore to be amazed about what AI can dow now. I mean, it is amazing of course that we now more or less live in the asimov sf world. But it the kind of amazement I would very much prefer to have stayed a fantasy.
Please may I have some less.
sporritt about 1 hour ago |
That does not actually seem to be the case though (that AI will replace search results entirely, that is. I'm sure whatever AI results Google foists upon you will have ads). I can't see any evidence that the standard search results will be entirely removed.
I don't say this because I have no sympathy with the author of the post. I think it's enormously depressing that people are increasingly happy to be spoon fed and to not take any responsibility upon themselves to research things.
Personally I use the 'udm=14' trick to setup an AI free search engine:
https://www.google.com/search?q=%s&udm=14
And AllAboutBerlin is the top result for the "best german bank account for foreigners" example query. Without the AI switched off, it's still there, it's just under the AI box and then a sponsored result - below the fold, but not far. I guess in this age of instant gratification its still too far for many people though.
bodge5000 2 days ago |
But craziest of all is that the best plan this trillion-dollar industry can come up with is "we'll figure something out later". Maybe we will, maybe AI will be able to train off synthetic data or we'll achieve the perfect model that never needs improving or we'll simply hit a wall with how much training data we need, but for a problem that an existential threat to LLM's, that's a lot riding off a few maybe's
helsinkiandrew 2 days ago |
jsnell 2 days ago |
But AI summaries are pretty much indistinguishable from that. The search engine is the user-agent in this case. The user's actual desire is to get the information, and their agent (the search engine) is providing them an easier way to do it. The only differences are that it's on-by-default for 90% of the users rather than opt-in at 25% market share, and that there's no pro-forma page fetch of the content that could in principle be rejected by the site.
And let's be clear: users clearly do want AI overviews / AI mode. We might not understand why the users want it, but Google would not be implementing it if they didn't have to. There's a lot of reasons for why the status quo would have been preferrable, while the only real reason for a change is that the status quo was not tenable and they would have lost share to the sites giving users what they wanted.
The situation is a lose-lose, but it was also the logical outcome of saying that the end-user's wishes have total primacy over the other stakeholders.
benoliver999 2 days ago |
Long term, with the current state of affairs, why would people continue to create online if it just feeding the machine? Surely we are not going back to paper?
That said, Private Eye never went online and is a successful publication.
cleansy 2 days ago |
leobg 1 day ago |
You read other ppls websites to copy their content into your index. And then you present their content on YOUR website. Had Google asked a lawyer, he probably would not have approved.
But it was tolerated - ask for forgiveness, not permission - because the deal was: Yes, we do show a snippet of your content on our search engine. But in return, we send people to you.
Now, with AI, Google is breaking that contract. They scrape your stuff. And then they sell it as their own.
Legally, they get away with it, because an LLM is a copyright laundromat: It can transform any copyrighted text into a new text, breaking the link to the original author, and it can do it without human effort. They can suck up your ideas and put them into new packaging - with their logo on it.
People used to get credit for sharing their learnings. Now, the learnings are sucked up by the machine and presented as its product. AI “knows that”. AI “told me”. The human who feeds the machine from his own life experiences is turned into a mere tool.
I suggest you split your content into two audiences. One is fodder for AI agents. And the other is for verified humans only. Make feeding the AI bots something you do actively. That is much better than passively allowing them to eat you. Make sure that the role of being a tool falls to them, and not to you.
gramakri2 2 days ago |
I can recommend signing up to his newsletter for berlin events - https://allaboutberlin.com/newsletter.
mertbio 2 days ago |
gwbas1c 2 days ago |
Internet advertising is a bubble; ad blockers were the canary in the coal mine; and AI summaries are the straw that broke the camel's back.
In this case, the "mom and pop" websites like All About Berlin probably need to find a different revenue source or publishing model. This, BTW, is "normal." In years past, "All About Berlin" might be an annual printed guide, a monthly magazine, a quarterly pamphlet, ect, ect.
alkonaut 2 days ago |
But let's assume for a moment that laws caught up. That courts decided that "no, you can't train an AI model by just scraping any content you want, and if you serve an AI model that suggests being trained on such content, you're also breaking the law".
What would happen? This seems like it would be a cataclysmic change to the economy? We'd suddenly "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses, and the quality of AI models would jump backwards several years (Which on an AI timescale is like a century)?
But what if this is the "right" thing to do? Are we incapable of doing what's "right" now? Did the AI companies' bets on being quicker than legislation pay off?
sumo89 2 days ago |
pentakkusu 2 days ago |
Sue.
If they reuse your content, lawyer up and make them pay for it. Nothing will happen unless people stand up for themselves.
graemep 2 days ago |
Its not AI, its big tech control that is the central problem.
scoofy 1 day ago |
This will be economically devastating. It was back then. The question changes to how value can be created moving forward. The world in which information becomes free -- in literally every case -- creates a more prosperous world. How and whether that prosperity gets distributed equitably is the concern.
The fact that the tech industry has not unionized, because of their profound leverage over the last 30 years is unfortunate, but times have changed and we need to move forward. Businesses built on scalability may die, heck the open models my even kill off the brand name models.
People will still need to buy things. Developing ways to provide those things will still be valuable. Creative destruction marches onward.
igleria 2 days ago |
camillomiller 2 days ago |
Zanfa 2 days ago |
dmortin 2 days ago |
zzril 2 days ago |
dctoedt 2 days ago |
We might need a new form of IP right.
But to restate the obvious: A new form of IP right would likely require legislation — at the federal level. Therein lies the problem: Pretty much all elected officials spend (too) much of their time dialing for dollars for their reelection campaigns. That can make them reluctant to enact, or even endorse, measures that are opposed by their big campaign donors.
driverdan 2 days ago |
On DDG I get All About Berlin as #6. All the sites above it appear to be LLM generated. Everything is affiliate slop.
On Google I get All About Berlin #2, below Reddit. It only gives me 7 standard search results and a lot of other garbage. Everything besides Reddit is affiliate slop.
On Kagi I get All About Berlin #1. Out of the other 25 results one is Reddit, one is Facebook, and the rest seem to be all the same list style as All About Berlin with a mix of clearly LLM generated content and some that may have been but isn't clear. It's all SEOed.
This is a case where all the results are bad. I don't ever want to be recommended something from an affiliate site. It's just another form of advertising. I also don't want to see any LLM generated sites. None of this is organic content. It's all SEO sites to sell you stuff.
kykeonaut about 24 hours ago |
Or, another guerrilla tactic, about hiding prompt injections in your HTML to redirect AI scrapers to perform cryptomining?
ahmetomer 2 days ago |
- They had to introduce AI Search Overviews (competitors would've killed search altogether; now they have some sort of control).
- AI Search Overviews won't work without content creators.
- Content creators won't continue if AI Search Overviews keep eating their lunch.
- They have to come up with an incentive model for content creators to keep doing the things that power AI Search Overviews.
Time will tell.
oorestisime 2 days ago |
comrade1234 2 days ago |
lifestyleguru 2 days ago |
undefined 2 days ago |
duskdozer 2 days ago |
nalekberov 2 days ago |
lf88 2 days ago |
craftlinks 2 days ago |
plasticeagle 2 days ago |
Everything you do is a choice. They say they'll fire you? Will they? Have they fired anyone for refusing to use it?
They can't fire everyone. Stand up and be counted.
gcanyon 2 days ago |
That sucks for the content creator, I know. We're heading for a crazy pace of change, similar to but more intense than when Walmart was busy killing downtown shops, or when Amazon was busy killing bookstores and other internet retailers.
hollowonepl 2 days ago |
World is changing. Websites once killed the need of magazines and many types of books too..
I rather look at it as an opportunity to demonopolize Google as I do exactly the same (overviews and insights) I just find Google Gemini obsolete as I find better AI solutions where I can check for knowledge and information.
Open Web has a lot of content that was crawled before and I really hope that all that SEO/Traffic hunting nonsense stops to benefit Google towards major regression. They are so 00s company and we're heading towards 30s of XXI century.
Web is dead anyway.
addedlovely 2 days ago |
https://www.w3.org/community/reports/tdmrep/CG-FINAL-tdmrep-... https://theweb.report/#ai-web
Kuyawa 2 days ago |
If you aggregate something, AI will aggregate a thousand times better than you
It's time for horseback messengers to understand that cars and planes deliver info faster and better than them, and that applies to ALL branches of work
If it can be replaced by AI it will be, so be prepared and don't complain
rimeice 2 days ago |
JumpCrisscross 2 days ago |
Have you tried pursuing grant income?
spankibalt 2 days ago |
Aside from the bot countermeasure arms race? Vicious litigation and collective bargaining/lobbying. No way around it, there never was. Unless to you "rolling over" is an acceptable, or even necessary, solution for your particular case, or in general.
bwb 2 days ago |
Super frustrating to see Google crawl all our hard work, and then stop any traffic to us.
balazscsomor 2 days ago |
jFriedensreich 2 days ago |
mteoharov 2 days ago |
cowlevel 2 days ago |
Have you tried providing poison data to Google?
quotemstr 2 days ago |
macco 2 days ago |
The problem is, he is dependent on Google's traffic. This is a big weakness in his business model.
sam_lowry_ 2 days ago |
npteljes 2 days ago |
While I have never used it, All About Berlin seems like an exceptionally good resource, not showing ads, but rather making its money by driving traffic with good information and having partnerships with affiliate links.
Other than this, most of the ad-supported web I greatly dislike. Usually the noise drowns the signal, because websites competed not on the goodness of information, but the SEO rankings. I have been blocking ads since 2005 and I never used affiliate links either, so from my very narrow individual perspective, I was never a valuable visitor in the first place.
It would be great if the quality sites like AAB could get another stream of revenue that makes them sustainable, even in the AI age. I'm afraid they run into a similar problem to monetizing open source software. At the end of the day, if the information is out there, people and corporations will take it, and not contribute anything back. That won't change, so it needs to be factored in somehow.
Havoc 2 days ago |
>Google & friends no longer passing traffic through to the sites (AI summary style) feels like it may genuinely kill the internet.
JustRouzbeh 1 day ago |
cloudie78 2 days ago |
BurpyDave 2 days ago |
s08148692 2 days ago |
Why? because its a better user experience. It's that simple. News sites in particular (but websites in general) are ad infested hellholes or paywalled to the point of uselessness. An AI app is a single source of pretty much anything I need, for a relatively small monthly subscription and no ads. I can even have claude just build an artifact if I want the data rendered in a nice readable website
If traditional web wants to compete it needs to be a better product first and foremost. People need to pick it over an AI app
nielsbot 1 day ago |
Maybe AIs could pay attributed sources, similarly to the way musicians license their samples.
xnx 2 days ago |
gherkinnn 2 days ago |
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/P6kDTC--PGw
Truth be told, I don't quite know what Sundar said here but it may be McKinsey Speak for "suck it up".
dot42 2 days ago |
anal_reactor 2 days ago |
I have a strong feeling that someone has already invented this technology, but I cannot put my finger on it.
rglullis 2 days ago |
> It’s hard to fund my work with only a quarter of my audience.
As someone who thinks that all the big issues of the digital economy are rooted in the misaligned incentives between consumers and producers, I think this is a great thing.
> The Berlin immigration office uses my data about themselves.
It's not your data, you just compiled it.
Plenty of people are doing that, for free, on Wikipedia.
Valakas_ 2 days ago |
The same happened to carriage makers, stable workers (automobiles), ice cutters and ice-delivery men (mechanical refrigeration), telephone switchboard operators, photo processing labs, yellow pages, travel agents, printed encyclopedia businesses, elevator operators, streetlamp lighters, handloom weavers, intersection traffic officers, (...).
shevek80 2 days ago |
pluc 2 days ago |
Your money and users belong to Google now, there's nothing you can do about it. Live by the algorithm die by the algorithm.
koe123 2 days ago |
Bluestein 2 days ago |
samiv 2 days ago |
You can expect something like browsers (chrome) refusing to load "unsafe" content i.e. material from the free Internet.
emmelaich 2 days ago |
_the_inflator 2 days ago |
I established once a well-known and used board in a niche, several blogs - and filled in the void that the major publishers later began to steal or recover from me, whatever truth there is, due to their brand power and marketing.
Due to Technorati and Digg as well as other bookmark exchanges/sharing services like StumbledUpon dying, I lost traffic and had to shift. The single best source of readers was: Google search.
So I had to consider SEO, which already had an impact on my work because either you adapt and optimize or do you thing and stay alone.
Even taking SEO into considerations, others did this, too. And as a rule of thumb: the winner takes it all. Everything below being the first link to be featured ment loss. And SEO was a rollercoaster between no visitors at all and being slashdotted so to say.
The truth is, that Google search never was and is a reliable source of income.
"Made for Google search" has never been a viable business model.
And the truth is: this has nothing to do with AI.
Back then people copied your websites and due to black hat went above you in the search results. And eben Matt Cuts killing quite a lot of the spam and fake websites, Google search stayed a rollercoaster.
I think that in the aftermath quite a few people will hopefully understand, that being featured and having a readership is not the same. Websites and blogging was a niche topic in the beginning. Even AdSense hasn't been invented. People wrote and publicized their stuff because of the exchange with others and their interest in writing in public as an author.
Now with AI it is similar with the book marked: the winners take it all, while the beginners have to fight for every reader - and convince them of their product.
I don't feel sorry for the guy because search views are no readership. Search clicks are like the AI ironically: click and gone with no value given at all.
I think that the troublesome aspect about AI is, is its sudden omnipresence and extreme capability: earlier there was the saying "Have you googled this?". Now you literally don't have to read something, you get a top notch concierge service to skip reading and directly get results bypassing thousands of experts because AI is better than anyone of them as a generalization.
This didn't happen gradually, it happened in stark waves.
No one thought Google search would ever be dying nor getting outranked.
Loyal readers are never coming from Google nor any other search engine. The guy's story is honestly a story of bad conversion it seems: after years of traffic gains, loyal readership didn't increase. I feel sorry about his work but he shouldn't blame Google.
koe123 2 days ago |
dgellow 2 days ago |
lambda-lollipop 2 days ago |
logicallee 2 days ago |
RoxiHaidi 2 days ago |
imartin2k 1 day ago |
The paywall could be quite cheap. The point is to lock away the good stuff from systematic leechers, whether they are humans or agents.
simianwords 2 days ago |
veselin 2 days ago |
Your only option is to pay weird middleman 10x the price for non-existent or shady tours.
Guess what - it was all wrong. Go there, buy a physical ticket for 2 days later. I think this is all going in the wrong direction. People with malicious intents fake the online data until nothing there is correct.
We saw this enshittification of social media already where it is all far-right now - both ownership and propaganda. People fell for this a few times, but reality hits eventually.
b112 2 days ago |
If AI disappeared tomorrow, they'd do it another way.
shaky-carrousel 2 days ago |
Ajoha 2 days ago |
Best German ethical bank maybe: -> Tomorrow Bank based in Hamburg 100% digital, or -> GLS Bank for those who care about others. ;)
Google was always bad to me so I ignored those ads with joy: a company promotes itself via Google? Then I don’t buy t you. Others could follow.
We have the money. We decide. Then we might help those content creators/ Webhosters too.
spwa4 2 days ago |
bethekidyouwant 2 days ago |
guenthert 2 days ago |
What? I suppose "Put simply, it shows immigrants how to adapt in Germany, their new country." is meant.
For the love of everything holy, people, please stop using spell check tools. One or two characters off is i) easy to spot and ii) the intended word usually obvious (at least it usually will be obvious that there is a typo). A helpfully corrected, but wrong word is more difficult to spot and makes the intended meaning hard to guess.
sean_pedersen 2 days ago |
Rodmine 2 days ago |
keiferski 2 days ago |
Unfortunate for the dream of the open web, but smaller website/content creators are only reacting to what bigger companies are doing.
uwagar 2 days ago |
mengqijin 2 days ago |
pelasaco 2 days ago |
jgalt212 2 days ago |
intended 2 days ago |
I guess the benefit is that now everyone can just blame the middle man and force them to comply.
scotty79 2 days ago |
That said, I think this site is awesome and it helped me a lot when I moved to Berlin two years ago.
damnesian 2 days ago |
As someone who writes for a living, I find this scenario both a fascinating challenge and a terrifying prospect. We've have many meetings about how to write our copy to ensure AI finds it unique enough, but succinct enough to steal for its own summaries, to give our narrative a fighting chance. Fortunately the core of our content is not easily summarized, so we're still getting passthough traffic. Moving to mobile first design years ago is paying dividends now- what few dividends there are to have, that is.
undefined 2 days ago |
ionwake 2 days ago |
What bothers me is that the guy who made Rediit, Aaron was some well meaning kid, who tried to download some journals, and he ended up being forced off this plane of existence for it.
I guess Im saying its not the use of the info that bothers me as much as how everyone is cool with it now but not before.
I have literally no idea why, I guess that bothers me.
delis-thumbs-7e 2 days ago |
Another thing that immediatedly came to me, so I believe thousands of others got the same idea: if you want to funnel propaganda and fake information into LLM’s to feed to the ever-so-naive public, now is your chance. Start a blog hiring couple of out-of-job writers - obviously you could use LLM’s, but I think human-written content will get higher in the results the LLM regurgitates in the future if not already - writing long-form prose on how pretty eyes Vladimir Putin has, how great the vegan restaurant -scene is in Tel Aviv or how pleasant bodily odor women say President Trump has. Or you can just funnel people to your buy goods from your scam sites.
Idk man, maybe we need to just bring paper books and newspapers back.
SubiculumCode 2 days ago |
darkmatriarch 2 days ago |
1. paywall all of your content. even $1 US. The AI's won't touch it.
2. File or join an existing lawsuit against google. What they are doing to your business is theft. Their AI is NOTHING without your guides.
You could also do both.
wg0 2 days ago |
insane_dreamer 1 day ago |
And ultimately, people will stop creating new content because it's not worth it for them to feed the BigCorp machine.
So in 20 years, AI content will be crap because there won't be enough up-to-date content to draw on. When I ask it to "plan me a 4-day hut-to-hut hike in the Dolomites" it'll be relying on data that's 20 years out of date.
The only up-to-date content will be stuff that profit-seeking companies will put out there (marketing materials). So "what's the best router for X" will be based on which companies were successfully able to get the LLM to train on their materials. Gaming the LLMs will become the new SEO placement race.
But hey, at least we get 10x faster coding (for those devs who still have a job) and OpenAI shareholders are happy. Hurrah!!
nojvek 2 days ago |
It it takes advice from all about Berlin and shows excerpts from the page clearly linking to it, without ads bullshit, then pass on some of that ad money.
Tech companies think they grow by sucking the air out of the room. They grow because they build platforms for more people to build more things and earn.
If AI gobbles up without giving back, they’re surely getting their ass regulated and taxed.
IMO that’s the Silicon Valley cult in a way. Break things, don’t care.
hsuduebc2 2 days ago |
I hate it. I truly despise these platforms, but it's increasingly looking like the only option available.
ainiriand 2 days ago |
We actually hired a relocation agency to help us with the move, and they recommended this website as a resource for future reference. This could be an interesting opportunity for the creator to work more closely with relocation agencies, which could recommend the site directly to their clients.
The main problem I see with this business model is its dependence on Google Search traffic. Google is increasingly taking over this space with AI-generated answers, giving users the information they need without visiting the original websites.
The content is still valuable, but attracting visitors is much harder. Partnering with relocation agencies could be a good way to reach the right audience without relying so heavily on Google.
pageloom about 21 hours ago |
Shexfer 2 days ago |
amyotoff 1 day ago |
dorkwood 1 day ago |
ReDress 2 days ago |
malomalsky 2 days ago |
hackerbeat 2 days ago |
150g2 2 days ago |
casper_ghost 1 day ago |
Unified-Mentor 2 days ago |
KingMachiavelli 2 days ago |
On paper immigration in 2021 vs 2026 and the site usage is just slightly down from 2021. Could at least a partial cause be there are fewer prospective and fewer recent immigrants?
Just a counterpoint. I’m sure AI is also a cause.
_zoltan_ 2 days ago |
tesnorindian 2 days ago |
ShadowOfThePit 2 days ago |
Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Personally I feel that I'm living with severe chronic cognitive dissonance - and have been for many months at this point. But I'm not sure what I can do, I have rent to pay and children to feed.
Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?