Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

DNS resolvers are the wrong place to fight piracy (https://techstackups.com)

680 points by ritzaco 2 days ago | 285 comments | View on ycombinator

qalmakka 2 days ago |

One thing that drives me nuts is that your average European Government (look at Italy or France) is absolutely open to implementing draconian laws with borderline authoritarian censorship in order to save the profits of football leagues. It's absolute madness, and it's a reflection of the corruption and how football got too big and too powerful in Europe.

There's nothing bad with football, but having it take >90% of all sport revenues and mindshare is unhealthy

bruce343434 2 days ago |

A self hosted recursive resolver fixes this. Have the courts take it up with ICANN

draygonia 2 days ago |

The only pirates I have a problem with are the ones who make money off of their sharing (charging for access, ads on their site, etc).

bemtevi 1 day ago |

The only way to fight piracy is make the paid version a better experience. Still, downloading a movie is a better experience than trying to watch it legally. Because legally you need to either sign up for a streaming service or get a DVD. Both serious pains.

For instance, if there were a site that offered movie downloads for $2-5 per movie, I'd happily pay for it. No DRM of course. Why bother? Pirates already copy all the movies anyway. Hyperion does it for music. I've bought lots of MP3s there of classical music without any problems and it's a decent price.

But for movies, the paid experience is way worse.

djha-skin 2 days ago |

This article is an AI-generated (see Pangram) rehashing of Cloudflare's article yesterday :(

MarcScott 1 day ago |

The UK has had blocks in place for well over a decade, via ISPs - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_websites_blocked_in_th...

As far as I am aware, they government has never gone after DNS resolvers other than the big 5 ISPs.

I very much doubt it has had a major impact on piracy. Anecdotally I am aware that plenty of naive teenagers put themselves at risk using 'free' VPN services to circumvent the blocks.

skrebbel 1 day ago |

Is this a ridiculous decision by the French court because the judges lack competency, or is this a defensible position, ie judges correctly interpreting a ridiculous law?

I feel like that’s two very different situations and a lot of writing about bad court decisions such as this one don’t specify which it is. The courts don’t operate in a void, they try to apply the law.

So in other words, should our ire be directed at the courts or the lawmakers here?

ketzu 2 days ago |

Seems at least the "geoblocking is enough" part should be legislated at a higher level, even if you agree that dns blocking is the right solution. Long and expensive fights in every country to get that recognized are stupid.

trentnix 2 days ago |

Every attempt to “fight piracy” that isn’t “prosecute pirates” is just a backdoor to suppressing speech a government doesn’t like.

gerdesj 1 day ago |

I think that this is turning into an issue involving a fundamental point of principle. DNS is simply a lookup service.

When you legislate to gag a lookup service, you are at the first stage of a very, very slippery slope towards a state of being that no European nation would ever want to be a part of again.

RenRenJuan 1 day ago |

Agree, totally wrong place. As far a namespace, my approach is to roll ur own. As far as piracy, not my problem, agree with those who say as I'm sure some do that the ppl concerned with piracy are for the most part ones that bought some work product and are trynna own resell rights vs the actual creators.

rileymat2 2 days ago |

One thing is not well explained, if they can’t reliably detect french users, how can they leave france?

fanwood 2 days ago |

We need to move beyond copyright

AppalachianEng 1 day ago |

It's too late to "fight piracy", the ai companies have already consumed all the ip. If you don't care to prosecute commercial piracy, why bother with private individuals?

kindkang2024 1 day ago |

Unaffordable costs for Quad9, or fighting for justice at the expense of others' deaths...

They seem to share a common pattern:

Knowing what is ‘right’, yet bringing wrongdoing forced onto others.

Better to go back to unknowing.

jMyles 2 days ago |

Every place is the wrong place to "fight piracy".

dev_l1x_be 1 day ago |

Having standards and not letting big players circumvent security measures is a good start though.

bloppe 1 day ago |

Am I the only one struggling to understand why "leaving France" is a viable legal option, but implementing a GeoIP block that applies to France only was deemed insufficient by the court? How do these situations differ legally?

undefined 1 day ago |

undefined

rsync 1 day ago |

Sigh.

This came up during the original "Les Kelly vs. Arriba Soft Corp." case in 2002[1] which was about the legality of "linking" on a web page.

The bottom line is that answering DNS queries, just like placing links on a web page, is protected speech.

If you doubt this:

It's easy to describe an (absurd) methodology of storing DNS records as human readable directions, in the form of anecdotes or sentences, which could then be parsed by a simple reader.

This is the reductio ad absurdum that I proposed in my public email exchange with Les Kelly[2] regarding the case:

"The idea that a web browser could simply read human english text descriptions of a pictures location on a web site, and then display it as if it were an inline link, is not that unbelievable."

... and the same is true with the DNS.

In 2026 it would be a trivial project to create a "DNS server" whose records were human readable, english statements and a client who could query them with similar.

After all these years, do I really have to create this ?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelly_v._Arriba_Soft_Corp.

[2] https://www.kozubik.com/published/decisions_discussion.txt

coldtea 1 day ago |

Fighting piracy is the wrong fight to begin with

NikxDa 2 days ago |

The irony of this clearly AI-written piece starting out by referencing the need for "a long-form, well-reasoned statement of why France is taking the wrong path" is amusing

dietr1ch 2 days ago |

They can follow-up by banning Google Maps so people wouldn't find their way to doing crime

undefined about 22 hours ago |

undefined

ctmlr 1 day ago |

I don't think the US cares about piracy anymore now since those laws became inconvenient for training machine learning models, looks like the EU hasn't caught on yet.

drnick1 1 day ago |

So, the conclusion seems to be, if you live in France, run Unbound on your own hardware and give the sports mafia the middle finger?

peter_d_sherman 1 day ago |

What a fascinating international legal issue!

I don't know and can't say who is right and who is wrong -- but I do know that this legal issue (which has and will have international ramifications both now and in the future) is definitely worth watching!

(Phrased another way, this problem is worthy of more research, both tech research and legal research...)

CommanderData 1 day ago |

Agreed, but this won't deter companies from pressuring Cloudflare and the likes.

I hope to one day see a system loke DHT that are almost impossible to stop

lnxg33k1 1 day ago |

All places are wrong places to fight piracy, I've been all about piracy when I was young, now I even have a season card, because I could follow my passion even when I didn't have the money to fight piracy, this year alone I've spent 2k for football, between season cards and merchandise, without considering the petrol to get to the stadium and parking, you want to fight piracy, fight piracy, alienate all the kids like I was to no follow their teams

TZubiri 1 day ago |

the “ Why DNS blocking doesn't work” section is weak, replace dns with any other service and analyze it legally or ethically

> it’s just a pointer

every person in a chain is responsible for the result, forget about the specific case, if you assume a chain of service providers constitute a crime, then a lawful order for any provider to stop is reasonable, regardless of how they contribute. Especially considering that sometimes by how the systems are designed, there’s few actors that are identifiable and servable and accountable, a DNS is all that, so it attracts court orders to stop crime.

you wouldn’t accept this excuse by its own merits for an obviously criminal matter, so why use this argument just because you might consider that the law and order is unjust?

> “other providers do it”

the last time I remember hearing this argument was in school when the teacher scolded someone, it’s almost not worth explaining this one, but you have to start somewhere.

> “others will do it”

props here because this one I did not hear in primary school, but highschool. Again forget about the specific crime that you may or may not agree with, in general does it sound like a reasonable defense or excuse? “if I didn’t do it, others would have done” weak

for some reason piracy attracts a lot of people with lack of legal training to question procedural matters on the grounds that a crime is minor. Few are prepared to consider that several countries have themselves several judges in several courts all the way up to the supreme that agree on piracy and copyright rulings, somehow freethinker867 wants to weigh in on the subject as some sort of court higher than a national supreme court on the basis not of the whole cases (which would take ages to read and understand) but on some first principle grounds that piracy is not that bad and therefore the whole system must be wrong

doctorpangloss 1 day ago |

you can take down private trackers in an afternoon, the truth is there are giant corporations that benefit from piracy too

undefined 2 days ago |

undefined

MadrasTh0rn 2 days ago |

Really disappointing situation.

nekusar 1 day ago |

Seriously, why can't I buy a textbook from India for $15 when the same sells for $200 in the USA?

Same company, but they greedy as fuck and want to use globalism to THEIR advantage, but throw a fit when us little guys try to.

shevy-java 2 days ago |

France makes everyone sad these days. Macron nuked the economy and fights the people on the street while amplifying censorship laws. The guy is the ultimate turncoat - unfortunately Le Pen will just implement ultranationalism 2.0 while appeasing dictator Putin. Meanwhile France's economy is not going forward anywhere - no real way for competition, rising debts dragging the whole Eurozone down. I think all those lobbyists that ruin a country, need to be held responsible, both with mandatory jail time (no way to pay fine to escape) as well as seizure of all illegal assets. The handwriting of what is going on is so clear.

p-e-w 2 days ago |

> In that thread, Quad9's CTO John Todd asked readers to write "a long-form, well-reasoned statement of why France is taking the wrong path", with plenty of sources, and to send it to policymakers.

I honestly can’t tell if this is a serious but hilariously misguided effort, or a deliberate attempt to fool people about what’s going on.

Judges and lawmakers didn’t do this because they misunderstood some technology issue. They did this because they got paid, or were appointed by people who got paid. They don’t give a rat’s ass about what the “correct” approach is in the opinion of tech bloggers.

If you want things to change fundamentally, you need money, leverage, or guns. Those in power have all three, and they are laughing at your attempts to educate them about what you think they should be doing. They’re not misunderstanding you. They’re not holding it wrong. This isn’t some random mistake born out of ignorance. Everything is going perfectly according to (their) plan. You’re barking up the wrong tree.

amajid012 2 days ago |

[flagged]

ReDress 1 day ago |

[dead]

curtis-sama 2 days ago |

[dead]

usernametaken29 2 days ago |

It’s insane to me that they found a legal way to prevent the distribution of copyrighted material via DNS. Why isn’t ChatGPT.com blacklisted? I can ask for a verbatim copy of any book and get it 1:1 too? Clearly piracy but somehow tolerated

CarlitosHighway 2 days ago |

John Todd, American, using the Switzerland ("The terrorist's favorite bankers / FIFA safe haven") scam not being able to offer his service to French people is supposed to make a mark? Why then does NextDNS (also based in France, and a much much better service) not cry on the Internet like American Johnny?

airza 2 days ago |

Ai dr