Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Germany and Austria Call for European Control of TikTok (https://www.techcentral.ie)

113 points by thm about 20 hours ago | 128 comments | View on ycombinator

myrmidon about 18 hours ago |

I firmly believe that no one should have singular control over a large fraction of feeds.

Media control is by far the easiest way to subvert democratic principles, and all the consolidation and centralization (I'm not blaming anyone for this, I consider it a direct consequence of market dynamics) has enabled a concentration of media power that was completely unthinkable int he newspaper age.

IF you really can't avoid it though, giving your local democratic government control seems the least bad option.

FinnKuhn about 20 hours ago |

The US did it with TikTok, so why shouldn't the EU also do it for TikTok, Instagram, FaceBook, etc.

la_fayette about 18 hours ago |

Social media is toxic for teenagers. Banning smartphones in Austrian schools is a good first step.

Honestly, I have never met anyone who spent hours mindlessly scrolling through social media and came away feeling that they had just had a great time.

herf about 19 hours ago |

Aside from avoiding propaganda, it's completely reasonable to want "the algorithm" to be based on local/geographic boundaries or people you might encounter in real life. Clustering people who can influence each other is often related to political boundaries, but there are many other ones as well. Social networks got this graph "for free" but TikTok is missing a strong social graph, so it's this debate is extra-important for TikTok. I think end-users and public policy should have an explicit role in picking their "community", rather than ML only.

amelius about 20 hours ago |

Meanwhile data brokers exist, and can have Chinese owners.

They should address user tracking more broadly.

vinni2 about 20 hours ago |

theplumber about 20 hours ago |

Then Facebook, YouTube and instagram. It’s time “take back control”!

bluegatty about 18 hours ago |

If the US can make the claim so can Europe.

undefined about 19 hours ago |

undefined

nonethewiser about 20 hours ago |

OK so I have no problem with the initiative.

But let's clarify something here:

>Both officials pointed to the uncertainty surrounding the Chinese government’s potential access to European user data, given ByteDance’s origins.

This is fully protected by GDPR already. In theory. In practice GDPR cannot and has not stopped it.

thiago_fm about 19 hours ago |

Do this also for Meta Platforms

Or is the EU parliment afraid of the US?

undefined about 15 hours ago |

undefined

ratelimitsteve about 20 hours ago |

given that america just extorted it from the chinese, is the idea that every political unit of sufficient size just have its own tiktok where users can be protected from that dastardly foreign propaganda and only exposed to wholesome, local, pre-approved truth?

Vivek-KY about 19 hours ago |

its banned in india

pizzao about 19 hours ago |

Great, now I can get curated American propaganda

slopinthebag about 18 hours ago |

surely people understand that if you give the EU control over social media algorithms they would use that to influence elections in favour of their preferred parties right? is that something we want?

ihsw about 20 hours ago |

[dead]

abdusco about 20 hours ago |

Is this another attempt at suppressing pro-Palestine speech?

jubilee33 about 19 hours ago |

[flagged]