Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

The 98% Slot Machine: How Paid Advertising Became an Extraction Tax (https://globalcommercegraph.com)

265 points by dev1one1 about 14 hours ago | 144 comments | View on ycombinator

hatthew about 12 hours ago |

This analogy doesn't hold at all. Casinos are engineered for the house to win and the customer to lose because the casino is paying the customer directly. They are disincentivized to let the customer win. If the customer always won, the casino goes out of business very quickly.

Ad auctions are completely different, since they are just a marketplace. A customer's (advertiser's) win comes from a third party, and the point of the ad platform is to connect that third party to the customer. The ad platform would love to be able to make every single customer win all the time. Although, if they did that, it would create a lot more demand and even out the ROI with increased ad prices. But that's not the "evil ad platform" engineering the customers to always lose in the way casinos do, that's simply basic supply/demand economics.

COI disclaimer: My current job is a small part of an ads platform on a website you have heard of. I dislike ads but realize they are a necessity for running some parts of the internet.

hackthemack about 13 hours ago |

I use to think we lived in an enlightened age, where we have now learned that we need to use scientific reasoning and analysis to make decisions. It is what lifted us up from superstition and folk tales.

But society, still, collectively, falls for snake oil, over and over again.

This topic was talked about in 2019. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465873

Freakanomics did a great podcast about if Internet Advertising actually works. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47906485

Anyone that has an interest in the topic should listen (or read) about what Steve Tadelis did in the 2012 timeframe. He was an economics professor at the University of California, Berkeley, and then worked at eBay, where he led the famous experiment on Google ad effectiveness.

Marol about 7 hours ago |

Deranged depiction of wishful thinking. These "casinos" as you call them, can be reverse engineered, and bargained to get unbelievable margins. B/E on your ads? Make more creatives. Period. If you are getting sales but you are not profitable yet, it means that you are a few clever decisions away from succeeding. The "just one sale away" is the direct result of skill issues of the founder. The real problem would be getting zero sales or having 0.7 ROAS (which is not bad if you are running subs btw). Your market is crowded? Change the market. Internet advertising gives you one of the best way to iterate in the world. You can test a concept in literal hours instead of days or weeks it would take you to contact right people or even find them. Facebook / google does that for you.

Also regarding the last paragraph that says you should step out of the casino. Why is this mutually exclusive? You can use paid ads to get returning customers and have the paid funnels automate your customer acquisition, which gives you even more time to make your existing clients happy. Big amount of people that quit paid ads actually forget about the fact, that if you have a client, that was brought to you from paid ads would most likely never be brought to you otherwise. And if he ever comes back to you again, he won't be accounted in the panel. That break even roas might actually be way above profitable, but you just are not accounting all the returning customers that have heard about you from the ads and stayed.

It does not mean the ad platforms are perfect though. You can literally get your entire business decimated in a matter of one automated decision that brings your ad account down. And there isn't any real way to secure yourself, other than taking this into account beforehand. Which in turn requires you to become an expert in evasion tactics, which is below optimal when all you wanna do is sell your damn product.

Also don't even get me started on Kafkaesque scenarios that you can face when using these platforms.

PaulHoule about 11 hours ago |

For a long time I’ve been chewing on this…

Back in the 2000’s I was involved with numerous “social” systems before there was Facebook, the thing they all had in common was that we knew we lived or died based on being viral so the most important knob we could turn in the process was the rate at which people completed the onboarding and recommended new people. So we were obsessive about plugging leaks in our funnel from both a craftsmanship and business standpoint.

Today whether it is mobile games or anything else I’m often left wondering if there is anybody left who remembers what it takes to tune up a funnel. Now I am told that for western mobile games they aren’t even interested in players who would care what the game mechanics are but instead just want to filter for a handful of ‘whales’ who will start spending money when they encounter the slightest speed bump… but still!

Right now I trade it back to the time when Facebook discovered its business model, made virality impossible, and convinced everybody to pay for traffic. You’d think the same motivations exist there, like you can save your money or your investors’ money if you have a good onboarding process so you should but what you find is…. People don’t.

I’ve had people blame the OKR/KPI culture for this which has everybody distracted by sub optimization…. But there’s also the problem that the thing you really need to compare customer acquisition cost to is lifetime customer value. So yeah, you spend $50 to get a customer to spend $20 where your COGS is $18…. That’s the part you know about and it looks awful and you tell yourself that that LCV will be more than $2 which is true because some of those customers will come back but it’s speculative. So you think you are practicing ‘quantitative marketing’ but you are like Coca-Cola in the mid 20th century spending on every kind of advertising because you think the brand equity is worth it.

bearjaws about 12 hours ago |

I don't really think this is true, as if advertising didn't work people wouldn't use it.

That being said, there is something to be said about how extractive it has become.

It used to be you ran a TV ad, and if you made a great ad, you got amazing ROI, you were rewarded for being clever.

Now, it's all captured algorithmically, there are no "great ads", you can only have good ads or bad ads. They know full well if your ad is great then they can charge you whatever they want, inevitably making your ROI only "good enough". Sure go to another platform where the algorithm will price you out eventually.

Look at Him & Hers / Ro / GoodRx / etc. They basically take every dollar they make and throw it into advertising, it's the only way to stay relevant.

PotenRoyal about 13 hours ago |

The gambling analogy doesn’t quite hold here. Gambling is a zero sum game. Advertising is not a zero sum game. There is room for both sides to walk away with gains from trade.

steeleyespan about 13 hours ago |

An AI written article with a bad analogy

tracerbulletx about 5 hours ago |

Businesses pretty much all use ads, the number of products that organically catch on without any advertising or aggressive sales is very small. Before google and the internet it was yellow pages, and TV, and Radio. Before that it was pamphlets and town criers. If you have run a business you've most likely got an ad budget and you are responsible for managing the ROI of the campaigns, this isn't black magic.

zergrush about 6 hours ago |

I've seen some posts on X where they celebrate mobile apps making 7 digit MRR but then you look at their net profit is like only mid 5 digits after taxes and ad spend and Apple's cut.

One developer in particular shared that he was spending $580k to make $650k before taxes and app store fees and you realize that apple is double dipping, it's an insane level of taxation on the developer to take on all the risk and its gamified so that you really can't penetrate big niches without it being a spending contest.

harrisonjackson about 4 hours ago |

> As more businesses enter the auction, bid prices rise. But they don't rise to a reasonable market rate. They rise to the absolute maximum point of economic tolerance: the exact dollar amount where the advertiser is breaking even on their gross margin.

This is well put, but also dangerously wrong in many industries - especially with VC money. Depending on who you are competing with and their resources and goals... they might be willing to outspend any sort of breakeven to grow users faster - so if you try to compete with them on the assumption you'll be near break even.... just so wrong and a way to really burn some cash.

nukanse about 7 hours ago |

The article it's wrong. If your customers lose money buying from you, they go bankrupt and you lose your customers. What happens is that the resource auctioned it's scarce and the people who makes more money from it decide the price, by paying enough to secure the resource.

This is a good thing, because the resource it's given to the people that makes better use of it, and the rest complain. They blame the vendor instead of their own bad use of the resource

dzink about 12 hours ago |

Gambling, advertising, trading, and AI have one thing in common: if you don’t do well it’s your fault. You didn’t prompt right, or target the right audience, or you don’t have the right harness, and the only way to remedy is always to spend more money.

The only way to keep out of those traps is to have real metrics of your own and benchmarks of your own. Performance changes over time so you can never trust the current state will continue.

conformist about 12 hours ago |

Psychological elements aside, this sort of misses that goods and services require multiple inputs from different counterparties (or different markets) that have different pricing power (some of which might be close to monopolies). It’s implausible that whenever there is one monopoly seller anywhere that all added economic value (or more than all, as in the article??) has to go to that one.

If I have to necessarily buy ads from google and water from the local water company, where does the economic value go in equilibrium? Clearly not all to the water company and not all just to google.

noduerme about 3 hours ago |

Sorry, but if my advertising was costing anywhere close to the value of the conversions, I wouldn't use that ad channel. That'd be dumb. I understand the complaint that there are fewer natural ways to reach new customers, but any sane person would look for better methods rather than take a loss. I'm not sure who the marketing managers are that this is supposed to refer/appeal to, but evaluating the toy situation described here would cause me to drol it immediately if 2 months went by with that cost / benefit pattern.

I also don't dislike the idea behind what the website itself is pitching for small companies, I think it's an interesting model, but it doesn't address the problem they're trying to name in this post either. Yes, don't be dumb wih your ad dollars. Making arbitrary segments like companies under 100 employees is not necessarily the answer, though, it's just one metric.

anonymous344 about 2 hours ago |

very sad just look at most yt and fb ads, they are scams with near 100% product profit margin. you can't advertise a regular product anymore

vgeek about 13 hours ago |

The whole ecosystem is extractive with the goal of improving quarterly earnings by removing control from the people spending the money. Online ads started out being trackable and much higher ROI than traditional media. Then they ran traditional media out of business while continously raising their own rates (opaque quality score, nebulous targeting options) and then go even further, essentially stealing publishers' content for their own walled garden models.

baud9600 about 11 hours ago |

For a long time I’ve thought that Google ads were a tax on businesses. You have to pay it, everyone does, but the return was _what_?

JoshGG about 7 hours ago |

This is an ad for a product. Does everyone see that this is an ad ?

highfrequency about 9 hours ago |

> The ad account goes dark. Google doesn't send a condolence note. The auction algorithm doesn't skip a beat.

This is clearly AI generated, but interestingly it’s the first AI written blog post on HN I found worth reading.

jwpapi about 11 hours ago |

That’s just victimhood mentality. There are tons of examples of companies printing with ads. I’m not saying that there aren’t players that play net-negative games. And those playing hurt everyone but the advertising sellers, but the game is not fundamentally flawed.

stevage about 12 hours ago |

They do not present any data at all to support their 98% figure.

melsin0906 about 1 hour ago |

hello this is a hacker and im hacking you right now!!!!

larodi about 11 hours ago |

So glad not having to look at this damn dashboard and all its myriad of tools, interconnects and whatnots, which even claim to be able to attribute a sale to some bizarre ins and outs of the search. Of course if all cookies, tags, and pixels that you have to install beforehand work. And also validations, and confirmations, legal checks, etc, etc. It reaaally is a giant slot machine. Really, first you have to be very lucky to get an actually good connectivity of all the needed info, and then you need to see Google in its lucky day actually driving this traffic that your struggling business so much needs.

As my godfather put it once - dude, you better give $10 each customer to come and buy, rather than spend $420 to get three. It will work better.

I very much hope this all dies for good with AI, something tells me we're in for v2 where all the bullshit is injected into LLM streams, and then other local LLMs would need to adblock it. Sad story. Not the internet I got fascinated about as a kid, tempting to attribute it to age, but there was surely more awe and fun in it than this never-ending slop of irrelevancy, and I'm not even talking AI.

RicoElectrico about 14 hours ago |

There's too little discussion out there about how scammy the online advertising is. Wish there was a reckoning.

unicopter about 3 hours ago |

This totally reads as LLM written work.

> Most businesses don't crash with a bang. They just quietly run out of runway.

> The ad account goes dark. Google doesn't send a condolence note. The auction algorithm doesn't skip a beat.

This is hallmark style of the clanker and the article is filled with this.

minimaxa about 5 hours ago |

Social media platforms seem very disposable, full of bots, ads that are immediately swiped and have no value to the viewer, and AI influencer shills pushing free skills and repos from another Silicon Valley AI company.

cm2012 about 13 hours ago |

It's an auction. It's not a conspiracy.

Every marketing channel has its pros and cons. Advertising is no exception.

jongjong about 10 hours ago |

I tried social media ads years ago for my project, and it was all bots. Wasted hundreds of dollars, so I'm afraid to try again today now that there is AI.

vinyl7 about 13 hours ago |

Still blows my mind that people pay to advertise to bots. Dead internet theory and all that

sandworm101 about 13 hours ago |

I drive by an Ikea on my way to work. They just installed a video wall in view of the highway. It is huge, four stories tall and square. It gets noticed but is not intrusive. It is not animated. In daylight it just looks like a big painting. At night it isn't any brighter than the parking lot around it. Yesterday it was advertising an end table for 65$. This morning it was something with a plant in the background. I actually saw and remember that ad. I almost never see ads on websites and certainly don't remember those I do. But that Ikea wall... THAT I remember.

Online adds are a fool's errand.

zombot about 2 hours ago |

A great article that shows how dark patterns work because their victims are clueless. Opting out of critical thinking can cost you more than money.

octoberfranklin about 11 hours ago |

A slot machine knows how much income the user is receiving because the slot machine hands it to them.

But in this model, the small business's revenue stream isn't (in most case) something that the ad networks can see.

scotty79 about 11 hours ago |

Business are trees. Customers are sunlight. Advertisements are the trunks.

Incredibly wasteful and as tall as they can physically be. If trees could talk to each other and decide to limit the heights of the trunks arbitrarily there would be so much energy saved that could be put into seeds and fruit to spread the forest faster.

But the trees of course can't agree because any defector would gain advantage over the cooperating trees.

In case of the economy the government should step in and replace the whole advertising industry with a single always up to date catalog of goods and services. If comapnies couldn't get ahead by inflating marketing budgets they would be forced to compete on quality and price instead what would be beneficial for everything including the health of those companies.

syngrog66 about 7 hours ago |

its a variant on the Sucker's Game pattern. a sucker's game is where simply by choosing to play, you lose (99% of time anyway.) therefore the only "winning move" is not to play at all

scuppernong about 9 hours ago |

clicks on this

"There is a quiet tragedy - "

CMD+W

refurb about 4 hours ago |

The fatal flaw in this argument is "the bidder bids up to their gross margin".

I can't think of any business that does this. It would be absurd to spend 100% of your gross margin on advertisements. Anyone doing this should shake their head and stop.

What do most businesses do? Use ad spend to drive more customer acquisitions. A lot of businesses do it by "gut" - "wait, I spent $400 and only got one customer? this isn't worth it".

thatmf about 12 hours ago |

Won't somebody think about the founders??

hellogetkwill 19 minutes ago |

[flagged]

samratkar about 4 hours ago |

[flagged]

pathadd about 5 hours ago |

[flagged]

grd_dev about 12 hours ago |

[dead]