Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

DeepMind Employees Are Unionising (https://www.gdmunion.co.uk)

121 points by nervai 1 day ago | 83 comments | View on ycombinator

delichon about 24 hours ago |

A pacifist friend gave me a book to read to explain her point of view, Island by Aldus Huxley. It is about two islands, one a peaceful paradise and the other a martial dictatorship. She wanted to teach me the lesson of how much better it was to live on the peaceful one, and I couldn't help but agree.

But she didn't think it was relevant that in the book the martial island then easily conquers the pacifist one and destroys their way of life. I did. To me it was a lesson that "si vis pacem, para bellum".

I see her position in the demands of these tech workers. In the fullness of time it wasn't ethical for the peaceful islanders to refuse responsibility for their own defense, as it set the stage for the downfall of the society they loved, in the name of being caring people. A modern phrase for this is suicidal empathy. Short sighted works too.

If you think you live on the martial island, the ethical move is to stop helping to build their whole economy, not just their military.

awongh 1 day ago |

We have a responsibility to ensure our work is not used to harm society. - I applaud the effort, but it's hard to see this working out in reality. Google does so much business in defense that it's hard to see how a union could affect that.

People are being paid millions to switch labs, so maybe they can use their huge amount of leverage against those in Google who want to sell those big government contracts, or maybe it'll attract everyone else who doesn't want to contribute to AI for war making?

bluerooibos about 24 hours ago |

I wish this were open to non-DeepMind employees as well - we need a general tech workers' union in the UK.

jckrichabdkejdb about 22 hours ago |

[dead]

simianwords about 23 hours ago |

I have never really got the point of Unions. Instead of my manager managing me, some one else will. What's the difference? More bureaucracy

siva7 1 day ago |

This world is so bizarre. I couldn't think of a group of workers more privileged in terms of pay and perks than DeepMind employees yet this is where i'm reading about worker unions as the term shifts to be about ethical use of company products.

reallymental 1 day ago |

Yeah this is going to age like milk. Too little, too late, too diffused.

You don’t want to lose your job (a charitable way of saying this is that you can at least influence the decisions from within, a false sense of purpose), because you see the writing on the wall.

What makes you think that the management cabal is going to sit by idly? What’s your leverage? Domain knowledge? Zip. Experience/Taste? Nada.

They have all the compute. You’re planning on leveraging this by going to a competitor? Good luck trying to convince them that you’re going to work loyally with them.

Too little, too late, too diffuse. Should have started this 10 years ago, attention was all they needed.

red_admiral about 23 hours ago |

gentlerain about 24 hours ago |

Seems like some people can be too smart to read current news.

Apart from the amount of money some elites think they will extract from this new industry, it has also become a political/geopolitical/status issue.

Think about the reasons we couldn't stop mass surveillance. What's coming is along those lines.

idiotsecant about 24 hours ago |

It's so funny how the HN cohort will always see themselves as temporarily embarrassed executives rather than the workers they are. For some reason management has been very effectively pulling the wool over the eyes of the workers here, right up until the slaughter begins.