Hacker news

  • Top
  • New
  • Past
  • Ask
  • Show
  • Jobs

Epic Games Turns to AI Coding for the Unreal Engine (https://spectrum.ieee.org)

37 points by rbanffy about 3 hours ago | 34 comments | View on ycombinator

skeledrew 1 minute ago |

Yes, this is the way. ArtCraft all the things so proprietary software owners wake up and start creating value again and reduce the enshittification of their products, or become irrelevant.

vblanco 28 minutes ago |

As much as epic seems to like AI coding, they are still failing at the basics. I develop games with them, and know other devs who also do, all of us using AI extensively. None of us use the official unreal engine MCPs and similar tools, because they are simply almost useless. We all run our own, and deeply optimize the engine.

So many MCPs and others and they still dont have a good way of having text assets, which lets the AIs properly use their agentic greps to find things quickly.

The engine is also a behemoth, which causes problem due to sheer bloat that slow down the iteration cycles, and that becomes the key bottleneck. Half of my dev friends are just swapping to godot, where its a smaller and leaner engine and we can just implement whatever feature we miss, but with much faster iteration loops.

_spduchamp 22 minutes ago |

I recently spent a couple days making a music video inside Godot engine using Claude, and in the end it was a perfect implementation of the vision I had in my head, but it also gave me a weird feeling. Is it MY art? It doesn't feel right, so I tossed out the project and I'm not releasing it.

I will from now on, keep AI out of the creative pipeline. Sure, I'll use it to brute force tune biquad filters and other low level grunt work to build tools, but then put the AI away, and focus on the art of making.

Grombobulous about 1 hour ago |

Start with fixing basic problems with the engine that show up in almost every game that utilizes it.

I think the launch of GTA VI shows the value in having your own engine. I don’t believe that game would have been possible to make with Unreal in its current form, even with a small army working on it.

Sure, comparing to the most expensive piece of media of all time is a poor comparison, but it’s not just Rockstar who sees benefit from their own engines.

Rimworld just recently switched off of Unity and to their own custom engine, greatly improving performance.

Epic is right to be worried about AI eating their lunch. Why bother with a third party company when the barrier for custom engine design is falling?

ozgrakkurt 4 minutes ago |

Games built with Unreal already started to look like washed-out garbage. Hopefully this will further reduce the quality so we will see more well built games.

rob74 44 minutes ago |

> Why Buy an Engine When You Can Build One?

Maybe because you prefer to spend your tokens on building stuff that sets your game apart from others rather than on rolling your own engine?

bemtevi about 1 hour ago |

I've stopped consuming new media...pretty much anything after 2023 unless it's verifiable anti-AI. Luckily there are a LOT of games out there that are AI-free, like ROMs of old console games and stuff. It's just no longer fun to experience something that another person (or group of people) didn't make themselves.

holoduke about 1 hour ago |

As an experiment I am vibe coding a 3d engine where I try to implement things used in AAA games without ever looking at the code. The goals is to get GTA6 quality graphics. Its amazing what you can get already. But reality is that things are still very hard. For example a displacement effect like you see in a game called Crimson Desert. I think I have spend at least 1 month of max account Claude tokens. Hundreds of prompts. Still not having the desired effect. https://github.com/holoduke/vibe