Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Seven new models at scalable price-performance (https://microsoft.ai)

597 points by gmays 1 day ago | 377 comments | View on ycombinator

athrowaway3z 1 day ago |

I was on the fence on jumping into the Anthropic IPO - but i think i'm going to skip it even though it's a product I actively pay to use and am happy with. Its just too overpriced.

Yes Anthropic will be leading for a while with the best model; but first the Chinese models, yesterday's OpenAI's Sol & Astra, and now even Microsoft getting Opus 5 performance. Remember that even Anthropic's own Opus 5.5 is _way_ more efficient than the models that were active in their “profitable” quarters.

I do not see a business that is going to do triple digits growth consistently to justify their valuation.

It is just too much of a fungible utility — and there is too much demand for any single approach to capture a market. Hell, AI is the perfect tool for any customer to 'uncapture' themselves.

testtestmetest 1 day ago |

I just want to learn, code on my own. I would literally take a 75% pay cut to go work at a place where llms are banned and I can use my own mind, preferably without going into defense. But I dont even care that much at this point, as long as my brain doesnt atrophy and my existance isnt being a meat proxy between the llms and management.

It feels like all the worlds most powerful companies are pushing these things on us to make us stupid and reliant. This timeline sucks so much.

We actually did significant research before llms. You cannot convince me that research and progress is getting done now, outside of like 10 companies.

Every is just using llms to cheat at their jobs and avoid tackling hard problems. I fully expect there to be a complete plateau in human progress because of these things, while its dressed up as the opposite.

Everybody is cheating on their jobs and while thinking to themselves "I bet theres some mega smart people out there using these llms to cure disease" while those super smart people are also just being lazy, cheating and letting their brains atrophy and also hoping someone else is taking the hard stuff seriously.

Gg idiocracy is coming.

johnshahbazian 1 day ago |

I didn't watch the keynote, but I've been testing MAI Code 2 and its been quite good for my usual work. They put it on par with Opus or Sol, and I wouldn't argue too much with that. Kudos to them for starting from scratch and getting it right.

ahmedfromtunis 1 day ago |

I think Microsoft should provide some of its models as open source/weight if they hope to secure any market share.

Otherwise, it's Windows Phone OS all over again.

M4R5H4LL 1 day ago |

The Ignite keynote looked so shallow and opportunistic to leadership. You wonder if they have any clout anymore, and it feels like the engineers have abandoned the ship. I am working day to day with AI Engineering, and it feels I have zero reason to do business using any of their tech stack. This clearly started with the dev division re-org, they completely missed the memo. There is zero innovation, and it is more than time for Nadella to go.

claaams 1 day ago |

Unless you're already in their ecosystem, why would someone join microsoft? They are becoming like Oracle. Their end user devices are avoided at most modern start ups, their cloud is expensive and confusing, their cloud customer support is awful as well.

theowaway213456 1 day ago |

Why are they not listed in the Artificial Analysis index?

tyingq 1 day ago |

This seems a pretty bold statement, especially the Opus 5.5 comparison.

"MAI Code 2 reaches 98% of the coding quality of GPT-6.1 Sol at about 40% of the price. And against Opus 5.5, it reaches 96% performance for just 5% of the price."

dgggh 1 day ago |

Microsoft and OpenAI are both targeting Anthropic where it hurts most: high token burn and cost. Microsoft is a bigger threat because they already have the hearts and minds of enterprise for decades.

low_tech_punk 1 day ago |

Models alone won't be enough. The GitHub Copilot usage-based pricing change really damaged the relationship with so many developers. They would need a much more enticing plan to make people switch from Claude or Codex. Or maybe, they just don't care about individual developers. B2B is all they need.

jjyycc 1 day ago |

I wonder if the cost is artificially lowered (using lower cost they set themselves for something) or if there are an objective calculation there.

abrichr 1 day ago |

I appreciated the concluding remarks at Ignite:

> Frontier transformation is intended to enable human ambition. ... We’ve given AI models far too much credit in the intelligence category. ... Intelligence means something more. Your unique ideas. ... Let’s all stay grounded on the principle that AI must do more for humanity.

reactordev 1 day ago |

It’s about time Microsoft punched back. These are actually pretty good. Not just for a niche use case either (Phi).

nickandbro 1 day ago |

I think if they announced MAI Code 2 Flash to be not just for coding , but for other applications as well, it would do a lot better considering its 65% the cost of GPT-6 Luna.

rajnathani 1 day ago |

From a business standpoint, Microsoft should ideally not choose to compete with OpenAI as they own 27% of OpenAI, and they might never gather enough capital in terms of both money and talent to be competitive with OpenAI or the other 2 big western AI players in the form of Anthropic and Google (as there’s a rule of 3 in capex heavy markets, and in the case of Google Search that it almost fully monopolized it).

At least for example Mistral has a case of sovereign AI for Europe, a niche which Microsoft cannot fill.

tintor 1 day ago |

Why are these new models not on Artificial Analysis?

npc99 1 day ago |

How am I supposed to use this if not via the more common inference servers such as OpenRouter or Bedrock? So many model companies are making this mistake nowadays thinking anyone who wants to try their model should have to sign up for some obscure proprietary API

dzonga about 20 hours ago |

models have no moat. a good enough enough model beats the "better" one.

snippet below I coped it from another comment of mine

>> my take Microsoft will be the bigger win, followed by Palantir due to Microsoft understanding how businesses small, medium & large enterprises use software. Microsoft now has its own dedicated FDE org - & for "a.i" to pay off you need a lot of FDEs - since the gains are all on the application layer. the models have become largely undifferentiated

so whether microsoft uses their own models or openai's - if their own models are good enough it doesn't matter they suck by a few percentage points against the frontier they will win.

arrsingh 1 day ago |

Lots of comments around Anthropic's moat here and how its non-existent. I bet anthropic is going to build a moat around two things:

1. brand recognition: everyone is going to simply default to using claude because thats what they know and recognize.

2. Applications for Business: Anthropic is going to go higher up the stack and build the specific apps for each business - Legal, healthcare, manufacturing, finance etc

The models will be the platform things are built on and the apps are the things that people get locked into.

drusepth 1 day ago |

Still just waiting for one of these smaller-but-good-enough models to be bundled in with the OS so I can build desktop apps on them that don't have weird charge-the-developer-the-more-users-use-it financials...

jimrandomh 1 day ago |

I can't find any reports of people having used and reviewed these models; it looks like they didn't release it to any reviewers before this public announcement. That's not a good sign for whether the real-world performance will live up to the benchmarks.

And, honestly, Microsoft is a severely toxic brand. I'm not a fan of Anthropic or OpenAI, but at least they pay lip service to safety and don't have history of consistently bad behavior going back decades.

cricketsandmops 1 day ago |

I found their transcription model to be one of the best i have used

splicebot 1 day ago |

Are there any numbers for Maia? A recruiter reached out to me for their compiler team and the hiring manager wasn't able to name anyone on the team he thought I might know based on my resume. Best he was able to do was a guy I worked with 20 years ago left their team a year ago.

It has all the markings of a classic MS project where the implicit assumption is a half-assed attack is enough, they just need to tie it to something popular.

caxco93 1 day ago |

so how do I use these exactly?

theanonymousone 1 day ago |

Happy that this time they are releasing them beyond GHCP too. Looking forward to test the flash one.

karakanb 1 day ago |

For a brief moment I was really excited that we would have a cyber-capable model at this price range coming from a legit provider, but I was disappointed to see that they won't serve that product outside of their beta product.

chriddyp 1 day ago |

Looks like they aren't on Open Router (yet). Very excited to give them a spin on my evals once they get over there.

hbarka 1 day ago |

What harness can I use which will allow this model but also be able to switch back to Anthropic or open models?

ChrisArchitect 1 day ago |

Related:

MAI Code 2 and Code 2 Flash

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50535885

undefined 1 day ago |

undefined

m3kw9 1 day ago |

If they offer it along side with opus/sol and show price/token used side by side, they could win some share. But they have to be confident it performs, otherwise people will look at it as Sol vs Luna or Opus vs Haku if it sucked.

gigel82 1 day ago |

MAI Image 2.6 Flash was about 2c / image, and it looks like 2.7 Flash is 1c / image. I used 2.6-Flash as a backup when my low cost Krea2 provider flaked out and the results were surprisingly ok (comparable with Krea2 Medium Turbo, cheapest provider cost is 0.67c / image).

At 1c it might even be a default choice, I'll definitely try it out.

gigatexal 1 day ago |

Has anyone validated these claims from Microsoft? Cuz if true wow

zkmon 1 day ago |

Given their access to data, code, hardware and research power, it's puzzling how Google and MS gave away the lead to some startups. So quickly.

nik736 1 day ago |

"Decision 1.1 is the latest decision model from Microsoft, 50x faster and 79x cheaper than GPT-6.1 Sol"... uhm okay. What a useless comparison.

seizethecheese 1 day ago |

> MAI Code 2 reaches 98% of the coding quality of GPT-6.1 Sol at about 40% of the price.

To me, this smells like the same trick I always see in claims about model routers. As in, running against a saturated benchmark then showing huge cost savings for a tiny performance drop (because almost any model will perform well).

Looking deeper, though, it looks like they are citing four benchmarks, only one of which is basically saturated (Terminal Bench 2.1).

On the other hand, on 2/4 of these benchmarks Sol 6.1 does better than Opus 5.5, which just doesn't pass the sniff test, so my conclusion is that these are cherrypicked benchmarks.

999900000999 1 day ago |

> Today, we’re taking a big step forward with MAI Licensed Weights: models under your control.

>Take a frontier MAI model, customize it using your proprietary data if you want to. Then run it securely in your own Azure environment.

Ohh Microsoft. Is it really my environment if it’s Azure ?

Anyway I wonder if GitHub Co pilot will start auto routing to these new models. All those gamed efficiency metrics sure do look impressive.

This whole article is strange. It’s as if Microsoft is seeing the Anthropic IPO and saying “um we have models too”

SillyUsername 1 day ago |

"from the company you can trust."

Well they're not wrong... if you trust them to have telemetry, take their own Github repos offline without notice or reason, exceed their Azure SLAs, and break Windows installs on a monthly cadence.

PowerElectronix 1 day ago |

A new challenger appears! Good to have a new horse in this race to the bottom. At those prices and performances microsoft seems poised to get a good chunk of the market.

abixb 1 day ago |

>This is Frontier Intelligence you can trust, from the company you can trust.

Pretty bold, after what happened last week. Race to the bottom wrt price-per-token is accelerating, and glad that large US corporations are now joining the race for frontier open source models. Look forward to open source releases from Google (Gemma has become stale now) and Meta (Llama is the skeleton in swimming pool meme).

firemelt 1 day ago |

and the crowd goes mild

andai 1 day ago |

>Security, alignment and containment are the most important priorities for agent development in 2027 and beyond.

Anyone else read John Lilly's stuff on SSI and laughed while reading that? Or at least, I imagine SSI is laughing ;)

DeathArrow 1 day ago |

>MAI Code 2 reaches 98% of the coding quality of GPT-6.1 Sol at about 40% of the price. And against Opus 5.5, it reaches 96% performance for just 5% of the price.

>MAI Code 2 Flash matches the performance of GPT-6 Luna at 65% of the price, and Haiku 5.5 at 20% of the price.

These are quiet some claims!

drewg123 1 day ago |

Amusing that this was announced 1 day before the Anthropic IPO

snthpy 1 day ago |

> Decision 1.1 is the latest decision model from Microsoft, 50x faster and 79x cheaper than GPT-6.1 Sol.

That is the dumbest comparison ever!

In other news: looking is 50x faster and takes 79x less energy than walking over and touching an object to figure out its identity.

InsidiousWombat 1 day ago |

Which one of them wrote the KB breaking printers ?

nalekberov 1 day ago |

> Built with Microsoft’s decades of proprietary data and world-class security expertise, our models help defenders stay safe in this new era where attackers have cheap and abundant offensive tools.

More like ‘decades of snooping on our users and …’.

undefined 1 day ago |

undefined

octoberfranklin 1 day ago |

Closed weights, don't care. China's still beating you.

undefined 1 day ago |

undefined

j45 1 day ago |

Is it world class because someone says so?

nozzlegear 1 day ago |

Release the weights you cowards!

durmusk 1 day ago |

Looking at the webpage, even Microsoft themselves do not believe the bs they claim.

largbae 1 day ago |

Where is Simon and the pelicans? I for one miss them! Don't make me go try all these models for myself!

ralph84 1 day ago |

"world-class" is one way to say "not-frontier"

metalliqaz 1 day ago |

is MAI a different team than the one that does Phi?

behnamoh 1 day ago |

> Decision 1.1 is the latest decision model from Microsoft, 50x faster and 79x cheaper than GPT-6.1 Sol.

No one compares decision models with Sol!

neonihil 1 day ago |

It will look like its useful. There will be business brochures about its being useful. Some sad engineers at sad megacorps will be forced to use it.

But at the end of the day: it will be what all other microsoft products turned up to be: an utter waste of time.

Spend your time on Claude, Gemini, Kimi, Trinity or even Deepseek. And thank me later.

mococa 1 day ago |

No local models? Meh...

hbarka 1 day ago |

[dead]

nhecker 1 day ago |

[dead]

leoc_dev about 19 hours ago |

[flagged]

Krea8ly about 20 hours ago |

[dead]

grd_dev 1 day ago |

[dead]

ahmedketata 1 day ago |

[dead]

undefined 1 day ago |

undefined

TutleCpt 1 day ago |

Haven't used any Microsoft technologies for over 10 years. Why is this company still in business?

gimlichgu 1 day ago |

Weak models, closed weights, no technical information