Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

AI came for the coders. Understanding why tells us who's next (https://www.robertpeake.com)

48 points by speckx about 15 hours ago | 52 comments | View on ycombinator

mattkenefick about 11 hours ago |

I think it most publicly came for coders, but has been quietly taking over everyone else without them knowing it.

datadrivenangel about 13 hours ago |

AI for coders is somewhat analogous to a backhoe or automated welding machine. An operator can do a lot more work than before, but setting it up to do that work correctly and safely still takes skill.

This however will put salary pressure on the people who were simply digging holes or welding beads without being as involved in the planning and design work. Time to remember that we can't forget the business part!

drdaeman about 10 hours ago |

> there will never be a compiler that can check for bugs in your poem.

Why not? There always were and will be artists who would want to crack their art open, analyze it, understand how it works, and synthesize new art intently, engineering it. And no amount of sacralization of that air of mystery around art will stop that from happening. I’m absolutely sure there will be machines that analyze poetry, model readers/listeners (contemporary or predicted future audiences), and find “bugs” as mismatches between the intended and modeled effects.

And the art won’t be any tiniest bit less enjoyable. Well, unless present-day adtech will survive and abuse it all.

danpalmer about 10 hours ago |

Software Engineering is objectively measurable, but needs a different objective measurement (test, benchmark, etc) for each part, feature, behaviour, etc. This is part of why I don't think it's going away as a discipline, although I agree it'll change very significantly.

The areas hit hardest are going to be those where one person can specify the objective once, and then value can be delivered ongoing from that. Data labelling, categorisation, maybe things like QA. Arguably things like autonomous driving.

jimbobbam about 9 hours ago |

Great article. I agree with the sediment entirely.

Still though, we have major problems that need solving. Broken infrastructure, rising tides, deforestation, loss of bio diversity. It will take people to stop looking at the box, and start looking at the problems that need fixing.

snailcoder about 10 hours ago |

The profession so good at their job they automated themselves out of it.

moishe_syzslak about 10 hours ago |

I don't know how good this poetry major is at coding, but his writing sucks.

So much of what has been automated most of us lament, and so much of what has not been automated we begrudge.

Wut?

itaintpretty about 10 hours ago |

> Yet, as I have said before, there will never be a compiler that can check for bugs in your poem.

I’m quite tired of the code is verifiable bullshit. Of course, it compiles or not, but that’s not the same as did you produce a coherent system, with proper boundaries? Did you decompose the problem properly?

People seem to think that is somehow the easy part. But that is not verifiable at all. Proper abstractions, division of responsibilities etc is not easy and requires non-trivial amounts of knowledge on human psychology.

The clankers are still getting better at it and that stuff isn’t verifiable. Or if it is, pretty damn near everything is. How is law different, finance, etc?

They still aren’t perfect but the fact they are improving on something so intangible should scare the S out of us. Nothing is safe.

teleforce about 9 hours ago |

>I used to joke that I got my degree in poetry instead of computer engineering so that, in case this computing fad went south, I would have something to fall back on. Thanks to AI, it’s barely a joke anymore.

Ironically the author got his degree in computer engineering (CE), and work as software engineer (SWE). If his current SWE carwr went south, he should revert to his CE career. Last time I checked Nvidia, a classic computer engineering company, is the world's most valuable company. Together with Micron, another classic computer engineering company, they form an impressive 34% of US earning boom [1].

By his own article projection poet probably be next so called "victim" of AI.

>Capitalism keeps people answerable with an existential threat: if you don’t work, you don’t eat.

Perhaps it's the probably the problem with rampant capitalism, and AI is just happened to be the most recent scapegoat.

The article is really negative in its narrative and, me and many others have addressed this negative AI naratives many time at HN [2]. It becoming boring and tiring, and this one is probably one too many.

[1] Nvidia and Micron Make Up 34% of America's Earnings Boom (Oct 2026, 47 comments):

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50236073

[2] There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video] (comments section, Oct 2026, 824 comments):

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50148916

fooker about 13 hours ago |

And yet, there are more coders than ever before.