Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Google is pushing OEMs against GrapheneOS and bootloader unlocking (https://grapheneos.social)

349 points by mraniki about 3 hours ago | 102 comments | View on ycombinator

JumpCrisscross about 2 hours ago |

Find your state attorney general [1]. Write them a letter. Calmly and dispassionately ask that they look into this from an antitrust perspective. Include a copy of this GrapheneOS thread.

GrapheneOS, on its side, should publish a template letter for every state. They should also consider releasing evidence for Google "repeatedly reaching out to OEMs to question whether they're working with us and threaten[ing] them" [2].

[1] https://www.naag.org/find-my-ag/

[2] https://grapheneos.social/@GrapheneOS/117645917131936200

ddxv about 1 hour ago |

This was the year for me, and developer verification was the hill. I started moving all my important emails, images, etc off Google. I can't do it all or all at once, but I made a new email account and started moving things.

I bought a new phone, GrapheneOS is on it now. I started moving things there one by one.

I got a home server and started self hosting my images and my docs.

You don't need to "do it all" just do some, it feels great.

nzeid about 3 hours ago |

Keep fighting the good fight. GrapheneOS has been a breath of fresh air the past several years and I really don't want to go back to manual rooting/debloating/hardening.

paweladamczuk about 1 hour ago |

I wish they would lead with evidence and sources for the claims they're making. As it stands, it looks to me like ragebait marketing.

I support what people at GrapheneOS do but I don't appreciate their recent communication style.

acd about 2 hours ago |

Strange since Pixels allow boot loader unlocking.

"The Sherman Antitrust Act[1] (26 Stat. 209, 15 U.S.C. §§ 1–7) is a United States antitrust law which prescribes the rule of free competition among those engaged in commerce and consequently prohibits unfair monopolies. It" Source: "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Antitrust_Act"

drnick1 about 2 hours ago |

My 10a will be the last Pixel I buy if the bootloader of future editions can't be unlocked. I'll jump ship to Motorola.

dethos 26 minutes ago |

This just reinforces what many have been saying for a while. We need at least a third option [1].

[1] https://blog.ovalerio.net/archives/3359

littlecranky67 33 minutes ago |

The thread says: "FIDO2 and passkeys can also be used without Google Play. We had a workaround to make it work with Google Play and could have worked around the other stuff too but it's nice they implemented this."

What is the issue with FIDO2/Passkeys on Graphene or Android devices and why woudl it require Google services? Asking as someone who uses passkeys only via Proton Pass as a browser extension on multiple systems - why does it need deep system integration?

mzhaase about 1 hour ago |

Google should not be allowed to control android.

hod6654 about 1 hour ago |

It's incredibly unfortunate Motorola's phones won't ship with GOS pre-installed. I feel now might be the last moment to push GOS into the mainstream. In a year or two it might be too late already...

We really need to be in a place where there's enough GOS users that any restrictions will cause problems for a significant portion of Android users. For now restrictions are imposed almost exclusively by banks, but I expect the situation to get much worse, judging by Google's actions

latentsea about 2 hours ago |

Everyone should run GrapheneOS.

jaypatelani about 2 hours ago |

Best is we need Linux Phone

YuechenLi about 2 hours ago |

With LLMs, unless you use a more extreme version of Samsung style hardware fuse, there really isn't anything that Google can do to prevent bootloader unlocking from a technical standpoint since all it really takes is one bug in the kernel for the bootloader to be unlocked.

Quothling about 1 hour ago |

I guess we're going to need the EU to support right of choice on devices.

pachouli-please about 3 hours ago |

I am on Murena /e/os on a Fairphone 6+ (https://www.fairphone.com/the-fairphone-gen-6) and it has been truly liberating. I haven't rooted my handsets in a number of years now thanks to locked bootloaders and payment contracts with carriers.

Now, I have virtually no google besides what I want (maps) and even this is just an app, not a system-level something with deep tendrils via google play services.

I don't mind having lost google messages (and rcs), tap to pay, or other things like that. I don't do a ton on my phone, but thanks to this, as well as firefox, kagi, root-level ad blockers and a few other things, it is very pleasant and my battery life is tremendous.

I won't use a phone that I can't really own and exert ownership over.

trinsic2 about 2 hours ago |

All these corporations a rushing all this locked down tech to push the mass surveillance state they are going to need when enough people wake up have had enough. Eventually the bill comes due.

khriss about 3 hours ago |

Now, I'm even more motivated to install GrapheneOS, just to spite Google.

More seriously, it's an indication that GrapheneOS is large enough that Google considers it a potential threat. As the saying by Gandhi goes "First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win'.

restlessforge about 2 hours ago |

This makes me want to try GrapheneOS? Like maybe it's just general anti-competitive behavior, but part of me is whispering "what's Google so afraid of?"

Melatonic about 1 hour ago |

Hopefully those Titan chips are actually secure and Graphene looking into all these things more doesn't discover something else.....

pjmlp about 1 hour ago |

> Google is sabotaging their OEM partners by making a growing number of features and updates exclusive to Pixels.

Good luck on them, I will never buy a Pixel anyway.

DeathArrow about 2 hours ago |

What happened to don't be evil?

skeledrew about 2 hours ago |

GMS needs to be ArtCrafted.

ACCount39 about 2 hours ago |

Google's in a real hurry to lock down Android lately.

They already got once over trying to keep competing services out with their GMS agreements. Clearly, the only lesson they learned is "try harder."

I hope they get dismantled in court at least in EU for this bullshit. I'm sick and tired of vendors deciding what the users are and aren't allowed to do with their own devices.

ocdtrekkie about 1 hour ago |

Google thanks GrapheneOS for years of helping them sell Pixels to idiots who mistakenly believe Android is open or that buying from Google leads to privacy.

As per usual, once again, Google's fake openness has fooled people into wasting developer resources on doomed forks instead of developing a real competitor.

g-b-r about 2 hours ago |

This is not very detailed, there's the new threats against OEMs (I guess Motorola), but it's not clear if they also noticed new mechanisms (besides Play Integrity and pairip/automatic protection).

Pairip is being pushed to all apps though, I think four thirds of the ones I try to install have it.

It would be time for them to recognize that the Play Store and account requirements are bad things™, though.

readthenotes1 about 2 hours ago |

For some reason a poster in the thread says that things will be better in February with the Democrats.

The new Congress is sworn in on January 3rd and, as graphene rightfully pointed out, it's more of the doj issue at the moment.

Congress could try to pass more laws for this, but there's already anti-monopoly laws in the books and they're not too proficient at passing laws that don't involve renaming post offices.

karel-3d about 2 hours ago |

This is a business decision clearly.

Google is still running a business. A good business, actually.

https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/

GuestFAUniverse about 3 hours ago |

Fits with their opt-out AI training. Even in Germany.

Fuckers.

tommyfalco about 3 hours ago |

Utterly unsurprised

vinaygundeti18 about 3 hours ago |

[flagged]

OiMateOwAreYa about 1 hour ago |

[dead]

teravor about 3 hours ago |

it seems like Google learned the no good deed goes unpunished lesson. given how Apple is free to lock down their hardware by never offering any options for any alternatives in the first place, Google now wants the same considerations.