1032 points by yigitdemirag 1 day ago | 767 comments | View on ycombinator
HJain13 1 day ago |
impulser_ 1 day ago |
Is it because Anthropic put a ton more effort into the character of the model that it basically roleplays as a human and that why it tends to think better when giving tasks that it might not be trained heavily on.
I have used Carbon more than most model to try and get the same results but it just feels like i'm talking to a smart AI. Which is fine if you are asking questions, researching an idea, but if you actually want to work on something, build something, it just falls apart. Like Opus can run for days on a task and it feels like it understand what it was doing 2 days ago even when it might not be in it context while other models feel like they breakdown and get lost or falter as the task grows.
declanjackson 1 day ago |
With the frontier getting more jagged, we might see more of this 'less intelligent overall but useful for the frontier tasks'-type models, meaning picking a model will only get more difficult from here.
(FD: I work at AA)
seizethecheese 1 day ago |
Carbon has a huge problem that it's just way too slow, and outputs way too much per task (on real world tasks, it's the worst at this https://micjm.com/blog/carbon-is-that-slow/).
Without the speed issue, Carbon would be a top model already. It's top on our battle system built on opencode, if you exclude early votes: https://agentduel.com/leaderboard?excludeEarlyVotes=true, though to be fair, small sample size so far.
Conclusion is that it's looking good for Neon. Even if it suffers from similar problems as Carbon, if it's even smarter and way faster, it should be a top model, maybe the best.
Edit: I was wrong about Neon being the larger model. I made this assumption because Neon has higher scores and they're both "v4".
nicoburns 1 day ago |
bayindirh about 23 hours ago |
On that latter category, I find Gemini superior to Claude for many tasks. Of course Google has an advantage when it comes to reaching places in the internet via its index and things like YouTube, but Gemini is really more useful than people give credit for the tasks I use it for.
onlyrealcuzzo 1 day ago |
This is probably the set of benchmarks most people care about: https://www.vals.ai/comparison?m=claude-fable-5-2,cobalt-c-h...
Overall, performs just under Fable (above Astra or Sol 6.2 or Carbon - slightly ahead of Opus 5.5).
Latency is by far the best for the level of quality.
It's about 2x more expensive than Sol 6.2, but significantly better and faster. You get what you pay for.
dannyw 1 day ago |
Unfortunately, their recent change to allow me to opt out of AI training (which would also include connector data like Gmail, photos, etc) hasn’t rolled out to me yet[1]; so I won’t be upgrading my subscription; nor using the Gemini app until I can opt out.
[1]: https://arstechnica.com/ai/2026/11/google-will-let-you-opt-o...
bemtevi 1 day ago |
What I simply don't get is why people want to push the boundaries of efficiency and knowledge. I used to think as a teenager that all knowledge was good but how good is knowledge when we can't acquire wisdom with a comparable speed?
The greatest thing about the early internet and earlier science was that people shared and communicated with each other. Now they just share what they produce wihouth much humanity at all.
It seems to me that the creation of all these models has just become a race where no one really cares about the finish line and no one really understands why we're doing it, except for the short-term trail of dollar bills on the race course.
For me, each new model release is a sad day for humanity.
ByteAtATime 1 day ago |
MisterBiggs 1 day ago |
jaykru 1 day ago |
bisonbear 1 day ago |
stillpointlab 1 day ago |
I think internally, Google, Anthropic and OpenAI are thinking "It's so easy, you just use Neon for X, Carbon for Y" - but most of the world is trying to map Sol, Astra, Neon, Opus, Fable, Mythos, Carbon, Haiku, etc.
I just hope they finally land on a naming scheme they are happy with and just stick with it. But I have my doubts. Perhaps they are all benefiting from this confusion.
chriddyp 1 day ago |
Costs spread between Hydrogen ($6) < Carbon ($11) < Argon ($13) < Neon ($17) for this 43 question exam.
At a quick glance, the tone is good as well. But we do a fair bit of prompting in our harness to guide the model, so I can't say how the default model behaves.
[1] https://plotly.com/blog/gemini-4-neon-plotly-data-analytics-...
irthomasthomas 1 day ago |
numpad0 1 day ago |
01 02 ... 13 14 15 16 17 18
H He
Li Be ... B C N O F Ne
Na Mg ... Al Si P S Cl Ar
???xnx 1 day ago |
This is an underrated quality of Gemini models.
jrflo 1 day ago |
brap 1 day ago |
xd1936 1 day ago |
Google Antigravity
Entry rate limits to advanced models, including Gemini 4 Argon and Opus 5.5, in Google Antigravity, our agentic development platform
Yet, here I am, running the `agy` cli, and the model picker says "Unavailable: Gemini 4 Carbon/Argon/Hydrogen/Neon is currently available to paid Pro and Ultra subscribers". It has been this way since the release of Carbon. I guess it's "3.8 Flash" or nothing for me.
aizk 1 day ago |
mertarican 1 day ago |
undefined 1 day ago |
artdigital 1 day ago |
So Neon is the new default, and Carbon the slow deep thinking “when you need it”? A bit like how Opus 5.5 was better than Fable 5.1 in most things, but Fable still had the edge over deeper things (then 5.2 came along)
Hydrogen has already became my default for 80% of small tasks. If Neon is as fast but smarter that would honestly be very cool
hadlock about 13 hours ago |
low_tech_punk 1 day ago |
horseloverthin 1 day ago |
Johnny_Bonk 1 day ago |
undefined 1 day ago |
ponyous about 22 hours ago |
Surprisingly it hallucinates quite a lot - inventing the URLs and variables between different tool calls. Has some of the highest code error per generation I've seen this year.
I am not sure why I would use this model yet.
raincole 1 day ago |
maplet 1 day ago |
On Artificial Analysis Intelligence, it scores comparably to GPT-6.2 Sol but is significantly more expensive.
asciilore about 20 hours ago |
One 5-hour window eats roughly 25% of the weekly limit. With Claude it's only about 13–14%. On top of that, I get fewer tasks done within a 5-hour window than with Claude.
So for me it doesn't pay off, and I'm staying with Claude.
stbenjam 1 day ago |
https://bitbin.de/ramen-bench/#google%2Fgemini-4-neon%2Fxhig...
seanjhkwon about 17 hours ago |
bluegatty 1 day ago |
They all need to pick a dam naming scheme and stay with it.
s20n 1 day ago |
XCSme 1 day ago |
Gemini 4 Argin vs 6.2 Sol vs 6.2 Astra vs Fable 5.2: https://aibenchy.com/compare/google-gemini-4-neon-xhigh/open...
lanthissa 1 day ago |
That spread is my personal bs detector for models over promising.
tesnorindian 1 day ago |
agrippanux 1 day ago |
dennysora-main 1 day ago |
But I still can't understand the differences between these models.
Recently I watched Veritasium talking about helium, and I was thinking, will the effort setting of these models eventually have something like "Temperature K" to configure?
woggy 1 day ago |
abraxas 1 day ago |
mvid 1 day ago |
vektormemory 1 day ago |
Eventually all these models will have to merge into a Omni model with image/video/tts voice/text all in one.
You try keeping 600+ models in our tables updated from all the model providers; it's a part-time job every day.
tossandthrow 1 day ago |
They strike me as a good combination Og price and quality, though I do need to develop the benchmarks much more
amunozo 1 day ago |
tech-historian 1 day ago |
epsteingpt 1 day ago |
Race is getting very interesting again.
winfredleeaweso 1 day ago |
dprkh 1 day ago |
gizmodo59 1 day ago |
jonathanstrange 1 day ago |
Maybe the people at Google don't realize that but some people need constancy. If a model was good enough for some work 6 months ago, it's not suddenly becoming not good enough for the same task.
bpiroman 1 day ago |
undefined 1 day ago |
darkotic 1 day ago |
mrbungie 1 day ago |
Edit: I stand corrected, it can be used in agy.
Edit2: I have an student account and students accounts can't use these models apparently, https://discuss.ai.google.dev/t/bug-entitlement-sync-paid-go...
BoldColdHold 1 day ago |
ariwilson 1 day ago |
and why can't I use any of these with agy and a $20 plan? unlike openai and anthropic
fwee 1 day ago |
fooblaster 1 day ago |
holistio 1 day ago |
I'm curious about Neon.
pilooch 1 day ago |
andsoitis about 23 hours ago |
rishadbaniya about 22 hours ago |
DeathArrow 1 day ago |
They have a small market share compared to Anthropic and OpenAI.
I would be more tempted to try MAI Code 2, from Microsoft, since it's clearly cheaper for about the same performance.
DeathArrow 1 day ago |
moecables 1 day ago |
sergiotapia 1 day ago |
lousken 1 day ago |
BrokenCogs 1 day ago |
tonyhart7 1 day ago |
3wolf 1 day ago |
XCSme 1 day ago |
So Carbon is already deprecated, or?
EDIT: They do explain where it sits in the line-up here:
https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/models-and-research/ge...
WarmWash 1 day ago |
So now we have
(XL): Carbon/Argon Astra Fable
(L): Neon Sol Opus
(M): Hydrogen Terra Sonnet
(S): Helix(rumored) Luna Haiku
gradus_ad 1 day ago |
Can't wait to buy Puts on ANT...
xiaoyu2006 1 day ago |
projektfu about 20 hours ago |
As a casual user of AI, I have trouble deciphering any part of an announcement these days.
d_burfoot about 18 hours ago |
minimumvector 1 day ago |
On Vals's Index (https://www.vals.ai/benchmarks/vals_index), it's Fable > Neon > Sonnet > Opus > ... > Astra.
On Surge's Tuesday@Work Index (https://surgehq.ai/benchmarks), it's Neon > Fable > Astra > Opus > Sol.
Overall, it seems like Gemini is back at the frontier with Anthropic and OpenAI, and well ahead of Meta and Grok. Despite what folks were claiming a couple months ago - when after Jeff Dean and Noam Shazeer left, they were saying Gemini would never be SOTA again.
Once Anthropic and OpenAI are public, I wonder how new releases like this will affect their stock prices?
bloky 1 day ago |
comboy 1 day ago |
islemaster 1 day ago |
ncd 1 day ago |
Good lord, this is an insane flow.
andyferris about 21 hours ago |
hiddenvulkcan 1 day ago |
I do think they're very well positioned, their small models are smart and fast, and integrating well with Google is a big plus for basic use case stuff. I always like these models!
hn8726 1 day ago |
xnx 1 day ago |
WarmWash 1 day ago |
On Google's scale you could probably mint a datacenter of free compute if you could get people to stop using 10T parameter giants to vibe check their emails.
undefined 1 day ago |
firefoxd 1 day ago |
[0]: https://idiallo.com/byte-size/buying-ai-for-your-company
psidebot 1 day ago |
hendry 1 day ago |
Nevermind the 20GBP pcm I pay for YouTube.
sheepscreek about 18 hours ago |
origini 1 day ago |
And then you have big names like Hy-dro-gen haija
thisisauserid 1 day ago |
simonw 1 day ago |
Here are the others in the family: https://static.simonwillison.net/static/2026/gemini-4-pelica...
anuptalwalkar 1 day ago |
clutter55561 1 day ago |
Revanche1367 1 day ago |
cesarvarela 1 day ago |
haiku -> hydrogen
opus -> neon
fable -> carbon
No mention of Argon in that page though.
cowlevel about 22 hours ago |
ryanschneider 1 day ago |
Jorge1o1 1 day ago |
Maybe the atomic number correlates to model pricing? Nope! Neon (10) is marketed as cheaper than Carbon (14).
Maybe the atomic number correlates to overall intelligence? Nope! Neon (10) and Carbon (14) are both marketed as smarter than Argon (18).
The only thing I can think of right now is that it's in alphabetical order by release... but in that case why the periodic table?
InsideOutSanta 1 day ago |
freecodeio 1 day ago |
45sdasf45 1 day ago |
Say what you like about Apples Pro, Max and Pro Max -- at least it gives some indication of size to the average person.
wangii 1 day ago |
I am confused with the naming scheme as well, and it's a fun topic, right?
jatindavis5 1 day ago |
nkmnz 1 day ago |
kristjansson 1 day ago |
e: No, Neon is the cheaper, mid-tier between Hydrogen and Argon. So Argon/Neon are aligned along the noble gasses, and Hydrogen kinda makes sense as the weakest ... but they threw Carbon in without any consideration
dekhn 1 day ago |
donandon about 24 hours ago |
rednafi 1 day ago |
Just give them a version number and an identifier, like:
1. V5 smol 2. V5 mid 3. V5 big 4. V5 yuge
WTF are Hydrogen, Oxygen, and Nitrogen? At least OpenAI and Ant have Luna, Terra, Sol, Astra and Haiku, Sonnet, Opus, Fable. They use those consistently.
undefined 1 day ago |
sudohalt 1 day ago |
expectfun about 23 hours ago |
avazhi 1 day ago |
Maybe focus on 1 or 2 things at a time and do it right, eh?
nandanadileep29 1 day ago |
sidibe 1 day ago |
sashank_1509 1 day ago |
Luna->Terra->Sol->Astra is fine, you need to be familiar with meaning of the names but it makes sense and works.
Haiku->Sonnet->Opus->Fable/Mythos is better, more common words, more obvious understanding.
Hydrogen->Argon->Neon->Carbon (is there a Barium too somewhere? ) fck all I have no idea, people don’t even know noble gases well, but hydrogen and carbon doesn’t even fit that. 1,2,3,4 would be a better naming scheme.
inshard 1 day ago |
TacticalCoder 1 day ago |
That sounds like serious benchmaxxing for Gemini 4 Neon is ahead on 17 out of 19 benchmarks vs Opus 5.5.
Not so bad for a company that, according to HN, "has lost the AI race".
P.S: I like the Google models but a truce before the Anthropic IPO would have been nice. This is just a very big dick move a few hours ahead of Anthropic's IPO. Shall we see Anthropic launch a new model from now 'till the opening bell?
Robdel12 1 day ago |
hippycruncher22 1 day ago |
MumminTODAY about 20 hours ago |
thefourthchime about 12 hours ago |
MumminTODAY about 20 hours ago |
undefined about 20 hours ago |
mdmizanur0001 about 23 hours ago |
mrbungie 1 day ago |
jatin_builds about 20 hours ago |
ReDress about 21 hours ago |
KronisLV about 18 hours ago |
ravivarmat about 22 hours ago |
gazebo2 1 day ago |
shimanski 1 day ago |
undefined 1 day ago |
martincsweiss 1 day ago |
doyoon_123 about 16 hours ago |
Vivek-KY 1 day ago |
nthypes 1 day ago |
lawandjustice 1 day ago |
2027 january RSI is achieved. 2027 february first big scary incident (100 million people severely affected by infrastucture collapse for several days) 2027 march a fleet of rogue self replicating agents is discovered. 2027 april first severe fatal incident (1000+ people dead, most likely from a missile created using oss models). 2027 june. Deadly virus created by a terrorist organization is released in Ukraine. Remind me!
newhotelowner 1 day ago |
Gemini is not very helpful there. It just kind of gave up.
hackersnooze1 1 day ago |
So if I am getting this right?
Notes: